‘Social Security Is Beyond Saving’: I’m 62 and My Brother-in-Law Says Claim $2,100 a Month Now. Here’s Why the 22% Cut He Fears Is Smaller Than the One He’s Proposing

Published November 19, 2026, 10:14pm ET · 5 min read

This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.

A middle-aged man with gray hair and glasses sits at a wooden desk, engrossed in reviewing multiple documents, one of which clearly displays 'SOCIAL SECURITY'. A laptop with a spreadsheet is open to his left, alongside a coffee mug, and a bright window illuminates the background.
An individual reviews important financial documents, including Social Security statements, a common step for those contemplating retirement or returning to work. © 24/7 Wall St.

I turned 62 in October and retired in June after 34 years at a power company. The Social Security website says I’d get $2,100 a month if I claim now, $3,000 if I wait until 67 and $3,720 at 70. My wife is 60, and her own benefit will be smaller than mine. We have $800,000 in my rollover IRA and the house is paid off.

The plan was always 67. Then this fall every story I read said the retirement trust fund runs dry in 2032, when I’ll be 68. My brother-in-law has collected since he was 62. At his kitchen table on Sunday he told me I’d be a fool to wait. “Social Security is beyond saving,” he said. “Take it now and get what you can.” I can’t stop doing the arithmetic. If I wait and the checks get cut anyway, I gave up five years of money for a promise nobody can keep. What happens to my check?

What “beyond saving” means in dollars

“Beyond saving” reads as a check that stops; on the Social Security Trustees’ own numbers it is a check that shrinks 22% in 2032, and only if the law stays as it is for six more years. Claiming at 62 to get ahead of that cut means taking a 30% cut today, and the trade pays only if you don’t reach your early 80s.

Here is where the 22% comes from. The Trustees’ 2026 report, released in June, projects that the retirement trust fund’s reserves run out in the fourth quarter of 2032. From then on the program can pay only what payroll taxes bring in, and the Trustees put that at 78% of scheduled benefits. No one has to approve that cut. It happens on its own, and the usual assumption is that it falls on everyone, including people already collecting.

For the average retired worker, the $2,170 check Social Security expects to pay in January would become $1,693. That is $477 a month, or $5,729 a year. For the average couple who both collect, $3,355 would become $2,617, a loss of $738 a month and $8,857 a year. Every figure here is in today’s dollars.

Your three checks, with the cut

Now your numbers. The cut takes the same share of every check, whenever you claimed.

Claim at Monthly check under today’s law After the cut Share of your full benefit
62 $2,100 $1,638 55%
67 $3,000 $2,340 78%
70 $3,720 $2,902 97%

Look at the last row. After the cut, the check at 70 is $98 short of the $3,000 you were planning on, and it is $802 more than you’d get at 62 before any cut at all. Waiting until 70 wins back nearly everything the cut would take.

Now look at what your brother-in-law is proposing. Claiming at 62 is a 30% cut that starts today and lasts for life. He wants you to take it to get ahead of a smaller cut that is six years away. And that later cut would still land on the smaller check. From 68 on you’d collect $1,638 a month, barely half of your full benefit.

What your brother-in-law gets right

He has one real point. Claim now and you collect 72 full checks before the fund runs short. That’s $151,200 no cut can reach, and it moves the break-even. Under today’s law, waiting until 67 pulls ahead of claiming at 62 when you’re 78 years and 8 months old. With the cut arriving at 68, that moves to 81 years and 9 months. If your health or your family history says you won’t see your early 80s, claiming now pays more.

Past that age, waiting wins by more every year. Here is the total you’d collect with the cut in place from 68, before cost-of-living raises.

Total collected by age Claim at 62 Claim at 67 Claim at 70
80 $387,072 $372,960 $348,192
85 $485,352 $513,360 $522,288
90 $583,632 $653,760 $696,384

The check your wife would live on

There’s a second person in this decision. When one spouse dies, the survivor keeps the larger of the two checks, and yours is the larger. Claim at 62 and the most your wife could collect as your widow is 82.5% of your full benefit. That is $2,475 a month, or $1,931 after the cut. Wait until 70 and she steps up to your $3,720, or $2,902 after it. The difference is $971 a month for as long as she outlives you. She is two years younger than you, so the odds favor her cashing that check last.

Where waiting is weak

Waiting has a price, and your IRA pays it. Every month you delay, the bills come out of savings. The bridge from 67 to 70 alone is 36 checks you don’t collect, or $108,000, about 14% of your $800,000. A bad market in those years means selling low to fund it.

The payable share is also a projection, and it moves. Last year’s report put the shortfall in 2033 with 77% payable. The law doesn’t say how a shortfall would be shared, so an even cut for everyone is an assumption. Congress has also changed the law before the money ran out, most recently in 1983, when the fund was a few months from empty. If it let the retirement fund draw on the disability fund, the Trustees’ date becomes 2034 and the payable share 83%. A fix could also raise taxes or trim benefits for people your age, so your numbers can still move in either direction.

What I would do

What’s coming in 2032 is a pay cut, and a plan can absorb a pay cut. Run every number at 78% and treat anything more as a raise. Then choose between 67 and 70 on your health, your wife’s and how much of a bridge the IRA can carry. If you claim at 67 and the cut arrives a year later, holding your spending where you planned it means the IRA covers $660 a month, or $7,920 a year. That’s about 1% of today’s balance.

Claim at 62 if you need the money or doubt you’ll reach your 80s. Don’t claim at 62 because of 2032. The cut your brother-in-law fears is smaller than the one he’s telling you to take.

Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.

Danielle Liverance

I've spent more than 15 years inside enterprise software, working alongside the finance, sales operations, and HR leaders who run the revenue engines at some of the largest tech companies in the country.

My day job is helping enterprise executives make smarter decisions about retention, compensation, and growth. These are the same operational levers that show up in every earnings report investors actually read. That perspective shapes my writing for 24/7 Wall St.

The headline numbers are easy. The interesting stuff is underneath: how companies make money, what executives are worried about, and what any of it means for the person checking their 401(k) on a Sunday afternoon. I write about personal finance and business as someone who has spent her career inside the rooms where these decisions get made.

All articles →