Mom’s Will Split the House and the IRA Three Ways. It Never Mentioned the $87,500 Ring, and a One-Page List Would Have Settled It
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
A mother’s will split the house and the IRA equally among her three adult children. It never mentioned her ring, which carried an estimated value of $87,500. That one gap can cause more family friction than either of the bigger assets, and it changes how the heirs end up paying tax on the ring.
Where an Unmentioned Ring Ends Up
A specific item the will leaves out usually passes under the residual clause, the catch-all provision that covers everything not given to someone by name. In this family, the rest goes to the three children in equal shares. The house can be sold and the cash divided. A single ring can’t be split. The usual outcomes are a buyout by one sibling, a forced sale or a family dispute.
Federal estate data show how easily personal items get lost in broad categories. IRS Statistics of Income tables for estate tax returns filed in 2024 list “Art” as its own category, reported on 1,296 returns[1] totaling $2,718,935,000. Jewelry falls into broader groups such as “Other assets,” which appeared on 6,397 returns[1]. Only 7,195[1] estate tax returns were filed in all, so most families settle an estate without any federal return recording what a ring was worth.
Why the IRA Followed Different Rules
The IRA most likely passed outside the will. A retirement account goes to the people named on the custodian’s beneficiary form, and the account’s governing documents control the transfer. For owners who die after December 31, 2019, the SECURE Act requires the full balance to be paid out within ten years. There are exceptions for a surviving spouse, a minor child, a disabled or chronically ill beneficiary, and anyone no more than ten years younger than the owner. Each child’s withdrawals count as taxable income, and that income will sit on the same returns as any later sale of the ring.
A One-Page List and Where It Holds Up
Many wills include a clause pointing to a separate written list of tangible personal property: jewelry, furniture, artwork, a watch. The owner signs and dates the list and can usually revise it without re-signing the whole will. Many states recognize such a list, but not all, and the formal requirements vary. Some states require the will to refer to the list and the owner to sign it. In states that give the list no legal force, it reads only as a request the heirs may choose to honor. A list would have settled this ring dispute only where state law enforces it and the document meets that state’s requirements. An estate attorney in the owner’s state can confirm both.
How the IRS Taxes an Inherited Ring
Under 26 U.S.C. § 1014(a)(1)[2], an heir’s basis is “the fair market value of the property at the date of the decedent’s death“[2]. IRS Publication 550 adds that gain or loss on inherited capital property is considered long term, regardless of how long you held the property. Without a filed Form 706, heirs use the appraised value on the date of death for state inheritance or transmission taxes. When an estate return is required, the executor must give each beneficiary a statement of the reported value under 26 U.S.C. § 6035(a)(1)[3].
In practice, a sale soon after a date-of-death appraisal near $87,500 produces little or no taxable gain. If the ring is held and later sells for more, the profit is collectibles gain. A gem or precious metal counts as a collectible under 26 U.S.C. § 408(m)(2)(C)[4], and 26 U.S.C. § 1(h)(5)(A)[5] applies that definition “without regard to paragraph (3)”[5].
Paragraph (3) is the IRA carve-out. Under 26 U.S.C. § 408(m)(3)[4], certain gold, silver and platinum coins described in 31 U.S.C. 5112, coins issued under state law, and bullion that satisfies contract-market fineness requirements and is held by a qualifying trustee are excluded from the definition of collectibles for IRA purposes. That exception governs what an IRA may hold. A ring sold from a personal account is still taxed the same way.
For tax year 2025, IRS Publication 550 lists a maximum rate of 28% on collectibles gain, compared with 20% at the top for ordinary long-term gain. The prior-year edition notes that if you are otherwise subject to a rate lower than 28%, the 28% rate does not apply. Heirs who are close to retirement and already taking inherited IRA withdrawals should also check whether a large sale increases the income figures used for Medicare premium surcharges. Those limits change, so confirm the current ones before deciding when to sell.
Three Steps That Prevent the Standoff
- Get a dated appraisal. Record the item’s value, description, photos and location. After death, a date-of-death appraisal sets the heirs’ basis.
- Write the list and reference it in the will. Assign each significant item to a named person, then sign and date the list. Confirm that the owner’s state enforces separate lists and what form it requires.
- Update it as things change. Revise the list when items are sold, given away or revalued. Check beneficiary forms at the same time so the IRA, the house and the jewelry all go where the owner intends.
A will that divides the big assets in thirds can still leave the most personal item unassigned. A short, current list, valid under the owner’s state law, gives the ring a named recipient before anyone has to argue over it (we put the full estate checklist, beneficiary forms and titling included, in a free report here).
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.








