Caterpillar’s 35% 3-Month Downturn: This Sell-Side Firm Predicts 90% Returns From Here With Another Close Behind
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
Caterpillar (NYSE:CAT | CAT Price Prediction) currently trades at $537.07, while Wall Street’s average price target sits at $807.26. If analysts are right, that gap implies roughly 50.3% upside.
Caterpillar builds the excavators and mining trucks that move earth, plus the turbines and reciprocating engines that power data centers. That second business made a cyclical machinery maker into an AI infrastructure name, with Power Generation sales up 30%[1] last quarter (the same data-center power and cooling angle we covered in a free report on seven AI infrastructure suppliers that aren’t chipmakers, here).
The gap stands out because it sits next to record fundamentals. Backlog reached $78 billion[2], and two named firms still see the stock nearly doubling.
How a Record Quarter Turned Into a 34% Collapse
The AI infrastructure trade came apart, and Caterpillar went down with it. Shares fell 33.94% over three months. Coverage of the third-quarter report said earnings and sales only modestly beat expectations, “adding to investor jitters about mounting challenges to the artificial intelligence infrastructure boom.”
Adjusted EPS of $7.20[1] topped the $7.0335 consensus, and revenue of $20.682B came in line with estimates. The prior quarter had delivered a 31.83%[3] beat, so a narrow one looked like a slowdown. Management also guided full-year margins, excluding tariff recoveries, to “near the bottom of the target range,”[2] flagged a $1.6 billion fourth-quarter dealer inventory drawdown, and pegged 2026 tariff costs at about $2.2 billion.
The damage was largely Caterpillar’s alone. The stock lost 25.77% in a month, while the S&P 500 fell 6.92%.
RBC and JPMorgan Still Model a Near Double
Analysts are focused on the backlog. It rose about 96%[2] year over year, and Caterpillar is booking large reciprocating engine orders as far out as 2029 and turbine orders into 2030. Management expects 58%[2] of that backlog to ship within 12 months.
RBC Capital’s Sabahat Khan clears $1,000.00 with a top target of $1,027.00, implying 91.2% upside. JPMorgan’s Tami Zakaria rates the stock Overweight at $1,000.00, implying 86.2%, though she cut that target from $1,100.00. Evercore ISI sits at $833.00, Wells Fargo at $805.00 and Citigroup at $800.00. DA Davidson rates the stock Neutral at $685.00.
Of the 29 analysts covering the stock, 2 rate it Strong Buy, 15 Buy, 11 Hold and 1 Sell. The recent revisions have been trims, and most ratings remain Buy or Strong Buy. Consensus EPS climbs from $27.1392 for 2026 to $32.1774 for 2027. That puts the stock at a forward P/E of about 18.
The thesis gets its next test with 2027 guidance next quarter. The CEO expects margins to “claw our way off the bottom of that margin target range.”[2]
Deere and CNH Held Their Ground While Caterpillar Sank
Caterpillar largely fell alone. Its peers slipped recently but remain up for the year.
Deere (NYSE:DE) trades at $624.89. It is down 1.16% over a month and up 34.22% this year. Its $694.01 target implies 11.1% upside. Of its analysts, 5 rate it Strong Buy, 11 Buy and 9 Hold, with no Sells. That upside is far smaller than Caterpillar’s.
CNH Industrial (NYSE:CNH) trades at $11.07. It is down 4.07% over a month and up 20.07% this year. Its $14.88 target implies 34.4% upside. Of its 19 analysts, 12 rate it Buy or Strong Buy and one rates it Strong Sell. CNH is a recovery play on the farm cycle, and its upside trails Caterpillar’s.
Caterpillar has the largest implied upside in the group. That pattern points to a stock-specific selloff.
Caterpillar Lags the S&P 500 After Years of Leading It
At $537.07, Caterpillar has 50.3% implied upside to the $807.26 consensus target from 29 analysts. Price targets are estimates, and each one is a single data point.
The stock is down 5.45% year to date, while the S&P 500 is up 4.97%. Over five years, Caterpillar is still up 191.1%, compared with 52.67% for the index.
Backlog Says Opportunity, Margins Decide It
The bull case strengthens if the 2027 outlook confirms that margins rise off the bottom of the target range while the $78 billion backlog converts on schedule. The bear case strengthens if the drop in AI capital spending reaches power generation orders, or if capacity bottlenecks and tariffs keep earnings stuck.
On the bear side, the CEO said there is “no slack in the system,”[2] and fourth-quarter EPS estimates drew 14 downward revisions in 30 days.
On valuation, the stock trades at about 18 times forward earnings against a record backlog. Still, January’s guidance is the checkpoint that matters most.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.





