Winmark Stock Is Down More Than 30% in 2026. Here’s What $1,000 Became in 10 Years

A $1,000 investment in Winmark (NASDAQ:WINA) made a decade ago would be worth $3,139.54 today, a 213.95% gain with dividends included. The catch is 2026: the shares are down 32.39% this year alone.

How a Resale Franchisor Became a Cash Machine

Winmark owns the brands, and franchisees own the stores. Its 1,398 franchised locations run Plato’s Closet, Once Upon A Child, Play It Again Sports, Style Encore, and Music Go Round. Most of Winmark’s revenue comes from royalties, which reached $21.71M in Q3, up from $20.91M a year earlier.

Because Winmark doesn’t carry store costs, the business produced $44.70M of free cash flow in FY2025. Management handed cash back through buybacks and special dividends so heavily that shareholders’ equity now stands at -$37.4M.

Why 2026 Hurt

Winmark has missed EPS estimates for five straight quarters. The worst was Q2, when it reported $2.81 against an estimate of $3.14. The stock fell from $461.40 at February’s earnings report to $283.70 in October. Much of the extra spending is going into new advertising funds. CEO Brett Heffes explained why: “For many years Winmark and our franchisees have underinvested in the marketing necessary to consistently amplify our message across North America.”

Your $1,000 Tripled but Trailed the Market

Winmark’s figures include dividends. The S&P 500 figures use the share price of SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust (NYSEARCA:SPY) only.

1-Year Return

• Initial Investment: $1,000
• Current Value: $673.40
• Total Return: -32.66%
• S&P 500 (same period): $1,120.29 (12.03%)

5-Year Return

• Initial Investment: $1,000
• Current Value: $1,231.72
• Total Return: 23.17%
• Annualized Return: 4.26%
• S&P 500 (same period): $1,602.76 (60.28%)

10-Year Return

• Initial Investment: $1,000
• Current Value: $3,139.54
• Total Return: 213.95%
• Annualized Return: 12.12%
• S&P 500 (same period): $3,507.26 (250.73%)

Even with dividends included, Winmark trailed the index over all three periods. When you bought made a big difference. Anyone who bought near February’s high took the full 2026 decline, while investors who have held for 10 years still have more than three times their money.

Dividends Did Much of the Work

Say you invested $1,000 at the November 8, 2016 close of $103.15. Since then, Winmark has paid $57.62 per share in dividends, or about $558.60 in cash on that stake. Based on the share price alone, the investment comes to $2,632.77. Large November payouts made up most of the cash, including $10.20 in 2023 and $10.96 in 2025.

The next payment is $5.02 (ex-dividend Nov. 10, payable Dec. 1). It combines a $1.02 regular dividend with a $4.00 special. At the current rate, the regular dividend comes to $4.08 a year. Winmark is also keeping more cash on hand because $60 million of debt comes due over the next 30 months.

What Has to Go Right After the Drop

Winmark’s outlook improves if the ad funds lift franchisee sales and royalties grow faster than the new spending. The outlook dims if earnings keep missing estimates and the debt payments leave less cash for buybacks and special dividends.

The bull case starts with a royalty stream that doesn’t require owning stores, plus growing demand for used goods. Winmark also has 79 franchises awarded but not yet open and over 2,800 available territories. The bear case is negative equity, slow store growth, and heavy reliance on franchisee performance.

I think this year’s drop matters more for the entry price than for the business model. Royalties still grew, and much of the profit pressure comes from marketing spending management chose to take on. Q4 royalty growth is the next figure to keep an eye on.

Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.