A Philadelphia bride named Nicole called The Ramsey Show with a problem most couples never address before the wedding. “I’m about to get married to my fiancé, and we’re looking over our budget because we want to be on the same page financially, and I’m realizing that he really prioritizes giving, which is something that I agree with, but it’s getting to the point where he doesn’t want to put anything in savings because he wants to trust in the Lord’s provision in our lives.” She asked how to decide what to tithe versus save, and when generosity tips into recklessness.
The stakes are concrete. A household with zero savings and a generous giving habit is one transmission, one ER copay, or one job gap away from credit card debt at 22% or 24% APR. That dollar given on Sunday becomes a finance charge by Friday. Nicole is trying to spot this trap before signing the marriage license.
The verdict: Ramsey is right, and the math agrees
Dave Ramsey praised the fiancé’s heart, then corrected the theology directly. “He just needs to fine-tune his doctrinal understanding a little bit because he’s off biblically.” He pointed to Proverbs: “In the house of the wise are stores of choice food and oil. Wise people save money.” Then the harder line: “The Bible also says that if you don’t first take care of your own household, you’re worse than an unbeliever. So when you’re generous to the point that your own household is at risk, that’s not biblical.”
And the line that punches hardest: “Don’t be an idiot and call yourself a Christian. That’s dumb. God gave you a brain, use it. And don’t blame your stupidity on Christianity. It makes those of us that use our brain that are Christians ashamed of you.” Ramsey was clear the fiancé had not crossed that line yet, but said he would revise that view if the pattern held.
Run the numbers on a household earning $6,000 a month after taxes. A 10% tithe is $600. A starter emergency fund of $1,000 (Ramsey’s Baby Step 1) takes less than two months at $500 a month. A fully funded three-month emergency fund on $5,000 of monthly expenses is $15,000. At $500 a month set aside, that goal is reachable in roughly two and a half years while still giving $600 every month. Giving and saving are not in competition.
Now run the opposite. Same household, zero savings, full giving. One $4,000 car repair lands on a 24% APR credit card. Paying $200 a month, the household carries that balance for more than two years and pays well over $1,000 in interest. Skipping savings funded a bank.
The variable that decides everything: attitude, not amount
Ramsey borrowed a Larry Burkett framing to name the real test: “The only difference in saving and hoarding is attitude. It’s not an amount. It’s why are you doing it?” A $15,000 emergency fund earmarked for medical bills, car repairs, and a job loss is stewardship. A $250,000 cash pile sitting untouched while the giver refuses to help anyone is hoarding. Same dollars, different posture.
The practical version: “We certainly have to have needs covered, and that includes saving. We don’t give away a million dollars and mom drives a ’93 Camry.” Co-host Rachel Cruze added the common-sense check: “Living at the edge of a cliff month to month probably isn’t the wisest thing overall when it comes to our levels of stress and anxiety. God gives us a brain too, Nicole.” And: “When it just doesn’t make sense, it’s okay to plug in your common sense and your reason to say, ‘Huh, that feels a little bit off.'”
What Nicole and any couple in this spot should do
- Write the budget together before the wedding. Put giving, saving, and fixed bills on the same page. If the numbers don’t add up, the disagreement is data, not drama.
- Set the starter emergency fund as a non-negotiable. $1,000 in a separate savings account, funded before any optional spending. Keep tithing while you build it.
- Define what “at risk” means in writing. Agree on the minimum cash cushion below which giving gets paused, not cancelled. Three months of essential expenses is a common floor.
- Revisit quarterly. Giving levels can rise as income and savings rise. The plan is not static.
You can be generous and prepared at the same time. Refusing to save is a budgeting choice with a bill attached.
Top Gaining Stocks
Top Losing Stocks