Beware The IRS Tax Trap Awaiting Anyone Who Raids Their Roth IRA Early

“When you owe the government money, they’re not very happy. And you probably owe the government money with pulling out from that Roth IRA.” That line came from Caleb Hammer on his Financial Audit show, talking to a guest named Veronica who had cashed out her entire Roth IRA, was carrying $13,142 in credit card debt, and had not filed her 2023 taxes despite the withdrawal. Her plan, in her own words: “hope that I have enough money by next year filing.”

Hope is not a tax strategy. If you did something similar, you are not totally stuck, but the order in which you fix things matters enormously. Get the sequence wrong and the IRS becomes your biggest creditor, well ahead of any credit card company.

The verdict: the tax bill is the real emergency

Hammer’s instinct is correct. When you raid a Roth IRA before age 59½, the IRS sorts the money into two buckets. Your contributions, the dollars you originally put in after tax, come out tax-free and penalty-free at any age. Your earnings, everything the account grew by, face ordinary income tax plus a 10% early-withdrawal penalty if you are under 59½ and the account is less than five years old.

Run the numbers on a realistic case. Say you cashed out a $20,000 Roth IRA that held $14,000 of contributions and $6,000 of earnings. The $14,000 is yours, clean. The $6,000 of earnings gets taxed at your marginal rate: at 22%, that is $1,320 in federal income tax. Add the 10% penalty, another $600. State income tax stacks on top of that. You are looking at roughly $2,000 in federal liability on a $20,000 withdrawal, before state taxes enter the picture.

Now compare that to the credit card. At a 24% APR paying only the 2% minimum, a $13,142 balance takes more than two decades to retire, and the total interest paid roughly doubles the original amount owed. Painful, but survivable with a real payoff plan. The IRS bill is the sharper threat. Unpaid taxes accrue a failure-to-file penalty of 5% per month, capped at 25%, on top of a separate failure-to-pay penalty and daily compounding interest. If a return goes more than 60 days unfiled, the IRS adds a minimum penalty of $525 for 2026 returns, or 100% of the tax owed, whichever is smaller. The credit card company sends collection letters. The IRS garnishes wages and levies bank accounts without going to court first.

If you cashed out a Roth and skipped a filing year, the tax return is the first call you make, before anything else.

The variable that decides how bad this gets

The single factor that changes everything is the split between contributions and earnings inside your withdrawal. Your Form 5498s from past years and your IRA custodian’s records will show you that breakdown. Two people can cash out the exact same dollar amount and owe wildly different taxes depending on how their account was funded and how long it grew.

Consider two scenarios. Reader A opened a Roth at 25 and contributed $7,500 a year for ten years, which is the 2026 annual contribution limit. The account grew to $90,000. They withdraw the whole thing at 36. Of that balance, $75,000 is contributions and comes out tax-free. Only $15,000 is taxable earnings. Federal hit at 22%: $3,300 in income tax plus $1,500 penalty, roughly $4,800 owed.

Reader B inherited a small Roth, contributed sporadically, and the account grew mainly through a single well-timed stock pick. Same $90,000 balance, but only $20,000 of it is contributions. Now $70,000 is taxable earnings. The 10% penalty alone is $7,000, and the additional income could push them into a higher bracket. Same withdrawal amount, completely different financial damage.

The broader economic backdrop makes all of this worse. The national personal savings rate slipped from 6.2% in early 2024 to about 3.7% in the first quarter of 2026, according to Bureau of Economic Analysis data. Meanwhile, consumer prices rose 3.8% in the year through April 2026, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. Inflation eats the financial cushion that would otherwise let someone pay down a $13,000 balance in a year or two, while a falling savings rate signals that fewer households have much cushion to begin with.

What to do this week

1. File the missing return first. Even if you cannot pay a dollar, filing stops the 5% per month failure-to-file penalty from accruing. For a balance under $50,000, you can request an installment agreement directly on IRS.gov and approval is largely automatic. Settling into a payment plan also cuts the failure-to-pay penalty rate in half, from 0.5% to 0.25% per month, for each month the plan remains active.
2. Pull your Form 5498 and 1099-R. The 1099-R from your custodian shows the gross distribution. Your historical 5498s document your contributions year by year. The difference is your taxable earnings amount. Hand both documents to a tax preparer or enter them into tax software before doing anything else with the numbers.
3. Stop the bleeding on the cards. List every balance and its APR. Then call each issuer and ask for a hardship rate reduction. A June 2026 LendingTree survey found that 84% of cardholders who asked for an APR reduction got one, with an average cut of 6.3 percentage points. Most people never ask. After that conversation, attack the highest-rate card first while paying minimums on the rest.
4. Close the lifestyle gap. “I’m living the life that I eventually will be able to afford” is the sentence that put Veronica in this hole. Spending against a future income you do not yet earn closes through debt, and debt at 20%-plus interest closes nothing. The gap has to narrow from the spending side, not the borrowing side.

The situation is recoverable. File the return, lock in a payment plan with the IRS, and treat the credit card minimum as your floor while building a real accelerated payoff schedule on top of it. The clock on the failure-to-file penalty stops the moment you submit the return, which is the single highest-return action you can take today.

Editor’s note: This update corrects the personal savings rate to 3.7% for Q1 2026 per Bureau of Economic Analysis data and replaces the article’s CPI index-level comparison with the verified 3.8% year-over-year inflation figure from the Bureau of Labor Statistics April 2026 report. It also adds the $525 minimum failure-to-file penalty for 2026 returns more than 60 days late, confirmed by IRS.gov, and updates Reader A’s contribution to $7,500, reflecting the 2026 Roth IRA annual contribution limit. The credit card rate-reduction success rate (84% of cardholders who asked received a cut, per a June 2026 LendingTree survey) was added to the action steps.

Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.