Comcast Yields More Than 5%, but $1,000 From Five Years Ago Is Worth About $600, Even With Dividends Reinvested
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
Think about someone who bought Comcast (NASDAQ:CMCSA | CMCSA Price Prediction) for the dividend. It’s understandable, as the checks came every quarter, and the payout rose from $0.25 in 2021 to $0.33 today. The cycle felt safe, but then they looked at the account balance. Comcast yields 5.25%, yet $1,000 invested five years ago is worth about $601 with every dividend reinvested.
A Cable Giant Squeezed in Its Core Business
Comcast built a large empire of Xfinity broadband, NBCUniversal, Peacock, theme parks and Sky. The pressure is at the center as domestic broadband lost 144K net customers in the third quarter, broadband revenue fell 4.7%, and video revenue dropped 8.7% as cord-cutting continued. On the October call, CFO Jason Armstrong said, “Competition remains intense, with particularly aggressive fiber promotions in certain markets during the quarter.”[1]
Some bright spots exist outside broadband: wireless reached 10.6 million[2] lines, and Peacock posted $261 million of Adjusted EBITDA versus a loss a year earlier.
One detail determines the math: Comcast distributed one Versant share for every 25 Comcast shares when the spin-off closed on January 2, 2026. The $601 return calculation must account for those shares along with reinvested dividends.
Your $1,000 Shrank to $601 While the Market Kept Climbing
1-Year Return
- Initial Investment: $1,000
- Current Value: $1,037
- Total Return: 3.67%
- S&P 500 (same period): $1,100 (10.03%)
5-Year Return
- Initial Investment: $1,000
- Current Value: $601
- Total Return: -39.9%
- Annualized Return: -9.7%
- S&P 500 (same period): $1,559 (55.93%)
10-Year Return
- Initial Investment: $1,000
- Current Value: $1,028
- Total Return: 2.79%
- Annualized Return: 0.3%
- S&P 500 (same period): $3,352 (235.21%)
Steady checks couldn’t offset a falling share price. The adjusted price fell from $41.93 five years ago to $25.31 today. Ten years of holding left you roughly flat while the index more than tripled. Timing still matters: shares rose 15.57% over the past month, up from a 52-week low of $20.48.
What Could Change the Math Before the Split Plays Out
The bullish case for Comcast rests on wireless and Peacock growing fast enough to offset broadband losses, and on the NBCUniversal and Sky separation, on track for mid-2027[1], creating value. At 8 times trailing earnings and 7 times forward earnings, the price assumes very little.
The bearish case centers on fiber and fixed wireless continuing to pull customers away. Buybacks stay paused through the separation, and management expects a fourth-quarter charge of over $1 billion[1].
The separation timeline is the key variable to track. If you own Comcast for income, the yield tells you what you’re paid each quarter, and total return tells you whether you’re actually getting richer. Check both before relying on the check.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.





