Dave Ramsey’s 8% Rule for a 65-Year-Old With $750,000 in an IRA and $2,600 a Month in Social Security. Here’s the Monthly Income, the Tax Bill and the Year the Money Ran Out.

Published November 15, 2026, 7:43pm ET · 5 min read

This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.

Dave Ramsey
© Dave Ramsey (BY-SA 2.0) by Gage Skidmore

Dave Ramsey says a retiree can take 8% a year out of a stock portfolio and never run out, because good mutual funds average 12%. He said it again on his show on Nov. 5: “If it’s making 12% and you pull off less than 12%, it will always be there.” For a 65-year-old with $750,000 in an IRA and $2,600 a month in Social Security, that rule promises $7,600 a month before tax. Here is what the rule pays, what the IRS takes, and what happened to the retiree who followed it starting in January 2000.

Taking 8% a year reads as a bet that the market’s average year shows up every year, and the retiree who started in 2000 shows what happens when it does not; in a long run of good years the same rule also leaves far more to spend than the 4% rule ever would.

Say you are 65, single, and retired this year with $750,000 in a traditional IRA, all of it in an S&P 500 index fund. Your Social Security is $2,600 a month, $31,200 a year. Ramsey’s rule says take 8% of the balance: $60,000 a year, or $5,000 a month. With Social Security, that is $7,600 a month coming in.

Where the 8% comes from

Ramsey’s arithmetic is simple. The stock market averages about 12% a year in his telling, inflation runs about 4%, so you spend 8% and leave 4% in the account to keep pace with prices. In 2023 he put it this way: “A million dollars should be able to create for you an eighty thousand dollar income, boys and girls, perpetually.” On a spreadsheet with a steady 12% every year, your $750,000 becomes $780,000 after year one and $1,276,462 after ten years, even as you pull out $60,000 every year.

The number that matters is 12%, every year, in order. The S&P 500 has returned 8.1% a year with dividends reinvested since the end of 1999. That average hides a decade at minus 1.0% a year (2000 through 2009) followed by 13.9% a year since. The order those years arrive in decides whether an 8% draw works.

The tax bill on $7,600 a month

The $60,000 from the IRA is ordinary income. Social Security is taxed by a formula: add your other income to half your benefit, and if the total is over $34,000 for a single filer, up to 85% of the benefit is taxable. Your combined income is $75,600, so $26,520 of your $31,200 in benefits, the full 85%, lands on your return. Adjusted gross income is $86,520.

You get the $16,100 standard deduction, plus $2,050 for being 65 or older. The new $6,000 senior deduction, in place for 2025 through 2028, shrinks by 6% of income above $75,000 for a single filer, so you lose $691 of it and keep $5,309. Deductions total $23,459, and taxable income is $63,061.

The 2026 brackets for a single filer run 10% to $12,400, 12% to $50,400 and 22% to $105,700. You are $12,661 into the 22% bracket. Federal tax comes to $8,585, about 9.4% of your gross income. You keep $82,615 a year, or $6,885 a month.

Your Medicare Part B premium stays at the standard $202.90 a month, because the surcharge line for a single filer is $109,000 of income from two years earlier and you are well under it.

The same retiree on the 4% rule

Take 4% instead and the IRA pays $30,000 a year, $2,500 a month, for $5,100 a month with Social Security. Combined income drops to $45,600, only $14,360 of your benefit is taxable, the senior deduction survives in full, and taxable income is $20,210. Federal tax is $2,177 and you keep $4,919 a month.

So the 8% rule puts $1,966 more in your pocket each month after tax than the 4% rule. That is the whole appeal, and it is real money.

Bill Bengen, who wrote the 4% rule in 1994, raised his figure to 4.7% in his 2025 book, which is $35,250 a year on your balance, or $2,938 a month. Morningstar’s December 2025 study puts the safe starting rate for a 2026 retiree at 3.9%, or $29,250 a year, $2,438 a month, for a 90% chance the money lasts 30 years.

What happened to the retiree who started in 2000

Now run the 8% rule through the actual market, using the monthly record of the oldest S&P 500 index fund with dividends reinvested. You retire at the end of 1999 with $750,000 and take $5,000 at the start of every month. Ramsey’s rule would have you raise the draw with inflation; this test does not, which makes it easier on the rule than it should be.

By the end of 2002, after the dot-com bust, you have $331,369 left. The market recovers, but $60,000 a year keeps coming out of a smaller pile, and by the end of 2007, before the financial crisis, the balance is $210,502. The end of 2008 leaves $88,562. At the bottom in February 2009 you have $63,997, 9% of what you started with. The money runs out in August 2010, 128 months in. You collected $640,000 over 10.7 years, and the next 16 years of retirement have no IRA in them at all.

The same retiree on the 4% rule, $2,500 a month from the same fund over the same years, bottoms at $251,699 in February 2009 and holds $1,310,918 today, after withdrawing $807,500. On Bengen’s 4.7%, the balance today is $460,980 after $948,812 of withdrawals.

Timing decides everything with an 8% draw. Retire at the October 2007 peak and the same $5,000 a month leaves $33,733 today. Retire at the March 2009 low and you hold $5,342,335 today after taking out $1,060,000. Nobody gets to choose which of those retirements they get.

Where the rule is weak, and where it is not

Ramsey is right that the stock market has paid well over long stretches. Left untouched from the end of 1999, that $750,000 is $6,167,709 today. The problem is withdrawals during the bad years, which sell shares at the bottom and leave fewer to recover. A test by the site Portfolio Charts ran an inflation-adjusted 8% draw from an all-stock portfolio for every retirement year since 1970: 21 of 53 start years ran out, the earliest after eight years.

The 8% rule works when the first decade is kind. It works for a retiree with a pension or a paid-off house who could cut the draw in half after a bad year. It fails for the retiree who needs every dollar of the $5,000 and gets 2000 or 2008 first.

The bottom line

On $750,000 in an IRA and $2,600 a month in Social Security, Ramsey’s 8% rule pays $7,600 a month before tax, $6,885 after a federal bill of $8,585. The 4% rule pays $5,100 before tax and $4,919 after. The retiree who took the 8% starting in 2000 was out of money by August 2010. The one who took 4% has $1,310,918 today. Pick the income you want to spend, then check it against the decade you might get.

Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.

Danielle Liverance

I've spent more than 15 years inside enterprise software, working alongside the finance, sales operations, and HR leaders who run the revenue engines at some of the largest tech companies in the country.

My day job is helping enterprise executives make smarter decisions about retention, compensation, and growth. These are the same operational levers that show up in every earnings report investors actually read. That perspective shapes my writing for 24/7 Wall St.

The headline numbers are easy. The interesting stuff is underneath: how companies make money, what executives are worried about, and what any of it means for the person checking their 401(k) on a Sunday afternoon. I write about personal finance and business as someone who has spent her career inside the rooms where these decisions get made.

All articles →