Why Retirees Leaving New York for Florida Convert to a Roth After the Closing, and Keep the Receipts to Prove Where They Lived That Day
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
New York is the biggest source of income moving into Florida. In the IRS migration data for 2022-2023, 43,187 returns[1] covering 71,476 individuals moved from New York to Florida, bringing $5,753,306,000 in adjusted gross income with them. That made New York Florida’s top origin state by AGI. For retirees holding traditional IRAs, the move opens a narrow planning window. The date of a Roth conversion can decide whether New York gets to tax it at all.
Why the Conversion Date Decides Which State Can Tax It
Treasury treats any converted amount as a distribution from the traditional IRA and a qualified rollover contribution to the Roth IRA[2] (26 CFR 1.408A-4, A-1(c)). That amount is included in gross income for the taxable year in which the amount is distributed or transferred from the traditional IRA[2] (A-7), which matches the income-inclusion rule in 26 U.S.C. § 408A(d)(3)(A)(i)[3].
New York splits the year of a move in two. A part-year resident’s New York income is the state’s adjusted gross income for the period of residence, plus New York source income for the period of nonresidence (N.Y. Tax Law § 638(a)). A conversion dated after residency ends falls in the nonresident half.
Be careful with timing, though. Section 639(a) requires a leaving resident to assign to the resident period any income items accruing prior to the change of status. If you start a conversion in New York and it settles after the move, you risk a dispute. Start and finish the whole transaction after the change.
Paperwork That Proves You Had Left New York
New York uses two residency tests. A domiciliary stays a resident unless they keep no permanent home in New York, keep one elsewhere, and spend not more than thirty days[4] of the year in the state (§ 605(b)(1)(A)). Separately, anyone who keeps a permanent home in New York and spends more than one hundred eighty-three days[4] there is a statutory resident whether or not domiciled in this state (§ 605(b)(1)(B)).
Florida law assumes an existing permanent residence is presumed to continue until the person shows that a change has occurred (Fla. Stat. § 196.012(17)). That is why the closing matters. It is the clearest dated record of the switch. Keep the following:
- The Florida closing statement and the recorded deed
- The sale or lease-termination papers for the New York home
- Your Florida driver’s license, voter registration and homestead filing
- A day-count log supported by card statements and phone location history
- The custodian’s conversion confirmation and Form 1099-R showing the transaction date
Federal Rules Still Apply After the Move
Moving to Florida changes your state tax, but the federal conversion rules stay the same. You cannot convert amounts that must be distributed for the year, including the calendar year in which you reach age 73, and the first dollars out in an RMD year count toward the RMD (26 CFR 1.408A-4, A-6[2]). Conversions made after 2017 can’t be recharacterized, so you cannot undo one. Under the aggregation rule in §408(d)(2), all of your individual retirement plans are treated as one contract valued as of the close of the calendar year to figure the taxable part of the conversion, and Form 8606 reports the result.
Hypothetical: How One Conversion Raises Medicare Premiums
The Hendersons are a hypothetical married couple. Both are on Medicare, they file jointly, and their modified AGI is $150,000. After their Florida closing they convert $100,000.
- Income: $150,000 + $100,000 = $250,000.
- In the 2026 Medicare table, joint income over $218,000 through $274,000[5] adds $81.20 a month to Part B, for a total of $284.10 versus the $202.90 standard premium.
- $81.20 × 12 = $974.40 per person, × 2 = $1,948.80.
- The Part D add-on is $14.50[5] a month: $14.50 × 12 × 2 = $348.
- Total: $1,948.80 + $348 = $2,296.80 in added premiums for the year the surcharge applies.
Medicare sets these surcharges using income from an earlier tax return, so the extra cost shows up later. Conversion income also counts for purposes of determining the taxable portion of social security payments[2] (A-9). On the federal side, the 2025 joint 24% bracket covered taxable income from $206,701 to $394,600. The years between the last paycheck and the first RMD are often the cheapest time to convert, which is the whole subject of our free Roth window guide: here.
Who Should Skip the Post-Closing Conversion
Converting after the closing tends to fit retirees who have fully cut their New York ties, can pay the tax from cash outside the IRA, and expect higher brackets later or want to leave money to heirs. Owners of Roth IRAs get no lifetime RMDs, but beneficiaries are still subject to RMD rules. It fits these households less:
- Snowbirds who keep a New York apartment and could pass the 183-day test
- Couples whose income sits just below a Medicare surcharge tier
- People who would pay the tax out of the IRA itself
- Retirees who will need those funds soon
Year-End Checks Before You Act
A conversion counts toward the tax year in which the funds leave your old account, so year-end timing matters. Before you act, confirm your day count and take any required RMD first. Ask your custodian when the transfer will settle. Save every record from the move in one file, because New York may later ask you to prove when you left.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.







