Nvidia Has Fallen After Four Straight Earnings Beats. Here’s Why It Could Happen Again.

Photo of AJ Tiarsmith
By AJ Tiarsmith Published

Quick Read

  • NVDA has beaten EPS estimates five straight quarters yet fallen on earnings day four times, with declines reaching roughly 6%.

  • With roughly 70% year-over-year growth already baked into FY2027 consensus, it is guidance rather than reported beats that decides how NVIDIA's stock moves after earnings.

  • Don't wait: the analyst who called NVIDIA in 2010 just revealed his top 10 AI stocks. See the full list FREE now.

Nvidia Has Fallen After Four Straight Earnings Beats. Here’s Why It Could Happen Again.

© BenBen Lam via YouTube

NVIDIA (NASDAQ:NVDA | NVDA Price Prediction) reports fiscal second-quarter results after the close on Wednesday, August 26, 2026, and the setup is unusual for a company this dominant. Over the past five quarters, NVIDIA has beaten Wall Street on both earnings and revenue every time. Yet in the four quarters since Q1 FY2026, the stock has fallen after earnings.

What Wall Street Is Looking For Today

Consensus estimates call for non-GAAP earnings of roughly $2.09 per share on revenue near $92 billion, roughly double year over year. NVIDIA guided last quarter to $91.0 billion, plus or minus 2%, with non-GAAP gross margin around 75.0% and no China Data Center compute revenue in the outlook. Wedbush analyst Matt Bryson expects a beat on both the top and bottom line and carries a $330 price target. He captured the dynamic well, noting NVIDIA has “consistently exceeded consensus” the last three quarters “yet the stock is roughly unchanged from October of last year.”

NVDA price target

Five Beats, Four Drops: The Pattern

Using verified surprise figures, NVIDIA has topped EPS estimates by 8.01%, 4.00%, 3.64%, 5.32%, and 5.42% from Q1 FY2026 through Q1 FY2027. According to The Motley Fool and TradingKey, day-of stock reactions ran, in order, roughly +3.3%, then about -0.8%, -3.2%, -5.5%, and most recently between -1.3% and -1.8%. The last clearly positive reaction was about a year ago. Shares closed Tuesday at $213.05, down 3.04% over the past week and up 14.37% year to date, underperforming the broader semiconductor complex in 2026.

NVDA earnings explorer

Why Beating Estimates Is No Longer Enough

This week’s coverage reveals no meaningful correlation between beat size and post-earnings direction. What moves shares is guidance relative to the buy-side bar. At a market capitalization near $5.16 trillion and rich forward multiple, near-flawless execution is already assumed. One analysis cited by TradingKey pegged roughly 70% year-over-year growth as already baked into FY2027 consensus. A strong quarter that fails to lift that trajectory reads as disappointment. Bryson’s note captures it: consistent beats, flat stock.

Contributing Factors Analysts Have Named

Beyond the guidance bar, analysts point to several pressures. Concentrated short-dated options positioning around key strikes, including heavy activity in the August 28 expiration with call volume of 886,423 and call open interest of 700,581, is cited as a possible source of mechanical selling through dealer hedging. Questions persist about demand continuity across the Blackwell-to-Rubin transition, durability of hyperscaler AI capital spending (the same buildout that lifts the power, cooling, and networking suppliers we pulled together in a free report on seven AI infrastructure names), and the scale of NVIDIA’s own $119.0 billion in supply-related commitments. CEO Jensen Huang argued last quarter that “demand has gone parabolic” as agentic AI workloads ramp.

Analysts also named custom silicon from hyperscalers and model labs, including OpenAI’s newly benchmarked chip disclosed on August 25, as a fresh risk. It is framed as a multi-year structural concern rather than a same-day catalyst, and cannot explain a pattern stretching back to 2025.

What Actually Decides Tonight’s Reaction

Four straight post-earnings declines reflect a guidance-driven tape, where guidance drives the stock reaction. Prediction markets currently price the odds of an earnings beat at 0.986, and analyst ratings stand at 58 Buy, 2 Hold, and 1 Sell. Watch tonight’s fiscal-third-quarter revenue guide and any color on China Data Center compute, Rubin ramp timing, and gross margin trajectory. History says a number that merely matches the whisper has not been enough.

NVDA analyst ratings

Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.

Photo of AJ Tiarsmith
About the Author AJ Tiarsmith →

AJ has spent the past 10 years writing about financial markets at The Motley Fool. His coverage centers on technology stocks and the broader macroeconomic trends, from interest rates to geopolitics,  that shape where markets are headed next. AJ is drawn to the stories where big-picture economics and individual companies collide.

Continue Reading

Top Gaining Stocks

MRNA Vol: 50,059,781
SMCI Vol: 48,195,311
CDW
CDW Vol: 1,764,150
CDNS Vol: 2,984,849
AMD
AMD Vol: 19,001,388

Top Losing Stocks

CTRA Vol: 73,319,495
ALB Vol: 2,271,504
Dow
DOW Vol: 9,178,020
LYB Vol: 3,664,898
ERIE Vol: 217,793