XLU vs VPU: Which Utility ETF Gets More From the AI Power Rush?
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
Data centers have pulled the sleepiest corner of the stock market into the AI trade. A 2026 Government Accountability Office report cites an Energy Department projection that data centers could use up to 12% of U.S. electricity by 2028. Retirement investors seeking that demand usually choose between two cheap index funds: the State Street Utilities Select Sector SPDR ETF (NYSEARCA:XLU) and the Vanguard Utilities ETF (NYSEARCA:VPU). Their returns look almost identical, but XLU packs its money into the giants while VPU spreads it across a long tail of smaller utilities.
How Much Each Fund Leans on Its Biggest Names
XLU owns only the S&P 500’s utilities, about 30 stocks. It held $23.1 billion[1] in net assets at midyear. Concentration measures how much of a fund rides on its largest positions. At XLU it runs high: the top 10 holdings made up about 57.5% of assets.
NextEra Energy (NYSE:NEE | NEE Price Prediction) alone accounted for 12.9%. VPU tracks the MSCI US IMI Utilities 25/50 Index, which holds more than 65 stocks, including mid-cap, small-cap, and water utilities. Its index rules cap any single company at 25%. All positions above 5% can’t add up to more than 50% combined. Those smaller names take money away from the mega-caps that drive the AI story.
Where the AI Power Money Actually Lands
The clearest winners are independent power producers, which sell into competitive markets instead of earning regulated rates. Constellation Energy (NASDAQ:CEG) signed a 690 MW deal with a hyperscaler at its Calvert Cliffs nuclear plant. This year, it added about 8,500 MW of long-term agreements. Such contracts lock in demand. Vistra (NYSE:VST) signed a 20-year agreement with a data center developer at its Odessa gas plant.
Together with smaller producers, Constellation and Vistra made up about 12% of XLU at midyear. VPU owns the same companies, but its small regulated utilities depend on rate cases for growth, so more of each VPU dollar goes to slower-growing businesses. (We analyzed seven of the companies providing the AI data-center expansion, from power to cooling, in a free report you can grab here.)
Nearly Identical Returns, Different Leaders
Three-year returns nearly tied. VPU returned 53.8% to XLU’s 53.3%. The longer record favors XLU, 50.3% to 48.4%. Owning more of the biggest companies delivered that edge over five years.
Income and Cost in Retiree Terms
| Metric | XLU | VPU |
|---|---|---|
| Expense ratio | 0.08% | 0.09%[2] |
| Annual cost on $100,000 | $80 | $90 |
The expense ratio is the annual fee taken from fund assets. The gap is small, but it favors XLU every year. XLU’s fact sheet lists a dividend yield of 2.6%, which is a year’s worth of dividends expressed as a share of the fund’s price. Electric utilities make up about 66% of the fund, and their regulated earnings keep that income steady.
Risks That Hit Both Funds
Utilities borrow heavily, so rising interest rates hurt them. The 10-year Treasury yield was 5.1%[3]. Regulation is another risk: Colorado legislative staff, citing federal data, report that retail electricity prices have risen faster than inflation since 2022, so resistance to rate increases could grow. That same report flags significant uncertainty in data center demand forecasts. XLU’s larger stake in power producers would take the bigger hit if those forecasts prove too optimistic.
Verdict: XLU Wins for Retirement Portfolios
XLU offers the stronger profile for most retirement portfolios. The fund charges less, has the better five-year record, and gives more direct exposure to the power producers signing data center contracts. A large base of regulated electric utilities still supports its income. VPU suits investors who want the widest mix of utilities, including small and water utilities, and who accept a slightly higher fee. The case would shift toward VPU if AI demand stalls and the largest power names lose value, because VPU’s long tail of smaller utilities would buffer the fall.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.






