Take-Two Stock Just Sank Almost 4% on the Day GTA VI Launched With a 99 Score
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
Take-Two Interactive (NASDAQ: TTWO) fell almost 4% on Thursday, the day Grand Theft Auto VI went on sale with a 99 out of 100 on Metacritic, tied for the highest score the review site has ever recorded. The stock closed at $208.65, down 3.7%, after touching $225.69 in the first five minutes of trading.
The reviews were a day old by then. Critics published on Wednesday, and Take-Two jumped 6.2% that day. On Thursday the game arrived, the wider market sold off, and the stock gave back more than half of Wednesday’s gain.
The drop reads as a sell-the-news move: the perfect scores were in the price by Wednesday’s close, and traders who had bought ahead of the game had little reason to wait once it arrived. The limit on that reading is that the whole market fell about 2% on Thursday, and Take-Two has not yet said how many copies it sold.
The 10s came on Wednesday
The PlayStation 5 version scored 99 on Metacritic from more than 140 critics, Barron’s reported, matching “The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time” from 1998 for the site’s record. Grand Theft Auto V scored 97 in 2013. IGN, GameSpot and Game Informer each gave the new game a 10 out of 10. Bloomberg called it the best-reviewed video game ever.
Investors reacted that day. Take-Two closed Wednesday at $216.61, up from $203.93. The gain followed a 10.5% slide on Monday and Tuesday, so the stock was already swinging when the game went on sale.
| Day | Close | Change |
|---|---|---|
| Friday, Nov. 13 | $227.82 | |
| Monday, Nov. 16 | $213.47 | -6.3% |
| Tuesday, Nov. 17 | $203.93 | -4.5% |
| Wednesday, Nov. 18 (reviews) | $216.61 | +6.2% |
| Thursday, Nov. 19 (on sale) | $208.65 | -3.7% |
Take-Two ended Thursday 8.4% below last Friday’s close. On 100 shares, that is $1,917 of value gone in four sessions, $796 of it on Thursday.
How launch day went
The stock opened at $214.73 and spiked to its high within five minutes, 4.2% above Wednesday’s close. Fifteen minutes into the session it was below $209. It climbed back to about $217.68 by 12:30 p.m., a small gain on the day, then slid through the afternoon and finished 45 cents above its low.
The afternoon slide matched the market. The largest S&P 500 fund fell about 2% and the largest Nasdaq-100 fund fell 2.2%. MT Newswires reported the Dow down more than 1,000 points late in the session. Take-Two lost 1.7 points more than the S&P 500 fund, so the market accounts for a little over half of the day’s drop.
Three reasons the stock did not rise
First, traders were set up to sell. Mizuho Securities desk analyst Jordan Klein told clients this week that a lot of hedge funds had shorted Take-Two ahead of the release, betting that expectations were too high and the launch would be a “sell-the-news event,” Investor’s Business Daily reported. Klein himself called the stock his “favorite non-AI long idea.” The Motley Fool wrote on Thursday that “there may be a sell-the-news dip, as some of the recent gains have already been priced in.” From its Oct. 30 close to Wednesday, the stock had gained 13.9%.
Second, the bar is very high. Bank of America analysts Omar Dessouky and Arthur Chu wrote that the game needs about $1.9 billion in its first three days to satisfy investors, and that less than $1.5 billion would count as a miss, according to Proactive. Sensor Tower estimated 19.1 million units and about $1.84 billion in revenue as of Thursday morning, Reuters reported. That is 2.3 times the roughly $800 million Grand Theft Auto V sold on its first day in 2013. It is an outside estimate, and it sits $60 million under the Bank of America bar with most of the three days still to come.
Third, the company has not given a number. “We still aren’t ready to declare victory,” CEO Strauss Zelnick said on the Nov. 9 earnings call, according to Reuters. “We tend to avoid claiming success before it occurs.” Take-Two kept its full-year net bookings forecast at $8.0 billion to $8.2 billion that day. Its forecast for the December quarter, $3.35 billion to $3.5 billion, is about double the $1.76 billion of a year earlier. A very strong first month is already in the company’s own forecast.
The question analysts care about most
The game came out on PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series consoles with no online mode and no PC version. Reuters reported that investors are waiting for Take-Two’s plans for both, and that some analysts expect them in 2027. The online mode is what turns a game into recurring revenue.
TD Cowen analyst Doug Creutz wrote that “‘when’ and ‘how big’ the next GTA Online will be is the most important question for the stock, more so than GTA VI unit sales.” Review scores do not answer it.
What the stock did in 2013
Take-Two also fell on the day Grand Theft Auto V came out. On Sept. 17, 2013, the stock dropped 2.0%, from $17.35 to $17.00. The company announced more than $800 million in first-day sales the next day. A month later the stock was 1.9% lower. Three months after, it was flat. A year after, it was up 32.5%, against 20.2% for the S&P 500 fund.
That is one release, and it proves little about this one. It shows that a first-day dip and a strong year have gone together before.
What holders can watch
- The first official sales figure. In 2013 Take-Two gave it one day after the game came out.
- The three-day total against the $1.9 billion bar.
- Any date for the online mode or the PC version.
- The next earnings report, expected in February, the first with the new game’s sales in it.
Analysts who cover the stock were positive going in. Baird’s Colin Sebastian has a $270 target, BMO’s Brian Pitz $285, Freedom Capital Markets’ Nick McKay $293 and Bank of America $330. Against Thursday’s close, those targets imply gains of 29% to 58%. Targets are opinions, and they miss often. The stock is 19.3% below its 52-week closing high of $258.41, set in July, and down 18.5% in 2026.
In after-hours trading Thursday, shares were near $210.
The bottom line
Take-Two fell on launch day because the best news about the game, the reviews, reached the market a day earlier, and because stocks fell broadly on Thursday. The reviews settled whether the game is good. The stock now depends on numbers no one outside the company has seen: first-week sales, and a date for the online mode. In 2013, the first sales figure came within a day.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.





