A Comeback Year That Doesn’t Feel Like One
Picture a 63-year-old who spent five years and most of his savings opening a small craft distillery. The build-out years were brutal. Equipment, licensing, barrels aging in a rickhouse while producing nothing sellable, and a lease he signed before understanding how long bourbon actually takes. By the time the first bottles moved, he had accumulated roughly $100,000 in business losses. He also started Social Security at 62 to keep the lights on at home while the distillery found its footing.
Then the tasting room caught on. This year, the distillery posted approximately $60,000 in net profit. His accountant applied the prior losses as a net operating loss carryforward, sharply reducing his regular taxable income. He assumed Social Security would see the same near-wash. It did not. A benefits notice arrived warning that part of his checks would be withheld because his current self-employment earnings were too high.
This confusion shows up routinely in small-business forums, usually phrased as some version of: “My old losses offset this year’s profit, so why is Social Security acting like I made $60,000?” The answer is that the income-tax calculation and the Social Security earnings test keep different score.
Two Ledgers, One Painful Gap
For federal income-tax purposes, a net operating loss from earlier years can generally be carried forward and used to offset part of a later year’s taxable income. That can reduce the founder’s regular income-tax bill substantially. It does not necessarily eliminate his self-employment tax, however, because an NOL carryforward generally does not reduce the current year’s self-employment-tax liability.
Social Security follows the current business result too. When calculating earnings for someone who claimed benefits before full retirement age, the agency does not let a prior-year NOL carryforward reduce current net earnings from self-employment. The distillery’s $60,000 current-year profit therefore carries substantial weight under the earnings test even though the NOL makes the income-tax side of the return look much leaner.
For this 63-year-old, full retirement age (FRA) is 67. In 2026, someone under FRA for the entire year can earn $24,480 before benefits are affected. Social Security then withholds $1 in benefits for every $2 above the limit. The prior $100,000 loss does not lower that $24,480 comparison. Social Security is measuring this year’s business earnings, not the distillery’s lifetime performance.
Benefits withheld under the earnings test are not simply lost. At full retirement age, Social Security recalculates the monthly benefit to account for months in which payments were withheld. That can raise later checks, but it does not replace the cash flow the founder expected this year.
Where This Collides With the Rest of Retirement
Three pieces of the retirement picture now pull against one another. Claiming at 62 permanently lowered his starting benefit by approximately 30% compared with waiting until 67. The 2.8% cost-of-living adjustment (COLA) for 2026 raised that reduced check only modestly. Now the earnings test can withhold some or all of those checks during the distillery’s comeback year.
There is a bitter irony in the timing. The business finally produces the income he spent years waiting for, and that success interrupts the Social Security payments that helped him survive the lean period. His CPA can be correct that the NOL softened the regular income-tax impact. Social Security can also be correct that the current profit exceeds its earnings limit. The two conclusions answer different questions.
What to Think Through Before the Next Filing
Before the next profitable year goes into the books, three steps can keep the comeback from becoming a cash-flow surprise:
- Calculate the Social Security number separately. Ask the accountant to estimate current net earnings from self-employment without applying the prior-year NOL carryforward. Compare that figure with the current earnings-test limit.
- Report the expected earnings before SSA discovers them later. Updating the estimate can allow benefits to be withheld on a planned schedule and reduce the risk of an overpayment notice demanding money back.
- Plan future income legitimately. Billing schedules, equipment purchases and other business decisions may affect the calendar, but they must reflect real business activity. At 63, simply asking Social Security to suspend benefits is generally not an available escape hatch.
The distillery’s old losses still matter for income taxes. They do not give its owner a credit against this year’s Social Security earnings test. When the comeback finally arrives, both ledgers need to be modeled before anyone starts pouring a celebratory glass.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.
Top Gaining Stocks
Top Losing Stocks