A 64-Year-Old Turned Down a $595,000 Annuity and Bought Dividends Instead. Here’s What Happened to His $3,025 Monthly Paycheck
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
He was 64, and the annuity offer was simple. He could hand over $595,000 and get a monthly check for the rest of his life. The catch was that he couldn’t undo it. Once he signed, the money belonged to the insurance company.
He turned it down and instead put the same money into six income holdings with a blended yield of 6.4%. The result is approximately $38,169 a year, or $3,181 a month on average. If you’re considering the same offer, his choice makes a useful test case.
What He Traded Away for Control
An annuity sells certainty, and the check keeps coming if he lives to 100, and the insurer’s claims-paying ability backs it up. That’s real protection against the fear of running out, but he also wanted something else. He wanted to keep the principal, leave it to his heirs, and have a check that could grow (we wrote about building a dividend ladder that pays for life without ever selling a share: here). In exchange, he took on two risks: companies can cut dividends, and prices can fall.
How Much Money Replaces $3,181 a Month
The math is income divided by yield:
- In the conservative band (3% to 4%), $38,169 divided by 0.035 is roughly $1,091,000. Dividend growth stocks and broad dividend funds fill this level. It’s the easiest one to sleep on, and it takes the most capital.
- In the moderate band (5% to 7%), $38,169 divided by 0.06 is roughly $636,000. Real estate investment trusts (REITs), preferreds, and covered call funds fill this level. It’s where he ended up. Dividend growth slows here.
- In the high band (8% to 14%), $38,169 divided by 0.10 is roughly $382,000. Business development companies (BDCs), mortgage REITs, and leveraged option funds make up this level. You often give up principal to get that income.
What Each Holding Does in His Paycheck
- iShares U.S. Large Cap Premium Income Active ETF (CBOE:BALI), 25%: The fund sells options on large U.S. stocks and pays out the premiums monthly. Its trailing yield is about 8.1%, but recent payouts annualize closer to 6.8%. The catch: payouts change every month, and selling options limits upside.
- Schwab International Dividend Equity ETF, 15%: This fund owns foreign dividend payers such as Unilever, Roche, and BHP, and it yields about 3.9%. The catch: it pays quarterly, and the payments vary a lot from one quarter to the next.
- W. P. Carey (NYSE:WPC), 15%: This net-lease landlord owns 1,755 properties that are 99% occupied. The company raised its dividend to $3.80[1] a year, up 4%, for a yield of about 5.8%. The catch: it cut its payout from $1.14 to $0.86 a quarter in late 2023.
- Main Street Capital (NYSE:MAIN | MAIN Price Prediction), 20%: This BDC lends to small private companies. It pays monthly and adds an extra $0.30 dividend each quarter. The regular payout alone yields about 5.8%, and the supplementals raised that to about 7.9%. The catch: the supplementals aren’t guaranteed, and the shares trade near $55 against a net asset value of $34.
- Toronto-Dominion Bank (NYSE:TD), 10%: TD is the anchor, yielding about 2.6%. Its reported earnings cover specific preferred-share, trust-security, and subordinated debt payments 17.2 times in the 12 months ended July 31, 2026. The catch: in a taxable account, Canada deducts tax before the dividend gets to him. The default rate is 25%, and the tax treaty cuts it to 15%. He can often claim it as a U.S. foreign tax credit.
- Global X U.S. Preferred ETF (NYSEARCA:PFFD), 15%: This fund holds preferred shares from Boeing, Oracle, and Wells Fargo. It pays a steady $0.10 a month, about 7.3%. The catch: the payout has slipped from $0.128 in 2017.
Why a Smaller Yield Can Pay More Later
With the 10-year Treasury at 5.2%[2], he’s taking stock and credit risk for roughly one extra point of yield. Growth is what makes up the difference.
If his income grows 4% a year, close to W. P. Carey’s latest raise, $38,169 becomes about $56,500 in 10 years. That’s roughly $4,708 a month. A standard annuity check remains flat. The preferred fund shows the risk on the other side: a high payout that shrinks over time.
Who Should Take the Annuity Instead
This trade suits someone whose Social Security already covers the basics, who wants to leave money to heirs, and who can live through a 25% drop without selling. The annuity suits someone with no other guaranteed income, a family history of long lives, or a stomach that can’t handle a dividend cut.
- Put the insurer’s monthly quote next to $3,181 and compare the gap to what you’d keep in principal.
- Rerun the paycheck without Main Street’s supplementals and with BALI’s lowest recent month. If it still covers your bills, the portfolio works.
- Before you buy TD in a taxable account, decide whether you’ll claim the foreign tax credit.
Take the guarantee if you need certainty. If you need control, dividends can give you that, as long as you can live with some months paying less.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.






