I Told My Boss I’m Done. Now I Have to Choose Between a 1.73% CD and a 5.26% Treasury

Here’s an eye-opening financial dilemma. An r/retirement poster called “u/dex248” on Reddit quit a job he openly likes, and his reason lines up closely with the first money decision he now faces. Earlier this week, under the heading “Today I told my boss I am quitting,” he described interesting, challenging work and a supportive, smart team. Time pushed him out: “I can’t keep working forever, and I don’t see the point of trying to do more on projects that I won’t be able to see through.”

“I think I finally hit a tipping point,” he wrote, without naming a savings figure or income plan. That judgment about time drives his next choice: where to park cash once the paycheck stops. Between a certificate of deposit (CD) and a Treasury, the government note is the better pick for most people in his position.

Why a 1.7% CD Falls Behind Social Security

One-year CDs average 1.7% nationwide, though individual banks pay more and less. Most new retirees reach for a CD first because it feels familiar.

Social Security’s cost-of-living adjustment (COLA) for next year is tracking in a range of 3.5% to 3.6%. A CD earning the typical bank rate doesn’t clear that threshold, so the cash loses buying power next to the check. Many CDs also charge early-withdrawal penalties that lock savers into that shortfall.

What the 5.3% Treasury Actually Pays For

The ten-year Treasury note yielded 5.3% at its most recent daily reading. That’s the highest level in the trailing year and the 99.6th percentile of that period’s readings. State and local income taxes don’t apply to Treasury interest, while CD earnings face levies at every level of government.

Treasuries trade on a deep secondary market, so a retiree can exit without a penalty, though a note sold early can fetch less than its purchase price. The U.S. government’s full faith and credit covers default risk, leaving price swings and reinvestment risk when the term ends.

Here the poster’s logic applies. The same read on time that ended his job decides whether a ten-year commitment fits or a shorter maturity better matches when the money is needed, avoiding a forced sale that could turn a safe asset into a loss.

Why BND Hasn’t Been the Safe Harbor

The Vanguard Total Bond Market Index Fund ETF Shares (NASDAQ:BND) is the core bond fund advisers often reach for second. BND shares were down 3% year to date through the prior session’s close, and they fell 4% over the past five years. Over that same five-year span, shares of the SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust (NYSEARCA:SPY) rose 76% on price. This ETF includes reliable value gainers like Apple (NASDAQ:AAPL | AAPL Price Prediction) and Coca-Cola (NYSE:KO).

SPY stands for the growth portion of a retirement portfolio; the CD-or-Treasury question covers only the cash bucket. BND still fits as a diversified, longer-duration fund holding Treasuries, agency mortgage-backed bonds and investment-grade corporate debt in one package, though its monthly distributions change over time.

What to Decide First as a New Retiree

For most new retirees at these rates, the Treasury is the better home for the cash bucket, and a CD at the typical bank rate is the worst option. Map when each dollar is needed, then choose Treasury maturities that end on or before those dates so each note can be held to maturity. Consider a CD only when a bank pays well above average and the term fits.

Getting this right matters because going back to work isn’t easy: there are 7.08 million job openings, down 3.5% from the prior month. Leaving a job he liked was a reasonable call about time, and his cash deserves the same clear-eyed treatment.

A frequent mistake is assuming a CD or bond fund is automatically safe. Size Treasury holdings to cover the years you can’t afford to sell (the sequence-of-returns problem we walked through in a free guide to defending the first five years of retirement), treat BND as broad longer-duration exposure, and size SPY as the growth portion funding later decades.

Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.