SoFi Falls 6% Despite StoneX Buy Initiation as Rising Yields Hit Fintech; Affirm Drops 9%, Robinhood Slides 6%

Rising long-term interest rates are overwhelming a fresh buy initiation from StoneX on SoFi Technologies (NASDAQ:SOFI | SOFI Price Prediction) and sending SoFi stock sharply lower. SoFi stock is at $14.36, down 6% in morning trading, extending a brutal run that leaves it down 45% so far this year. The selloff arrives one day after the initiation, setting a cheap-stock argument against a tougher environment for lending.

Meanwhile, shares of Affirm Holdings (NASDAQ:AFRM) are at $70.99, down 9%, falling harder than SoFi stock. Additionally, shares of Robinhood Markets (NASDAQ:HOOD) are at $104.25, down 6%, tracking the slide in SoFi stock closely.

Fintech as a group is holding up better, with the ARK Blockchain & Fintech Innovation ETF (CBOE:ARKF) down 2%. Meanwhile, the SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust (NYSEARCA:SPY) is down 0.7%. That gap shows the selloff landing hardest on individual lenders and brokers while the broad market gives up far less ground.

StoneX Bull Case Meets a Hotter Inflation Report

StoneX initiated coverage of SoFi with a buy rating on October 13, arguing that the valuation had become attractive against stronger operating performance. September inflation came in above forecasts a day later, and long-term interest rates climbed in response. Higher long-term rates cut into what a consumer lender earns on the spread between its funding costs and its loan yields, and that gap drives a large share of SoFi’s profit.

That sequence puts SoFi’s valuation case and its earnings case in direct tension. The initiation leans on a share price that had fallen well behind the company’s operating gains, while higher rates threaten the lending margin that produces them, and a cheaper multiple on SoFi stock offers less comfort when the earnings it’s applied to could come under pressure.

Deposits Set SoFi Apart From Affirm and Robinhood

SoFi runs a digital bank that originates personal, student and home loans and holds customer deposits, giving it cheaper and steadier funding than wholesale markets. What remains open is whether those deposit costs stay low enough to protect its lending margin if long-term rates hold at this level. On October 8, SoFi Tech Solutions, the company’s software-licensing arm, announced a partnership with Orbi to launch a crypto-linked card in Mexico, its first such program in Latin America.

Affirm, by contrast, funds its installment loans in capital markets, while Robinhood’s revenue comes from trading activity. Customer deposits separate SoFi from both, and that’s the piece of its model the rate debate now tests most directly.

SoFi’s Rate Test Runs Through Funding Costs

SoFi’s upside argument rests on an initiation that sees value in SoFi stock after a steep decline, paired with a bank model that can lean on deposits when outside funding gets expensive. The bear case, however, holds that higher long-term rates squeeze the gap between what SoFi pays depositors and what it collects on loans, which could weigh on the earnings that support the valuation argument. Both arguments can hold at once, which helps explain why SoFi stock is falling with a bullish call fresh on the record.

SoFi’s next move hinges on whether long-term rates hold or ease after the inflation surprise. A decline in yields could let the valuation argument confirm itself, while a further climb would test how much margin SoFi’s deposit advantage can defend, so investors should weigh that rate risk when setting their exposure.

Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.