Phillips 66 vs. Valero: Which Dividend Can Better Survive Falling Refining Margins?
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
Phillips 66 (NYSE:PSX | PSX Price Prediction) and Valero Energy (NYSE:VLO) each just reported a quarter of sharply wider refining margins, so which refiner dividend better fits an investor building a nest egg for retirement? The two companies carry almost the same market value, $93.36 billion for Phillips 66 and $93.20 billion for Valero. Both raised their payouts in 2026, and both stocks have pulled back hard. Phillips 66 fell 17.07% over the past month, and Valero fell 23.48%.
Refiners make their money on fuel margins: the gap between what crude costs and what gasoline and diesel sell for. That gap swings a lot. Phillips 66 made a realized refining margin of $38.00/bbl versus $12.48[1] a year earlier during the third quarter. Valero’s margin was $39.24/bbl versus $13.14/bbl a year earlier[2]. Margins this wide eventually narrow, so retirees need to know which payout holds up when they do.
Current Yield: Phillips 66 Pays More per Dollar Invested
The Phillips 66 quarterly dividend now stands at $1.33, or a forward annual rate of $5.32. At $239.34, that’s a yield of about 2.2%. Valero’s forward annual dividend of $4.80 on a $334.23 share price works out to about 1.4%. Because of when Valero’s payments fall, its trailing total of $3.60 understates what it pays today. Even on the fairer forward basis, Phillips 66 wins.
Dividend Safety: Valero’s Balance Sheet Is in Another League
In 2025, Phillips 66 generated $4.96 billion in operating cash flow, spent $2.23 billion on capital projects and paid $1.92 billion in dividends. Free cash flow covered the dividend about 1.4x. Valero brought in $5.83 billion, spent $796 million, and paid $1.41 billion in dividends, for roughly 3.6x coverage.
After its WRB and Lindsey acquisitions, Phillips 66 saw its debt-to-capital ratio climb to 48% from 39%[3], with total debt at $27.1 billion. Valero ended September holding $9.8 billion[4] in cash against $8.6 billion of debt, for net debt-to-capitalization of 4%. Its CFO called the dividend “a permanent commitment”[4] that the company has maintained before, as it did in 2020. That year, operating cash flow of $1.02 billion fell short of the $1.60 billion dividend.
Phillips 66 gets some cushion from its midstream and chemicals businesses, which steady earnings when refining weakens. Valero’s renewable diesel unit turned a $ 28 million loss into $ 353 million in profit, so it adds to the swings more than it smooths them. Even so, Valero’s cash pile decides this category. Valero wins.
Dividend Growth Record: Phillips 66 Raises Through the Cycle
Phillips 66 has grown its quarterly payout from $0.20 in 2012 to $1.33, and it kept raising in 2021 and 2022. It rose twice in 2026. The latest increase, from $1.27 to $1.33, is about 4.7%, and the payout is up roughly 10.8% from the $1.20 it paid a year ago. Valero kept its dividend at $0.98 from 2020 through 2022, and its one 2026 raise was 6%. Management now plans to be “more ratable on dividend growth,”[4] which means buybacks will do more of the work. Phillips 66 wins.
Verdict: Phillips 66 Is the Retiree’s Refiner
For a retiree living on dividend checks, Phillips 66 is the better fit: it offers a higher yield, faster dividend growth, and more diversified earnings. Its CEO says the company targets “returning more than 50% of net operating cash flow to shareholders”[1]. Its specific risk is debt. A 48% debt-to-capital ratio leaves less room for error if margins drop, and the shut California refineries still cost money ($27 million in the third quarter).
Valero is the better fit for retirees who care most about balance-sheet strength and total return. Its shares have gained 640.6% over 10 years, compared with 308.6% for Phillips 66. Its specific risk is concentration. With refining as its core and its other units also linked to commodity swings, its income will closely track the fuel cycle, and dividend growth will likely remain slow. Fourth-quarter margins will show how much of 2026’s windfall each company can keep.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.








