Why So Many Investors Are Paralyzed Right Now, and How to Break the Freeze

Even though the stock market continues to hit new highs, investors are filled with anxiety. Uncertainty about world events and the global economy causes many people to freeze, says author and journalist Simone Stolzoff.

Why do our brains lock up when markets get erratic? For early humans, “if there was a rustling in the bushes and they didn’t know the source of that noise, it could have potentially been lethal,” Stolzoff said on a recent episode of HerMoney with Jean Chatzky. “Uncertainty was a matter of life or death. And so our brains are wired to feel safe and secure when we have certainty and feel incredibly uncomfortable and anxious when we don’t.”

Chatzky drew the line to investing. “If you are waiting for certainty, if you’re waiting for perfect answers, it’s almost impossible to get yourself to accept the fact that some things in this world just don’t have them,” she said.

Investors who freeze lose capital slowly to inflation and forgone compounding while waiting for a signal that will never arrive. Sitting in cash feels safe, but it quietly bleeds purchasing power. Prices keep rising whether or not you make a decision.

“If you don’t put your money to work, then you’re facing inflation risk,” Chatzky said. “You’re facing risk from taxes that is going to reduce the purchasing power of your dollar. So you’re going to lose money anyway simply by doing nothing.”

Consider $50,000 in a savings account at the current policy rate. The nominal interest earned over a year is roughly $1,875 before taxes. With CPI running at current levels, most of that is consumed by inflation. The same $50,000 in a diversified index fund earning a historical long-run average closer to 8% would generate something closer to $4,000, leaving a positive real return after inflation. Paralysis has a price, and it compounds for every year of indecision.

The framework that breaks the freeze

Stolzoff’s fix is structural. Build “certainty anchors”: 3 to 6 months of liquid savings, automated 401(k) contributions, and a rules-based investing plan you do not renegotiate every time the news cycle spikes. “When we are certain about some facets of our life, it makes it easier to hold uncertainty in others,” he said.

Pair that with Jeff Bezos’s one-way versus two-way door test. Marriage and buying a house are one-way doors. Starting a 401(k) contribution at 6% of salary is a two-way door. You can dial it up or down next month. Stolzoff also endorses Bezos’s 70% rule. “You should make decisions when you are sort of 75% ready, because if you wait till you’re 100%, it’s often too late,” he said. Stolzoff recommends finding “that little string in the large tapestry that you can pull on” rather than throwing your hands up in resignation.

Whether this advice helps or hurts hinges on one question: Is the decision reversible? An automated $500 monthly contribution to a target-date fund is a two-way door. If you hate it in three months, you can change the allocation or pause it. Cashing out a 401(k) to time the market is a one-way door. Taxes and the 10% early-withdrawal penalty are permanent.

Tips for handling financial uncertainty

1. Build the anchor first. Park 3 to 6 months of expenses in a high-yield savings account close to the 3.75% policy rate. Certainty in the emergency fund makes uncertainty elsewhere bearable.
2. Automate the two-way door. Set a 401(k) contribution today, even at 3% of salary, and step it up 1% per year. As Stolzoff said: “Action can absorb anxiety. It’s actually through the doing that we begin to see more clearly and our anxiety begins to shrink.”
3. Apply the 10-10-10 test. Consider Suzy Welch’s test: What is the impact in 10 days, 10 months, 10 years? Most investing decisions look small at 10 days and enormous at 10 years.
4. Stop researching once new information stops arriving. If the next article tells you what the last three did, you are seeking validation rather than new information.