Heading into 2020, Americans were riding one of the strongest waves of economic optimism in years. Unemployment hovered near historic lows, consumer confidence was elevated, and the expansion appeared to have room to run.
Then Covid-19 abruptly shut down the economy. Massive fiscal stimulus distorted the pandemic’s impact, while also igniting the inflation surge that followed, leaving households grappling with higher prices for everything from groceries to gasoline long after the pandemic ended.
For investors, that history still matters. Economic sentiment often shapes consumer spending, corporate earnings, and, ultimately, election outcomes. Gallup’s long-running Economic Confidence Index offers a revealing window into how Americans view the economy, and its latest readings suggest that while confidence recovered briefly after President Trump’s 2024 election victory, renewed geopolitical turmoil has once again darkened the outlook.
Economic Confidence Has Never Fully Recovered
In January 2020, the Economic Confidence Index stood at +40, and ticked higher to +41 in February before the pandemic arrived. Within two months, the index had collapsed to -33 as lockdowns spread across the country. Confidence gradually recovered as businesses reopened, even briefly turning positive in 2021.
Ironically, the economic recovery created its own problem. Successive rounds of stimulus payments, combined with supply chain disruptions and surging consumer demand, ignited the highest inflation in four decades. Confidence deteriorated again, bottoming at -58 in June 2022 — even worse than the depths reached during the pandemic itself.
Trump’s return to the White House after the 2024 election sparked another improvement. Gallup’s index climbed from -26 in October 2024 to -14 by June 2025, suggesting voters expected policy changes to improve the economy. Yet optimism never returned to pre-pandemic territory as inflation, elevated gasoline prices, and high interest rates continued weighing on household budgets.
Iran Conflict Revives Economic Anxiety
However, after the start of the Iran conflict, Gallup’s index slid from -20 in February to -45 in May, worse than any reading recorded since 2022. Following a temporary ceasefire, confidence improved to -31 in July, but Gallup noted its survey was conducted primarily before renewed hostilities pushed oil and gasoline prices higher again. That timing is key.
If higher energy prices persist — and pump prices of $4.11 a gallon are well above the psychologically important $4 threshold — Americans will once again feel the squeeze every time they fill their gas tank. Consumer sentiment has historically responded quickly to gasoline prices because they are among the most visible household expenses.
For investors, weakening confidence also raises questions about discretionary spending, corporate earnings growth, and whether businesses become more cautious heading into 2027.
Independents Could Decide The Midterms
The political implications may be even more noteworthy. Gallup found Republicans’ economic confidence jumped to +41 in July from +22 in May, while Democrats remained deeply pessimistic at -76, little changed from -80.
The swing group, however, remains independents. Their confidence improved from -58 to -38, but that’s still deeply negative despite the temporary truce. Independents have consistently played an outsized role in determining control of Congress, making their outlook one of the more closely watched political indicators.
With the midterm elections a little more than three months away, the old Clinton campaign mantra — “It’s the economy, stupid” — feels as relevant as ever.
Key Takeaway
In short, Gallup’s latest survey offers a reminder that economic perceptions can shift faster than economic fundamentals. The modest rebound in the index suggests Americans welcomed lower energy prices during the ceasefire, but overall confidence remains far below pre-pandemic levels. Because the survey largely preceded the latest jump in oil and gasoline prices, the next reading could reveal whether renewed geopolitical tensions have erased that improvement.
For investors, that’s worth watching. Consumer confidence influences spending, earnings, and market sentiment, while history shows prolonged economic dissatisfaction often creates headwinds for incumbent parties. Whether those political consequences materialize remains uncertain, but the economic backdrop heading into November is more fragile than the headline improvement suggests.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.
Top Gaining Stocks
Top Losing Stocks