Warren Buffett’s 10-Year Rule for a 68-Year-Old With $650,000 in an IRA and $3,000 a Month in Social Security. Here’s the Monthly Income and the Tax Bill.
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
Warren Buffett has a ten-year test, and he put it in one sentence in his 1996 letter to Berkshire Hathaway shareholders: "If you aren’t willing to own a stock for ten years, don’t even think about owning it for ten minutes." In the same letter he told most investors that the best way to own stocks is "through an index fund that charges minimal fees."
He wrote that sentence about choosing a business to own. Turned around and applied to a retiree’s money, it reads this way: any dollar you will spend inside ten years is not ten-year money, and it does not belong in stocks. The limit of that reading is the price of safety: the dollars kept out of stocks lock in today’s Treasury yields and give up whatever stocks earn on them over the decade.
So here is the ten-year test applied to a common case, a scenario built for the arithmetic: a 68-year-old who retired in June, single, with $650,000 in a rollover IRA and $3,000 a month from Social Security, who wants $5,500 a month to live on. The questions are how much of the $650,000 can be in stocks, what the monthly income is, and what the IRS takes.
How much goes in stocks
Social Security covers $3,000 of the $5,500. The IRA covers the other $2,500 a month, $30,000 a year, which is 4.6% of the account in year one.
Ten years of that is $300,000. By Buffett’s test, that money fails. You will spend it before ten years are up, so it should never see a stock. The other $350,000 passes the test. You will not touch it for a decade, so it goes into a very low-cost S&P 500 index fund, the kind Buffett has named for his own family’s money. The split comes out at 54% stocks and 46% Treasuries.
Where the $300,000 goes
The $300,000 goes into a ladder of Treasury notes inside the IRA, one maturing each year for ten years. As of Wednesday the 2-year Treasury paid 4.86%, the 5-year 4.95% and the 10-year 5.10%, according to Treasury data. The 10-year first closed above 5% in September, a level it had not reached since July 2007.
Call the ladder’s blended yield about 4.9%. That is $14,700 of interest in year one, about $1,225 a month, and it stays inside the IRA untaxed until it is withdrawn. Each year one note matures and pays that year’s $30,000. The interest is the cushion: it is what pays for a raise when prices rise, and in a year when stocks fall it means the fund is never sold at the bottom.
The monthly income
Add it up and this retiree has $5,500 a month coming in, $66,000 a year, with $36,000 of it from Social Security and $30,000 from the IRA.
The portfolio earns a good share of that on its own. The ladder pays $14,700. The stock side buys about 505 shares of Vanguard’s S&P 500 ETF at Friday’s close of $693.38, and those shares paid $7.43 each in dividends over the past 12 months, a yield of 1.07%, so about $3,700 a year. Interest and dividends together come to $18,400, more than half the withdrawal, before a single share is sold.
The tax bill
The IRS decides how much of your Social Security is taxable by adding your other income to half your benefit. For this retiree that is $30,000 from the IRA plus half of $36,000, which is $48,000. That is above the $34,000 line for a single filer, so run the worksheet in IRS Publication 915 and $16,400 of the $36,000 benefit counts as income. The other $19,600 is tax free.
Total income for federal purposes is $30,000 plus $16,400, which is $46,400.
Now the deductions. For 2026 the standard deduction for a single filer is $16,100. Anyone 65 or older gets an extra $2,050. And the tax law passed in 2025 added a deduction of up to $6,000 for people 65 and older through 2028, which this retiree gets in full because income is under the $75,000 level where it starts to shrink. Those three add up to $24,150.
Taxable income is $46,400 minus $24,150, which is $22,250. The first $12,400 is taxed at 10%, which is $1,240, and the remaining $9,850 at 12%, which is $1,182. The federal bill is $2,422 for the year, call it $2,400. That is 3.7% of the $66,000 this retiree spends, and it leaves about $5,300 a month after federal tax. Most states do not tax Social Security at all.
The Roth window before 73
Born in 1958, this retiree starts required withdrawals at 73, in 2031. That leaves five years in which the IRA can be moved into a Roth a slice at a time at low rates.
Filling the rest of the 12% bracket allows a conversion of $15,200 a year. The extra federal tax on it is $3,400, an effective rate of 22.2% on the converted dollars, because every dollar converted also pulls more Social Security into the taxable column, until 81% of the benefit is taxed. Five years of that moves $76,000 into a Roth, where it grows with no required withdrawals and comes out tax free. Even with the conversion, income stays $34,480 under the $109,000 line where Medicare’s Part B premium of $202.90 a month starts to carry a surcharge.
What changes at 73
Assume the stock side earns 7% a year, well under the 15.2% the S&P 500 returned over the past ten years, the ladder keeps paying 4.9%, and the withdrawal rises 2.5% a year. By 73 the ladder has spent down to about $208,000, the fund has grown to about $491,000, and the IRA holds about $700,000.
The first required withdrawal on $700,000 is $700,000 divided by 26.5, the IRS divisor at 73, which is $26,400. By then the plan is already drawing $33,900 a year, so the required amount forces nothing extra out. The job at 73 is different: sell enough of the fund in a good year to put ten years of withdrawals back into the ladder.
Where the plan is weak
The ten-year test is a bet that the stock side will have a decade to work. The last ten years would have turned $350,000 into about $1.44 million with dividends reinvested, by the S&P 500 fund’s record from November 2016 to this week. The worst ten calendar years in the same record, the end of 1999 to the end of 2009, lost about 10% with dividends reinvested, and would have left $316,000. The ladder is what lets you wait that out without selling.
Buffett said as much in his 2017 letter: "in any upcoming day, week or even year, stocks will be riskier, far riskier, than short-term U.S. bonds. As an investor’s investment horizon lengthens, however, a diversified portfolio of U.S. equities becomes progressively less risky than bonds."
The second weakness is inflation. The $30,000 rungs are fixed, and the interest is the only raise. If prices run hot, the stock side has to refill the ladder sooner.
The third is Buffett’s own instruction for his wife’s money, which is 90% in the index fund and 10% in short-term government bonds. On $650,000 that is $65,000 in bills, about 2.2 years of this retiree’s withdrawals. That split was written for a trust that will never need the principal. For someone drawing $30,000 a year, the ten-year test is the more careful reading of the same man, and his 2017 letter holds the line that fits: "it is insane to risk what you have and need in order to obtain what you don’t need."
The bottom line
For a single 68-year-old with $650,000 in an IRA and $3,000 a month from Social Security, Buffett’s ten-year test puts $350,000 in the S&P 500 index fund and $300,000 in a Treasury ladder paying about 4.9%. The result is $5,500 a month to live on, a federal tax bill of about $2,400 a year, a $15,200 Roth conversion that fits in the 12% bracket each year until 73, and a first required withdrawal that is smaller than what the plan already pays.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.






