Homebuilder Confidence Just Fell to Its Lowest Since 2012
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
Nearly half of America’s home builders are now cutting prices. That is the clearest finding in the November NAHB/Wells Fargo Housing Market Index, released Tuesday, November 17.
The index fell to 25 from 29 in October. NAHB called it a 14-year low and the weakest reading since April 2012. Any reading below 50 means more builders rate conditions as poor than good.
The index surveys how builders feel about their market. It measures sentiment, and it usually moves before the hard data on sales and starts.
The iShares U.S. Home Construction ETF (CBOE:ITB) closed at $91.73, down 1.81%. The State Street SPDR S&P Homebuilders ETF (NYSEARCA:XHB) fell 1.9%. D.R. Horton (NYSE:DHI | DHI Price Prediction) slid 0.85%, Lennar (NYSE:LEN) lost 1.73%, and PulteGroup (NYSE:PHM) fell 1.92%.
The broader market also fell that day, so the selling reflected more than the report alone. ITB is down 4.64% over the past week but still up 6.17% over the past month. That means the group rallied right into a report showing builders losing confidence.
Price Cuts Are Eating Into Margins
The share of builders cutting prices rose to 46%, the highest since Covid. The average cut held at 6% for an eighth straight month, so more builders are cutting, but each cut is about the same size.
The share of sales incentives reached 68%, also a post-Covid high. It has now been at or above 60% for the 20th straight month. Builders keep sales moving by giving up price, and that reduces gross margin (the profit left on each home after building costs) before it shows up in revenue.
Lennar shows how this works. Its home sale gross margin was 15.8%[1] in its fiscal third quarter, down from 17.5% a year earlier, with incentives running near 12.0%.
Buyer Traffic Signals Weaker Orders Ahead
All three parts of the index fell. Current sales conditions dropped six points to 28. Sales expectations for the next six months fell two points to 30, and potential buyer traffic fell two points to 16.
Traffic matters most because the people touring model homes now become next season’s orders. Leaving out the start of the pandemic, traffic is at its lowest in 15 years.
Every region fell on a three-month average, and the West was weakest at 23. The South, the largest building market, fell three points to 27, so the region that usually supports the national number is weak too.
Rising Costs and High Rates Pressure Builders
NAHB Chairman Bill Owens, a builder from Worthington, Ohio, said stepped-up immigration enforcement is keeping legal workers off job sites. Higher fuel prices are leading subcontractors to raise their rates sharply, and more builders are scaling back construction.
NAHB Chief Economist Robert Dietz pointed to tariff-driven material costs, worker shortages, and regulation. He said mortgage rates above 7% are discouraging buyers.
The average 30-year fixed mortgage rate was 7.48% on November 17, near the 7.61% high of its 52-week range. A Fed that is expected to raise rates in December keeps mortgage rates high. That also makes rate buydowns, where builders pay to lower a buyer’s mortgage rate, more expensive to offer.
Weighing the Bull and Bear Cases for Homebuilders
The bull case starts with pent-up demand that could return quickly if rates fall. Owners locked into low-rate mortgages also keep resale supply tight, and the biggest builders can afford to fund their own buydowns.
The bear case is stronger. Price cuts and incentives are reducing margins while costs rise, and the Fed is leaning toward increases. Those locked-in owners are also freezing turnover: October existing-home sales ran at a 3.75 million pace, the slowest since August 2010.
My view is that the bear case wins and that the group’s recent rally exceeded the underlying data. PulteGroup looks better positioned than its peers. More than 60%[2] of its business comes from move-up and active-adult buyers, which supported a 24.8% home sale gross margin.
October housing starts and permits come out November 18 at 8:30 a.m. ET, and new-home sales follow on November 25 at 10 a.m. ET. If ITB closes below $86.40, its October 16 level, the stocks will have caught up with what builders are saying.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.





