His Indexed Annuity Tracks the S&P 500. The Fine Print Says “Price Return,” Which Means It Leaves Out Every Dividend the 500 Companies Pay
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
Picture a hypothetical 62-year-old who just retired. He has been pitched a fixed indexed annuity “linked to the S&P 500” with no market losses. That sounds like stock-market upside with a safety net. Then he reads the contract and finds one phrase: the index is the S&P 500 price return index. That phrase means his interest credits will be based only on changes in share prices. Every dividend the 500 companies pay goes uncounted.
This matters right now. The S&P 500 has been volatile, and that kind of market is when principal-protected products get the most attention. The SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust (NYSEARCA:SPY) fell 6.6% over the past month and 5.45% over the past week, closing at $715.84.
What “Price Return” Leaves Out of the S&P 500
Index providers publish more than one version of the S&P 500. The price return version tracks only share-price changes. The total return version assumes every dividend is reinvested. Most fixed indexed annuities tied to the S&P 500 credit interest using the price return version.
Here’s why: the insurer never buys the stocks for you. It keeps your premium in its general account and uses part of that account’s yield to buy options on the index. You own a contract, so you never own shares and never receive dividends.
An S&P 500 fund shows how much cash that leaves out. SPY pays quarterly. Its latest distribution was $1.888834 per share (ex-dividend September 18, 2026), and its trailing 12-month total is $7.582717. At the current price, that comes to about 1.06% a year. That cash stream also grows. SPY’s December 2016 quarterly payout was $1.32893, while its price gains exceeded 220% over the past 10 years. A price-return formula excludes the dividend distributions.
Caps and Participation Rates Shrink Whatever Is Left
After dividends are gone, the contract limits the price gain too. A cap sets the most you can be credited in a period. A participation rate sets what share of the index gain you get. Insurers set both, and many contracts allow them to be changed at renewal.
Hypothetical example: a $100,000 premium measured over the same 12 months in which SPY’s price rose 8.03%. The cap and participation rate below are made up for illustration. They are not current offers.
| Crediting Scenario (Hypothetical) | Credited Result |
|---|---|
| Full price return, no cap | $8,030 |
| 7% annual cap | $7,000 |
| 50% participation, no cap | $4,015 |
| Dividends at SPY’s trailing rate (index fund owner only) | About $1,059 |
What you get in return is the floor. In a down year, the credit is zero and the account value holds steady, before any rider fees or surrender charges. That “guarantee” depends on the insurer’s claims-paying ability. State guaranty associations act as a backstop if an insurer fails, but coverage limits vary by state, so check your own state’s limit.
How the Credited Gains Get Taxed
In a nonqualified contract (one bought with after-tax money), credited interest grows tax-deferred. Withdrawals are taxed as earnings first. Under 26 U.S.C. § 72(e)(3)(A)[1], a withdrawal counts as income to the extent the contract’s cash value, measured before any surrender charge, exceeds your investment in the contract. Those gains are taxed as ordinary income. An index fund held in a taxable account works differently, because qualified dividends and long-term gains can get lower rates.
Withdraw early and the bill grows. 26 U.S.C. § 72(q)(1)[1] adds an extra tax equal to 10%[1] of the taxable part of an annuity withdrawal, generally for owners under 59½, with listed exceptions. If the annuity sits inside an IRA, distributions are taxed “in the manner provided under section 72[2]” per 26 U.S.C. § 408(d)(1), and required minimum distribution rules still apply.
Who This Trade-Off Suits, and Who Pays Too Much for It
A price-return indexed annuity fits best for someone who would otherwise keep the money in CDs or Treasuries. That person wants some link to stock gains, can live with a capped upside, and can leave the money alone for the whole surrender period. Measured against cash, losing dividends costs little, because a CD pays no dividends either.
It fits less well for someone with a long time horizon who can sit through market drops. That investor can own the whole S&P 500, dividends included, through a fund such as the Vanguard S&P 500 ETF (NYSEARCA:VOO), which has a net expense ratio of 0.03%. Some people split the difference: part of their savings in a CD or Treasury ladder for safety, the rest in an index fund for growth. If the goal is lifelong income without ever selling a share, a dividend ladder is another route we walked through in a free guide here.
Questions to Ask Before Signing Anything
- Which index exactly? Ask whether it is price return, total return, or a custom “volatility-controlled” index the insurer designed.
- What crediting method? Ask about annual point-to-point, monthly averaging or monthly caps, and whether the cap or participation rate can be reset at each renewal and to what minimum.
- What does it cost? Ask for the surrender schedule in writing, along with any income or death benefit rider fees, which are subtracted even in zero-credit years.
- How is the seller paid? Commissions influence which products get recommended, so ask how much the agent earns on this one.
Going forward, keep an eye on renewal notices. Caps and participation rates move with interest rates and option prices, so the deal you sign is only guaranteed for its first crediting period. Our hypothetical retiree’s contract tracks only the price gains. If that matches what he wants, the floor may be worth it. If he expected the full S&P 500 return, dividends included, the contract’s index name already tells him he won’t get it.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.








