Barrick Mining (NYSE:B) trades at $36.45, while Wall Street’s average price target is $56.08. That leaves an implied upside of well over 50%, a gap large enough that Barrick qualifies as one of the more disconnected large-cap names in its sector.
The company is one of the world’s largest gold and copper producers, recently rebranded from Barrick Gold, with its ticker changed from GOLD to B on May 9. Wall Street entered the year heavily bullish: two consecutive blowout quarters, a $3.0 billion share buyback authorized in May 2026, a 40% dividend hike, and a targeted spinout of North American gold assets.
Yet the stock is heading in the wrong direction while gold prints record after record. Why the divergence?
Gold Rips, the Miner Slips
Barrick has fallen 17.6% year to date and is down 13.9% over the past month alone. From its January 2026 peak of $49.64, the stock has lost roughly a quarter of its value even as the SPDR Gold Shares ETF (NYSEArca:GLD) has held far better, off just 6.5% year to date and still up 20.5% over the past year.
The pressure is company-specific. A leadership transition is central to the story, with Mark Hill running the company on an interim basis before being named CEO. Layer on escalating security issues that slowed development at the Reko Diq project in Pakistan, a $200 million payment to the government of Mali in November 2025 tied to the Loulo-Gounkoto dispute, and reported early-stage discussions to divest the African business, potentially via a London listing or an all-share transaction with Endeavour Mining. Add strategic noise from the rebrand, the targeted North American spinout, and higher royalty costs tied to elevated bullion prices, and it becomes clearer why the market has ignored the gold rally. Technicals reinforce the mood, with TradingKey’s mid-June signal flagging a Sell reading with resistance at $46.12 and support at $39.17.
Why Wall Street Has Not Blinked
Analysts are staying put because fundamentals keep improving. Q1 2026 revenue totaled $5.2 billion, beating consensus by 15% and rising 67% year over year, with adjusted EPS of $0.98 versus a $0.81 estimate. Free cash flow hit a record $1.2 billion, up 195%, and the realized gold price reached $4,823 per oz.
Analyst sentiment on the stock skews decisively bullish. Recent activity has consisted of reiterations rather than cuts, suggesting analysts view the pullback as noise around an intact thesis.
The catalyst list is specific. CEO Mark Hill has framed the year around executing the “North American Barrick IPO to unlock further shareholder value,” with completion targeted by late 2026 subject to market and regulatory conditions. Beyond the spinout, analysts point to the Fourmile discovery with 2.6 million ounces indicated and 13 million ounces inferred, the Lumwana copper expansion tracking ahead of schedule, and Goldrush ramp-up.
Keep in mind that analyst targets matter less as promises than as directional signals.
Cheap on Multiples, Heavy on Overhangs
Barrick trades at a trailing P/E of 10 and a forward P/E of 9, with TTM revenue of $19.04 billion and diluted EPS of $3.65. The market cap is roughly $61.2 billion, and the balance sheet holds $6.706 billion in cash.
The stock is up 74.8% over the past year, so this is a pullback within a much bigger uptrend. The 52-week range spans $20.52 to $54.69. Against the current $36.45 share price, the $55.83 consensus target implies a return well north of 50%, dwarfing the mid-teens returns the broad U.S. market has produced.
The Takeaway: An Opportunity for Patient Hands
The bull case for Barrick strengthens if the North American IPO closes on schedule, the Reko Diq security situation stabilizes, and gold holds above $4,000 per oz into 2027. That combination would let free cash flow compound, the $3.0 billion buyback shrink the float meaningfully, and and close some of the gap to $55.83.
The bear case holds if the market is right to price in execution risk. A delayed or discounted spinout, further security incidents in Pakistan, another operational stumble in Mali, or the new CEO making moves that unsettle strategy could keep the multiple compressed even with strong bullion prices. Rising all-in sustaining costs are a real drag, with 2026 guidance of $1,760 to $1,950 per oz.
Overall, the indicators look encouraging. The valuation, cash generation, and analyst conviction are hard to argue with. This suits investors comfortable holding through headline risk and willing to wait for the gap to consensus to close.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.
Top Gaining Stocks
Top Losing Stocks