He Tried to Convert His RMD to a Roth at 75. The IRS Says a Required Withdrawal Can Never Go In, and Leaving It There Costs a 6% Penalty Every Year
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
A 75-year-old who converts traditional IRA money before taking that year’s required minimum distribution (RMD) runs into a Treasury rule. The RMD dollars cannot be converted. If they end up in the Roth anyway, the IRS treats them as a regular Roth contribution. Any part of that contribution above his limit is charged a 6% excise tax for every year it stays in the account. The fix is simple, but it has a deadline, and the order of steps in an RMD year matters.
Why an RMD Can Never Count as a Conversion
A conversion has to qualify as a “qualified rollover contribution”[1] under 26 U.S.C. § 408A(e)(1)(B)(i). For IRA money, that means meeting the rollover rules of Section 408(d)(3). Section 408(d)(3)(E) has the heading “Denial of rollover treatment for required distributions”[2] and says the rollover rules do not apply “to any amount to the extent such amount is required to be distributed.”
The two rules are tied together by Treasury Regulation 1.408A-4: “In order to be eligible for a conversion, an amount first must be eligible to be rolled over.”[3] It also sets an ordering rule that catches many retirees. In an RMD year, “the first dollars distributed during that year are treated as consisting of the required minimum distribution until an amount equal to the required minimum distribution for that year has been distributed”[3] (26 CFR 1.408A-4, A-6(a)).
A trustee-to-trustee transfer gets no exception. Under A-1(c), any converted amount “is treated as a distribution from the traditional IRA”[3] however the transfer is done. When RMD money lands in a Roth, A-6(c) says it is taxed as a distribution “and then contributed as a regular contribution to a Roth IRA. The amount of the required minimum distribution is not a conversion contribution.”[3]
How the 6% Tax Comes Back Every Year
Section 4973(a) charges a tax “for each taxable year”[4] equal to 6% of excess contributions, measured at the close of the year. The tax is capped at 6% of the account’s value. For Roth IRAs, Section 4973(f)(2) carries any excess forward from the prior year until distributions remove it or it is absorbed by unused regular contribution room in a later year. The regulation applies this tax to a erroneous amount to the extent it exceeds “the individual’s regular contribution limit.”[3] Regular Roth contributions are linked to compensation, so a retiree with no earned income may have little or no room.
Section 408(d)(4) provides the fix. If the contribution is withdrawn “on or before the day prescribed by law (including extensions of time) for filing”[2] that year’s return, and the net income it earned comes out with it, Section 4973(f) treats it “as an amount not contributed.”[4] The RMD itself remains taxable income.
Worked Example: A Hypothetical Retiree Named Walt
Walt is hypothetical. He turns 75 in 2026, was born in 1951, has no wages and has no after-tax basis in his IRA. For people born from January 1, 1951 through 1959, RMDs start at age 73, so 2026 is one of his RMD years. His traditional IRA held $492,000 on December 31, 2025. The Uniform Lifetime Table divisor for age 75 is 24.6.
| Step | Math | Result |
|---|---|---|
| 1. 2026 RMD | $492,000 ÷ 24.6 | $20,000 |
| 2. He converts $50,000 before taking any RMD | First $20,000 counts as the RMD | $20,000 is RMD money |
| 3. Valid conversion | $50,000 minus $20,000 | $30,000 |
| 4. Excess Roth contribution | RMD dollars with no compensation to support them | $20,000 |
| 5. Excise tax if left in for 2026 | $20,000 × 6% | $1,200 |
| 6. Left in for three years (no growth assumed) | $1,200 × 3 | $3,600 |
The full $50,000 is still taxable income for 2026, because both the RMD and the conversion count as distributions. Walt has until the due date of his 2026 return, including extensions, to remove the $20,000 plus the earnings on it. If he misses that date, he owes the 6% tax for each year until the excess is withdrawn.
Skipping the RMD Costs More
Leaving the RMD in the old account is a separate mistake with a higher penalty. Section 4974(a) levies a tax of 25%[5] on the shortfall. The rate drops to 10% if the shortfall is fixed within the correction window in Section 4974(e). The IRS can also waive the tax when the shortfall came from “reasonable error”[5] and the owner is taking steps to fix it.
A Decision Framework Before Converting in an RMD Year
- Order the steps: Figure the RMD for each IRA separately. The total can come from one or more of the IRAs. RMDs from 401(k) and 457(b) plans must come from each of those plan accounts separately. Convert only after the RMD is fully paid out.
- Count the full tax hit: Converted amounts count as income “for all purposes,”[3] including the taxable share of Social Security benefits. Adding a conversion on top of an RMD can push income into higher brackets or Medicare surcharge tiers.
- Who may benefit: Owners who have cash outside the IRA to pay the tax, who expect higher rates later, or who wish to pass tax-free money to heirs. These accounts has no RMDs while the owner is alive, but beneficiaries still face distribution rules.
- Who conversions may not suit: Owners who would cover the tax from the IRA itself, who need the money for living costs soon, who expect lower tax rates later, or whose heirs are in lower brackets.
Two more points are worth tracking. Final RMD regulations may still change the details: Announcement 2026-7 says some upcoming rules will apply for the distribution calendar year that begins no earlier than 6 months after the final regulations are issued in the Federal Register. Separately, people born in 1960 or later start RMDs at age 75, which gives them more years to convert before RMDs begin (those low-tax years between a last paycheck and a first required withdrawal are what we cover in our free Roth Window guide).
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.








