After closing at $71.01 on February 20, iShares Silver Trust (NYSEARCA:SLV) had posted a 11% gain over the past week, heading into Friday, when multiple news events were likely to affect the market. That bounce follows a brutal stretch for silver that saw the metal collapse sharply after Trump nominated Kevin Warsh as the next Fed chair. The dollar surged, safe-haven demand evaporated, and retail traders who’d ridden silver’s 145% one-year rally scrambled for the exits.
The social sentiment tells a contradictory story as Reddit chatter around SLV has turned decidedly bearish, with sentiment scores sliding from 50.49 over the quarter to just 40.59 this past week. That’s neutral territory tilting negative, yet the price is climbing anyway.
The Puts Capitulation Trade
Head over to r/wallstreetbets, and you’ll find the dominant narrative isn’t bullish conviction. It puts capitulation as traders who bet against silver are now posting their losses and admitting they pushed their luck too far. One recent post titled “SLV puts capitulation, shouldn’t have pushed my luck” captured 83 upvotes and 62 comments. The post describes a trader closing out a short position at a loss after holding too long through silver’s recovery.
SLV puts capitulation, shouldn’t have pushed my luck
by r/wallstreetbets user in wallstreetbets
Another from earlier in February, “16K gain on SLV puts in 30 minutes,” went viral with 1,676 upvotes. That post detailed a rapid-fire options win on silver’s decline following the Warsh nomination, with the trader closing the position within half an hour for a substantial profit.
16K gain on SLV puts in 30 minutes
by r/wallstreetbets user in wallstreetbets
The pattern here matters. When traders who’ve been shorting an asset start closing positions and admitting defeat, that forced buying can push prices higher even when sentiment remains sour. It’s mechanical, not emotional.
What’s Actually Driving Silver Now
The Warsh nomination spooked precious metals because he’s viewed as hawkish and committed to Fed independence. That strengthened the dollar and crushed the theory that metals would replace the greenback as a reserve currency. But silver didn’t stay down. After bottoming near $69.72 last week, it’s clawed back over 5%.
Ultimately, silver’s industrial demand profile spans solar panels, electronics, and EV components, and the scope of this demand provides a fundamental floor that other purely monetary metals lack. Whether the current recovery holds depends on whether the dollar keeps climbing and whether the Fed maintains its hawkish stance under Warsh, factors that weigh directly on real yields and dollar-denominated commodity prices.
For now, SLV sits 13.82% above where it started the year, but still 12.67% below where it traded a month ago. The Reddit crowd is betting against it with puts, but some of those bets are now unwinding, so the future is wide open.
Top Gaining Stocks
Top Losing Stocks