Clark Howard Says 3 Million Seniors Just Got Dumped by Medicare Advantage and Have Two Months to Act
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
More than 3 million seniors are getting letters this fall saying their Medicare Advantage plan will be gone in 2027. Clark Howard, the consumer advocate who hosts The Clark Howard Podcast, put it bluntly on his November 18 episode:
“More than 3 million people on Advantage plans have received or will receive notices that their Advantage plan has gone poof. They offered you a free gym membership and all these things. Now they’re gone. They say, go have a nice life.”
Then he got to the part most retirees don’t know about: “If your Advantage plan dumps you, you’re a free agent again. You’ve got a 2-month window to move into traditional Medicare and get a Medigap policy without medical underwriting. It’s fantastic.”
Medical underwriting lets a Medigap insurance company review your health history and then turn down you or charge you more. If you miss this window while living with a heart condition or a cancer history, you could be stuck in Advantage plans for good.
Howard Is Right, and the Out-of-Pocket Math Proves It
Howard’s opinion holds up. A cancellation notice lets you buy Medigap on the same terms as a healthy new enrollee. Under federal guaranteed-issue rules, you can generally apply as early as 60 days before your plan ends and as late as 63 days after. If your plan ends December 31, your window runs into early March 2027.
The two paths charge you in different ways. Advantage plans often cost little or nothing up front. Then you pay copays and coinsurance until you reach a yearly cap. Original Medicare plus Medigap reverses that. You pay a steady premium and very little when you get sick. Howard summed it up this way: “People love Advantage plans because they’re cheap until you have a problem, and then weirdly the out-of-pocket ends up being often much, much higher than traditional Medicare.”
You pay the Part B premium on either path, and it’s $203 a month[1] in 2026, so leave it out of the comparison. For this example, assume a Medigap Plan G costs $150 a month. Plan G covers nearly everything except the $283[1] Part B deductible. Your worst-case year costs about $2,083, plus a standalone Part D drug plan.
Now compare an example Advantage plan with a $0 premium and a $6,000 in-network out-of-pocket maximum. A diagnosis that hits that cap costs you $6,000. That one bad year costs $3,917 more than the Medigap path. A chronic illness can bring the same bill every year.
How Much Care You Need Next Year Decides the Winner
Which path wins depends on how much care you use. In a light year with $500 in copays, the Advantage plan comes out $1,583 ahead. Two light years like that add up to $3,166, which is still less than what a single heavy year costs you on Advantage.
Nobody can predict which kind of year is coming. Underwriting makes the guess riskier. Once the window closes, most states let insurance company turn you down for health reasons. Buying Medigap now protects your ability to get coverage later, after a diagnosis you can’t see coming. Premium surcharges tied to your income can stack on top of all this, which is one of several traps we mapped out in a free Medicare guide.
Big Insurers Are Shrinking Where Margins Are Thin
In January, UnitedHealth Group (NYSE:UNH | UNH Price Prediction) announced plans to reduce UnitedHealthcare membership to 46.9 to 47.5 million[2], down from 49.8 million, partly by leaving unprofitable contracts. By the third quarter, its Medicare Advantage membership had fallen by 935,000[3]. On the earnings call, executives described “footprint refinements and product refinements, really around the residual PPOs.”[4]
Humana (NYSE:HUM) has grown individual Advantage enrollment by about 1,208,000[5] this year. Its CEO still cited “our members impacted by planned exits.”[6]
UnitedHealth shares are down 19% over the past month, while Humana is up 48% this year despite a 16% drop this week. Insurance company face political heat, too: after CVS Health (NYSE:CVS) announced its breakup, Senator Elizabeth Warren posted “We need to break up Big Medicine once and for all.”
Four Steps to Take Before Your Medigap Window Closes
- Find your notice and mark the dates. Look for your plan’s end date. Then put the 60-days-before and 63-days-after deadlines on your calendar. Keep the letter, because insurance company may ask for proof that you qualify for guaranteed issue.
- Get Medigap quotes for your ZIP code. Price Plan G and Plan N with several insurance company. Ask each one in writing to confirm you’re applying under guaranteed-issue rights. Some states give you broader protections than federal law does.
- Price a Part D plan. Enter your exact prescriptions in the Medicare Plan Finder on Medicare.gov. Then add that premium to the Medigap path before you compare.
- If you’d rather stay in Advantage, compare plans on their caps. Annual enrollment runs October 15 through December 7. Line up each plan’s yearly premium against its out-of-pocket maximum and check that your doctors are in the network.
A cancellation notice gives you a short chance to trade an uncertain worst-case bill for a predictable one, and that chance ends when the window closes.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.








