Her Mother Left Her A $450,000 IRA. The Supreme Court Ruled 9-0 It Wasn’t ‘Retirement Funds,’ So It Wasn’t Shielded In Her Bankruptcy. Here’s How Parents Can Protect An IRA They Plan To Leave To Their Kids
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
A mother’s IRA was worth just over $450,000 when her daughter inherited it. By the time the daughter and her husband filed for Chapter 7 bankruptcy in October 2010, roughly $300,000 was left. They tried to protect it as “retirement funds.” On June 12, 2014, the Supreme Court ruled against them in Clark v. Rameker, and the decision was unanimous.
Parents ask some version of this question all the time: if I leave my IRA to my kids, does the protection I had come with it? For most families, the answer is no. Here is how to change that.
Why Your IRA Loses Its Protection the Day Your Child Inherits It
The Court read “retirement funds” to mean “sums of money set aside for the day an individual stops working.” It pointed to three features of inherited IRAs. The heir can never add money. The heir has to take withdrawals “no matter how far they are from retirement.” And the heir can take out the whole balance at any time with no penalty.
In the Court’s view, nothing about an inherited IRA stops someone from spending all of it “immediately after bankruptcy for purposes of current consumption.” Your own IRA protects you because it is built to last until you retire. Your child’s inherited IRA is built to be spent. The ruling covers the federal bankruptcy exemption only. Some states protect inherited IRAs under their own laws, but if your child moves to a state that doesn’t, that protection can disappear .
How the SECURE Act Made the Problem Bigger
When Clark was decided, many heirs could stretch withdrawals across their whole lives. That option is mostly gone. For owners who die after December 31, 2019, the account generally has to be emptied within ten years. The exceptions are a surviving spouse, a minor child, a disabled or chronically ill heir, and anyone not more than ten years younger than the owner. The IRS says that if the owner died in 2025, the heir must empty the account by December 31, 2035. Missing a required withdrawal sets off an excise tax of 25% on the shortfall. That drops to 10% if it is corrected in time.
So the law forces the money out within a decade. Once it lands in your child’s checking account, creditors can reach it like any other cash. It also counts as taxable income. An heir 65 or older who takes large withdrawals can pass the $109,000[1] single-filer income threshold. That raises the monthly Part B premium from $202.90[1] to $284.10.
A Trust That Holds Up Once the 10-Year Clock Starts
The usual fix is to name a trust with spendthrift language (a clause that keeps creditors from reaching the money while it stays in the trust) as the beneficiary, instead of naming your child directly. How the trust is written decides whether it works.
A conduit trust passes every IRA withdrawal straight to your child. Under the 10-year rule, that means the whole account reaches your child within a decade, and creditors can reach it there. An accumulation trust lets the trustee keep withdrawals inside the trust and pay them out at its discretion. That keeps the money protected. The catch is that income kept inside a trust reaches the top federal tax bracket at a small fraction of the income an individual would need to get there.
This is where Roth conversions help. Withdrawals from an inherited Roth are generally tax free once the account meets the qualified distribution rules. An accumulation trust can then hold that money without the heavy trust tax bill. Roth heirs still face distribution rules , so the trust is still what provides the protection.
The Roth conversion is what makes using the trust affordable. You pay the conversion tax at your own rates. If you spread conversions over several years and keep joint income under $218,000[1], you avoid the Medicare surcharge yourself.
Two other tools reduce the amount at risk. Once you are old enough to qualify, qualified charitable distributions of up to $111,000 in 2026 let you give money to charity straight from the IRA. And naming your spouse as first beneficiary lets them treat the IRA as their own . That keeps it a retirement account and keeps the trust problem off the table until the second death.
What It Takes to Leave an IRA Your Child Actually Keeps
Start with your child’s real risk. A business owner, a doctor facing malpractice claims, someone in a shaky marriage, or someone already carrying debt is the heir Clark applies to most. If that describes your heir, the plan is:
- Name an accumulation trust with spendthrift provisions as the IRA beneficiary.
- Convert to Roth a piece at a time, sized to stay under the Medicare surcharge (IRMAA) level you care about.
- Give to charity from the IRA if you are already giving.
- Check the protection rules in your child’s state, and check again if they move.
The right structure is what buys this protection. Your IRA had protection because of what it was for, which was your retirement. Your child’s protection lasts only as long as the money sits in a structure your child doesn’t control. Under the 10-year rule, an IRA left directly to your child will be fully withdrawn and exposed to creditors within a decade. Naming the right trust is what changes that, and it is one line item on a longer estate checklist we put together in a free guide to the paperwork that decides whether your money reaches family or lawyers.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.








