Why Retirees in Pennsylvania and Illinois Convert to a Roth Before They Move to the Carolinas, Not After. Both States Tax a Paycheck and Charge $0 on the Conversion
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
Retirees who leave Pennsylvania or Illinois for North Carolina or South Carolina face a timing question on Roth conversions. Both home states tax wages, yet both keep retirement account payouts out of their income tax. That includes income from converting to a Roth. Once a household is domiciled in the Carolinas, the same conversion becomes state-taxable income. The order of conversion and move decides whether the state takes a cut.
Plenty of households make this move. IRS migration data for 2022-2023[1] shows 7,061 Pennsylvania returns moving to North Carolina and 4,214 moving to South Carolina. Illinois sent 3,731[1] returns to North Carolina and 2,024 to South Carolina. South Carolina ranked 3[1] and North Carolina 4 nationally for net AGI made. Pennsylvania ranked 46[1] and Illinois 49.
How the Federal Conversion Tax Works in Any State
Taxes on a conversion fall in the year it happens. Under 26 U.S.C. § 408A(d)(3)(A)(i)[2], gross income includes amounts converted that would have been taxable as a regular distribution. Under § 408A(d)(3)(A)(ii)[2], the early-distribution penalty in section 72(t) does not apply to the conversion. The IRS says conversion amounts are “normally included in income on your return for the year that you converted them”, and you report them on Form 8606. The conversion rules are laid out in Treasury Regulation 1.408A-4.
If you have made nondeductible contributions, the pro-rata rule applies. 26 U.S.C. § 408(d)(2)[3] treats all of your IRAs as one contract and all distributions in a year as one distribution, with values measured at the close of the calendar year. Required minimum distributions come first. The IRS says you cannot convert amounts that must be distributed for a year, “including the calendar year in which you reach age 73”.
Why Pennsylvania and Illinois Charge $0 on the Conversion
Illinois. Illinois starts with federal adjusted gross income, so wages are taxed (35 ILCS 5/203(a)(1)[4]). It then deducts amounts included in income under several federal retirement provisions, including Section 408 of the Internal Revenue Code[4], which covers IRAs (35 ILCS 5/203(a)(2)(F)). A conversion comes out of a traditional account, so it gets the same deduction.
Pennsylvania. Pennsylvania taxes wages as gross compensation on Line 1a of Form PA-40. State law excludes retirement benefits from personal income tax. Department of Revenue guidance says “most of the personal income tax rules that apply to individual retirement accounts” also apply to Roth IRAs. It has separate reporting for distributions taken before reaching 59 1/2. Pennsylvania residents younger than that should check with a preparer before they convert.
What Changes After the Moving Truck Arrives
North Carolina generally taxes IRA payouts. Its main exception, under the Bailey settlement, covers certain government retirement accounts in which the retiree was “vested” as of August 12, 1989[5]. South Carolina offers a deduction for qualifying retirement income, but the deduction is capped. Converting a large amount can push well past that cap.
Residency is set by legal residence. Illinois defines it as the place where you live and “intend to return after temporary absences”. In the year you move, Illinois treats income from your resident months as Illinois income (35 ILCS 5/301(b)[6]). That makes it practical to convert before you establish a Carolina domicile.
Hypothetical Household: Running the Numbers
Consider a hypothetical Illinois couple filing jointly, with $150,000 of modified adjusted gross income, who plan a $100,000 conversion.
- State tax before the move: Illinois deducts the conversion, so the state cost is $0.
- State tax after the move: Each 1 percentage point of Carolina tax costs $100,000 × 1% = $1,000.
- Medicare income: $150,000 + $100,000 = $250,000. That falls in the 2026 joint tier of over $218,000 through $274,000[7], which adds $81.20 a month to Part B.
- Annual Part B surcharge: $81.20 × 12 = $974.40 per person. For two enrollees, $974.40 × 2 = $1,948.80. Part D adds another $14.50[7] a month each.
The federal tax is the same no matter which state you live in. The move changes only the state layer.
A Decision Framework to Use Before Closing Day
- Compare future and current federal brackets. Saving on state tax does not help much if the federal bracket you pay now is higher than the one you expect later.
- Map the Medicare tiers. For 2026, Part B surcharges start over $218,000[7] for joint filers and over $109,000 for single filers.
- Fund the tax from cash. Paying the tax from the account reduces the amount that grows tax-free.
- Consider the legacy goal. Roth IRAs have no RMDs for a living owner, but “RMD rules do apply to the beneficiaries”.
Retirees who would pay the tax from the IRA, households just below a Medicare tier, people who plan to leave the IRA to charity, and Pennsylvania residents under 59½ whose state treatment is unclear are a poor fit for conversions. For these groups, the state tax savings usually don’t cover the added costs. For everyone else, the quiet years before the first RMD are often the cheapest window a saver ever finds, which is the whole subject of our free Roth conversion guide.
What to Watch Before Your Next Conversion
RMD rules are still changing. Treasury’s proposed RMD regulations (REG-103529-23) are still open. Treasury and the IRS anticipate certain parts of the final rules will apply for the distribution calendar year that begins no earlier than 6 months after the final rules are issued. Social Security’s 3.6% COLA for 2027 also raises base income, which leaves less room for conversions below the Medicare tiers. Conversions count in the calendar year they happen, so any move-year conversion needs to be done before your legal residence changes.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.







