Disney Is the Cheaper Stock, but Home Depot Pays the Bigger Dividend. Which Is Better for Retirees?
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
Should a retirement-focused investor own Walt Disney (NYSE:DIS | DIS Price Prediction) or Home Depot (NYSE:HD) right now? Disney is cheaper on forward earnings, but on trailing GAAP earnings the two trade at almost the same multiple. Home Depot’s dividend yield is about double Disney’s. Across valuation, income and long-term track record, Home Depot wins two of the three categories, and those two matter most to retirees.
Valuation: Disney Wins on Forward Earnings
The price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio shows how many dollars investors pay for each dollar of annual profit. A lower number generally means a cheaper stock. Based on next-year earnings estimates, Disney trades at a forward P/E of 16, compared with 22 for Home Depot. Disney also costs less on enterprise value to EBITDA, at 12 versus 16, and on price-to-book, at 1.87 versus 20.94.
On trailing earnings, the gap goes away. Disney’s trailing P/E of 25 is about the same as Home Depot’s 24. The main reason is fiscal third-quarter net income, which dropped 49.9% from a year earlier to $2.64 billion. Still, Disney’s discount appears supported by improving operations. Disney+/Hulu subscription operating income more than doubled to $712 million, and Experiences operating income rose 20%. In its fiscal third-quarter report, Disney guided to about 16% adjusted EPS growth for fiscal 2026 (including a 53rd week). Home Depot guides to growth of flat to 4%. Winner: Disney.
Income: Home Depot Pays More and Pays Reliably
Dividend yield is the annual dividend divided by the share price. It is the cash you collect each year just for holding the stock. Home Depot pays $9.32 a year in quarterly installments, a yield of about 2.7%. Disney pays $1.50 in two semi-annual payments, a yield of about 1.3%.
Disney’s dividend is better covered. It uses about 30.9% of trailing EPS and about 25.7% of fiscal 2025 free cash flow. Home Depot pays out about 65.2% of trailing EPS and about 73.5% of fiscal 2025 free cash flow of $12.65 billion. Payment history determines this round. Disney’s dividend records show no payments between the December 2019 and December 2023 ex-dividend dates. Home Depot’s quarterly records run from 1999 through 2026, and its February raise of 1.3% marked its 156th consecutive quarterly dividend. The small size of that raise shows how little room the payout ratio leaves. Winner: Home Depot.
Track Record: Home Depot by a Wide Margin
| Period | Disney | Home Depot |
|---|---|---|
| 1 year | 12.42% | −1.8% |
| 5 years | −22.96% | 7.1% |
| 10 years | 32.47% | 260.7% |
Disney has led over the past year as streaming turned profitable. Over longer periods, it lags well behind. Those years included heavy streaming investment and the dividend suspension. Home Depot compounded through a decade of home improvement demand, and its quarterly dividend rose from $0.69 in 2016 to $2.33. Housing is now a drag. The CFO said housing turnover “has never been lower as a percentage of the housing stock.” Even so, Home Depot’s beta of 0.947 is well below Disney’s 1.426, so its shares tend to swing less than the market while Disney’s swing more. Winner: Home Depot.
Verdict: Home Depot Is the Retirement Stock
Home Depot fits income investors better. It offers about twice Disney’s yield, pays every quarter, has a dividend record without the four-year gap in Disney’s history, and has a less volatile stock. The higher payout ratio and slow housing market will likely keep dividend increases modest. A reliable, rising check still matters more to someone living on portfolio income than a lower multiple does. (Building a ladder of payers like this, so the dividends cover the bills and the shares stay put, is the whole subject of our free guide.)
Disney fits a different investor: someone at least a decade from retirement who cares more about earnings growth and buybacks than current income. Management had targeted at least $9 billion in fiscal 2026 repurchases and expected double-digit adjusted EPS growth in fiscal 2027. For that patient owner, the forward discount gives Disney more upside. For a retiree focused on income, Home Depot’s dividend profile lines up more closely with that goal.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.






