Your Company Stock Is 40% of Your Retirement Because You Never Sold a Share. These 3 ETFs Are How You Diversify Without Dumping It All at Once

You have already done the hard work. Throughout your career, you have saved for retirement and have been rewarded with your company’s stock. Now, A stake worth 40% of your account sits in one holding because you never sold. If that describes you, then you already know the position is too big. What you need is a way out, spread across many smaller investments. Three low-cost funds give that money somewhere to go: the Schwab U.S. Broad Market ETF (NYSEARCA:SCHB), the Vanguard Total International Stock ETF (NASDAQ:VXUS), and the Vanguard Short-Term Inflation-Protected Securities ETF (NASDAQ:VTIP).

Four Obstacles Keeping You From Selling a Single Share

One company now drives your savings, your paycheck, and possibly your bonus. A bad stretch for that business can hit all three at once. You’ve heard that argument before. What actually blocks most people is one of four obstacles:

• Taxes. Shares you’ve held a long time often carry large gains, so every sale creates a bill that feels like a loss you decided to take.
• Restrictions. Trading windows, blackout periods, and company holding requirements can limit when you’re allowed to sell at all.
• Optics. Selling can feel disloyal, or like a signal that you know something your coworkers don’t.
• Regret. Nobody wants to sell right before the stock runs.

Let a Written Schedule Make Every Decision for You

All four obstacles have the same fix: decide once, then follow a schedule. Sell a set portion at set times, and you never have to pick the right moment. Each sale becomes routine maintenance. If the stock rises after a sale, you still own the remaining shares. If it falls, some of your money has already moved.

Put the plan in writing before the first sale. A rule set in advance is far easier to follow than a judgment call made every quarter while the share price is moving. Ask your plan administrator whether your company permits pre-scheduled sales arranged during an open window, since those can keep your schedule on track around blackout periods. Spreading sales across more than one tax year is also a common way to manage the bill.

Two details often get missed. First, if any shares sit inside a workplace retirement plan, employer securities can sometimes qualify for special tax treatment. Have that situation reviewed separately before you sell those shares. Second, new grants keep coming. A plan that covers only the shares you own today gets undone by the next vesting cycle, so decide now what happens to each new grant when it vests.

SCHB: Hundreds of Companies Instead of One

Your current position ties your results to one company. SCHB spreads your money across the broad U.S. market, including large, mid-size, and small companies, which gives sale proceeds broad U.S. market exposure. Net assets were about $43.3 billion as of May 31, 2026, and its largest single holding made up roughly 6.3% of the portfolio. Many of its other positions amount to fractions of a percent.

SCHB pays distributions quarterly, totaling $0.3075 per share over the trailing 12 months. Its adjusted return was 19.91% over the past year and 308.73% over 10 years. Those gains came with full stock market swings. Diversification changes what your losses depend on, and losses remain possible.

VXUS: A Second Economy for Your Savings and Your Paycheck

Your employer’s success and your salary already ride on the U.S. economy. VXUS holds developed and emerging market stocks outside the U.S., so it diversifies your income source along with your portfolio. Its expense ratio is 0.05%, which means you keep $999.50 of every $1,000 working for you each year.

VXUS gained 20.01% over the past year, roughly in line with SCHB. Over 10 years, it returned 144.86%, well behind SCHB, a reminder that foreign stocks can lag for long stretches. Distributions come quarterly but vary widely, from $1.3631 per share in December 2025 to $0.1562 in September 2026.

VTIP: A Stable Place to Park Your Tax Money

Each sale can create a tax bill due later. VTIP holds short-term Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities, whose principal adjusts with inflation, a feature some investors use for proceeds set aside for that payment. Short maturities also mean less sensitivity to interest rates than longer TIPS funds carry. The fund returned 1.51% over the past year and 34.14% over 10 years, small by design.

Inflation protection still matters. Consumer prices rose 0.4% in August from July, and five-year TIPS carried a real yield of 2.68% on October 9. Payouts are quarterly and uneven, ranging from $0.9333 per share in October to $0.0227 in April, so treat them as variable income.

Trade-Offs to Weigh Before Your First Sale

A slow plan means you keep concentration risk while you unwind. If your employer’s stock falls quickly partway through, the shares you haven’t sold take the hit. Taxes stay real, too. Spreading sales manages the bill, and you still owe it. And none of these funds is guaranteed to beat your company’s stock in any given year.

What the three funds offer is a portfolio built on hundreds of companies and multiple economies. When your savings and your salary come from the same place, that’s the protection you’re missing, and a written schedule is how you get there one sale at a time.

Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.