Warren Buffett’s Sister Lost $12 Million in the 1987 Crash and Ended Up $2 Million in Debt at 59. He Didn’t Pay It Off. She Later Gave Away $200 Million
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
On the morning of Monday, Oct. 19, 1987, Doris Buffett was 59 and worth more than $12 million. She was Warren Buffett’s older sister, she lived in Fredericksburg, Virginia, and her money had grown from an investment she made with her brother in the 1950s. When the damage from that day was counted, the fortune was gone and she was $2 million in debt.
The Dow Jones Industrial Average fell 508 points that day, or 22.6%, still its largest one-day percentage drop. Her story is worth retelling this weekend because the S&P 500 just fell about 9% in five days, its worst week since April 2025, and sits about 11% below its October record.
Her loss reads as a warning about collecting income by selling promises with borrowed money, which is how a crash can take more than a person has. The reading has a limit: an investor who simply owned stocks that day lost about a fifth on paper and was whole again in less than two years.
What she had been sold
Doris’s trouble came from options. A small brokerage in Falls Church, Virginia, First Potomac Securities, had sold her on writing what are called naked puts, according to “The Snowball,” Alice Schroeder’s biography of her brother. A put is a promise to buy someone else’s stock at a set price if the market falls. The seller collects a fee for making the promise, and the broker pitched those fees to Doris as steady income. “Naked” means no cash was set aside to keep the promise.
The week after the crash, The Washington Post reported that First Potomac had closed because two customers lost $6 million and could not pay $2.6 million of it. Doris Buffett, the paper reported, was said to owe the firm about $1.4 million from stock and option trades made on margin. Michael Zitz, who later wrote her biography, put her debt at $2 million. She rented rooms in her house to college students to get by.
If a broker or an adviser has ever offered you extra income from options, this is the trade to understand.
How a promise can cost more than everything
The Post noted that week that options investors had to put up only 15% of an investment’s cost. Here is what that does, with round numbers in place of hers.
Say you promise to buy $1 million of stock and put up $150,000. The market falls 22.6% in a day, as the Dow did. The stock you must buy is now worth $774,000. You have lost $226,000. The deposit is gone and you owe another $76,000.
A retiree who owned the same stock outright that morning had the same loss on paper. That retiree owed nobody and still held every share, and U.S. stocks passed their pre-crash highs less than two years later, according to the Federal Reserve’s history of the crash.
Here are both investors in 1987 and in the week that just ended:
| Owned outright | Promise with 15% down | |
|---|---|---|
| Money put up | $1,000,000 | $150,000 |
| After a 22.6% day | $774,000 in stock | Nothing, and $76,000 owed |
| After last week’s 9% drop | About $914,000 in stock | About $64,000 |
Last week’s drop took about $86,000 from each of them. For the owner, that is a bad week. For the seller of promises, it is more than half the deposit, with the market open again Monday.
What her brother did
Warren Buffett ran Berkshire Hathaway and had the money to pay her debt. He did not pay it. A 2014 profile in Outlook Business said she came through with good advice from her brother and no financial assistance. According to Schroeder, he arranged for a trust left by their father to advance her $10,000 a month, which is $120,000 a year. Their mother was harder on her. Zitz found a line in their mother’s daybook: “Don’t give Doris a cent.”
Buffett’s own stock was not spared that month. Berkshire shares fell from $4,250 to $2,675, a 37% drop he listed in his 2017 letter to shareholders beside the company’s three other big falls. He took one lesson from the list: “This table offers the strongest argument I can muster against ever using borrowed money to own stocks. There is simply no telling how far stocks can fall in a short period.”
A rough measure of what the promises cost her: $12 million at the early October price is about 2,800 Berkshire shares. At Friday’s close of $855,000 a share, that many shares would be worth about $2.4 billion.
How she came back
The second fortune came nine years later. Her mother died in 1996 and left her Berkshire shares, and at 68 Doris was rich again. She started the Sunshine Lady Foundation that year and spent the rest of her life giving money to people knocked down by bad luck: battered women, prisoners working toward an education, the mentally ill and the people who care for them. “If there was no fairy godmother for me, maybe I could be one for others,” she said.
By the time she died in 2020 at 92 she had given away more than $200 million, The New York Times reported. That is more than 16 times the fortune she lost. She told CBS News in 2009 how she wanted it to end: “I’d love that last check to bounce.”
Her brother wrote the foreword to her biography. “If you’ve created your own problems, don’t bother to call Doris,” he wrote. “If some undeserved blow has upended you, however, she will spend both her money and time to get you back on your feet.” We wrote on Nov. 17 about the $5.5 billion of Berkshire stock he had just given away himself.
What to check in your own accounts
Doris wanted what most retirees want, which is steady income. The pitch she heard is still made today, so after a week like this one, ask three questions about every account you own.
- Margin. Does the statement show a loan, listed as a margin or debit balance?
- Options. Have you, or an adviser acting for you, sold puts or calls for income? Is the full cash to honor each one sitting in the account?
- Leverage inside a fund. Does anything you hold aim for two or three times the market’s daily move?
If every answer is no, a bad week can lower your balance and it cannot take more than you have. Readers who want what Doris wanted can take income from shares they own outright, where nothing comes due in a crash. Our dividend Income List is built that way. It goes out free in The Daily Profit, our weekday email, and an Income issue this coming week will show which of its payouts held up through the selloff.
The bottom line
The 1987 crash cost people who owned their stocks outright about a fifth of their money for less than two years. It cost Doris Buffett everything she had and $2 million more, because she had sold promises on borrowed money. Her brother’s rule from that month’s fall fits in one line: nobody can tell how far stocks will fall in a short period, so never own them with borrowed money. She got a second fortune at 68 and gave it away. Most people get one, and this weekend is a good time to check yours for promises.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.







