A Single Retiree With a $2 Million IRA Lands $500 Over Medicare’s Surcharge Line and Pays About $1,150 for It. Changing How She Writes One Check to Her Church Puts Her Back Under, and Here’s the December Move Advisors Make First
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
Picture a single 73-year-old retiree with $2 million in a traditional IRA. She gives to her church, files on time and takes no wild risks. Medicare still bills her as a high earner this year, because her income went over a line by $500.
She can fix it for free. She makes the same gift to the same church but sends it from a different account. Below is the math, plus the December check that determines whether the fix works.
How $500 Over the Line Turns Into a $1,148 Medicare Bill
For 2026[1], the standard Medicare Part B premium is $202.90 a month. Single filers whose modified adjusted gross income (MAGI) is over $109,000 also pay a surcharge called IRMAA, short for income-related monthly adjustment amount.
Social Security sets that surcharge from your federal tax return submitted two years prior. On the return Medicare used, our retiree’s MAGI was $109,500. That moved her Part B premium from $202.90 to $284.10 a month, and her Part D drug coverage picked up another $14.50 a month.
Over 12 months, the two surcharges add up to $1,148.40. IRMAA works like a cliff: going $1 over a level raises your premium for the whole year. An appeal on Form SSA-44 won’t help here. That form covers life-changing events such as marriage, divorce, the death of a spouse, loss of income[2], and a church gift doesn’t count as one.
IRMAA is one of several Medicare costs linked to income from two years ago, and we mapped out the full set of surcharges and coverage gaps in a free guide to Medicare’s hidden bills.
Her Income Stack, Line by Line
At 73, her divisor on the IRS Uniform Lifetime Table is 26.5. Dividing $2 million by 26.5 gives a required minimum distribution (RMD) of about $75,472. Assume she also collects $36,000 a year from Social Security and earns some bank interest.
| Income source | Counts toward MAGI |
|---|---|
| IRA required minimum distribution | $75,472 |
| Taxable Social Security (85% of $36,000) | $30,600 |
| Bank interest | $3,428 |
| Total MAGI | $109,500 |
With income this high, the maximum 85% of her benefits is taxable. She writes her $6,000 church gift from checking, and that check does nothing to her MAGI. Itemized deductions come off after adjusted gross income is figured. Besides, with the 2026 standard deduction for single filers at $16,100 plus the extra amount for anyone 65 or older, she most likely doesn’t itemize.
Qualified Charitable Distributions Take the Gift Off Her Tax Return
One solution is a qualified charitable distribution, or QCD. Under 26 U.S.C. § 408(d)(8), IRS Publication 590-B defines it as “generally a nontaxable distribution made directly by the trustee of your IRA” to an eligible charity. You have to be at least 70½, and for 2026 the cap is $111,000.
A QCD will count towards your required minimum distribution, and the money never appears in her income. Say her custodian sends $6,000 of her RMD directly to the church. Her MAGI then drops to $103,500, which is safely under $109,000.
She also stops owing federal income tax on that $6,000. In 2026 the 22% bracket starts at single taxable income over $50,400, so the QCD saves her $1,179.20. Add the surcharge she avoids, and the same gift is worth about $2,328 a year. The catch is that you can’t claim a charitable contribution deduction for a QCD, which costs her the deduction of up to $1,000 that non-itemizers can claim for cash gifts to charity starting in 2026. State savings depend on whether your state taxes IRA withdrawals.
Why Advisors Check the Remaining RMD First in December
Timing matters. If she has already taken her full RMD in cash, a December QCD can’t take that income back off her return. The QCD would be tax-free, but her MAGI would stay at $109,500.
So the first December step is to ask the custodian how much of her 2026 RMD she hasn’t taken yet. If at least $6,000 is left, she sends that much to the church as a QCD and takes the rest the usual way.
Then mind the calendar. Many custodians stop taking QCD requests in mid-December. They also warn that when a QCD is paid by check, it may count only when the church cashes it. Missing the RMD completely costs more: the excise tax is 25% of the shortfall, or 10% if she fixes it within the correction window.
Her 2026 return will set the premium she pays in 2028. IRMAA level rise with inflation, so the 2028 line will probably be a little higher. Still, a $5,500 buffer is safer than hoping inflation covers a $500 shortfall.
Who Gains Most From Changing How the Church Gets Paid
This move pays off most for people who are 70½ or older, give to charity regularly, take the standard deduction and sit within a few thousand dollars of an IRMAA level. Married couples filing jointly have their own lines, beginning at $218,000.
If you’re close to a level, run the numbers with a CPA or fiduciary advisor before your custodian’s December cutoff, while you can still change which account pays the church.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.







