Trump Says the U.S. Will “Catch” China on Rare Earths Within 10 Months
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
On Tuesday, Nov. 17, 2026, on the sidelines of the ASEAN summit in Manila, President Donald Trump told reporters the U.S. is producing rare earths at a level it has never reached and will “catch them” within 10 months. He was answering a question about his message to China. He did not say how he would meet the target, what the production figures covered, or whether he meant mining, refining, or magnets.
Rare-earth stocks kept falling while he promoted U.S. production. MP Materials (NYSE:MP) closed at $34.86, down 3.41%, giving it a market cap of $6.21 billion. It then traded at $36.31 at 7:59 p.m. ET, up 4.16%.
USA Rare Earth (NASDAQ:USAR) fell 6.94% to $6.64, its lowest close since its $6.50 finish on Apr. 3, 2025. That followed a 12.62% drop on Monday, Nov. 16.
The pledge to “catch” China is stated intent. No contract, budget, or company came with it.
Trump also said Quad members (the U.S., India, Australia and Japan) reached agreements to secure critical-mineral supply chains so no single foreign supplier can force them. No deals, companies, or dollar amounts were named.
The group expressed grave concern about economic coercion, including arbitrary export restrictions, without naming China.
Sizing the Gap Layer by Layer
U.S. Geological Survey estimates put U.S. mine output at 51,000 tons in 2025, up from 45,500 tons in 2024, nearly all from Mountain Pass, California. China mined 270,000 tons of a 390,000-ton world total, so U.S. mining alone would need to grow more than fivefold to match.
Refining is where the gap broadens. The U.S. produced about 8,900 tons of refined compounds and metals, still imports 67% of what it uses, and China supplied 71% of those imports from 2021 through 2024.
In 2024, China held 60% of rare-earth magnet mining, 91% of refining, and 94% of sintered magnet production. Matching China on ore would mean little, because the ore would still need processing, where China’s lead is largest.
What MP and USA Rare Earth Actually Produce
MP’s third-quarter rare-earth oxide output fell 3% to 12,887 metric tons, but NdPr oxide rose 41% to 1,018 tons. NdPr is the magnet ingredient that drives value, so the mix matters more than total tonnage.
Revenue rose 176% to $147.7 million, yet MP lost $20.7 million as magnet start-up costs went up to $14.2 million. MP finished General Motors (NYSE:GM | GM Price Prediction) magnet qualification in Fort Worth, Texas, and expects saleable deliveries in the fourth quarter.
Under the July 10, 2025 deal, the Pentagon bought $400 million of convertible preferred stock (about 15% on conversion) and set a 10-year NdPr floor of $110 per kilogram. Buyers will take 100% of a second plant targeting about 10,000 tons a year, due for commissioning in late 2028[1]. A price floor limits how much MP can lose if prices fall, while construction timelines and the refining gap remain separate hurdles.
USA Rare Earth is at an earlier stage. Its Stillwater line has 600 tonnes[2] of annual capacity, and it used $143.7 million[3] of operating cash in the third quarter.
How China’s Export-Control Pause Threatens the Rare-Earth Premium
On Monday, Nov. 9, China extended its pause on some rare-earth export controls to Jan. 10, 2027. A thaw can reduce the premium investors pay for non-China supply, and that puts both investment cases at risk.
MP is down 31% for the year and sits 64.7% below its $98.65 record close. USA Rare Earth is down 44% and about 83% below its $38.68 peak.
Why MP Carries Less Execution Risk Than USA Rare Earth
China’s 94% share of magnet production will likely survive Trump’s timeline, and MP’s case rests on its own output, price floor, and signed buyers.
That leaves MP with less execution risk than USA Rare Earth, which is still spending more cash than it generates while it builds out capacity.
Trump meets Chinese President Xi Jinping on Thursday, Nov. 19, around the APEC summit in Shenzhen. If MP’s next earnings report shows no saleable GM magnet revenue, or if the stock closes below its $31.90 52-week low, the case for MP weakens considerably.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.






