‘He says it’s only 1%’: I’m 65 with $1.2 million in three index funds. My wife wants to hand it to an adviser. I say that’s $12,000 a year. Who’s right?
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
I retired in June after 38 years as a mechanical engineer. I’m 65. My wife is 63 and left her job at the school library two years ago. We have $1.2 million: $950,000 in my rollover IRA and $250,000 in a joint brokerage account, all of it in three index funds I picked in 1996 and have rebalanced every January since. The house is paid off. We take $3,750 a month from the portfolio and will take less when my Social Security starts at 67.
Last month her sister’s husband sent us to his adviser. Nice office, a glass wall, a bowl of mints, and a chart of our “retirement income path” that looked a lot like my spreadsheet. On the drive home she said, “He says it’s only 1%.” I did the arithmetic at the first red light. One percent of $1.2 million is $12,000 a year. That’s $1,000 a month, more than our property tax and the car insurance together. Over 30 years I make it more than $350,000. It’s $1,000 a month for a phone number.
She didn’t argue with the numbers. She asked, “What happens to me if you go first?” My spreadsheet has 14 tabs. She has never opened it and says she never will. She wants someone she can call who knows our names.
I think the fee will eat our retirement. She thinks my pride will leave her alone with a spreadsheet. Who’s right?
You are both right, about two different things
The fee is charged on the whole balance every year, in up markets and down, whether you call him or not. It compounds against you, because every dollar paid in fees is a dollar that stops earning. Jack Bogle, Vanguard’s founder, put it in one line in 2007: “the miracle of compounding returns is overwhelmed by the tyranny of compounding costs.”
A 1% fee reads as small because it is quoted as a percentage; on your balance it is $12,000 in the first year, and it keeps coming out of money that would otherwise compound. It is also the price of the thing your wife is asking for, and I will get to that.
Here are your numbers. I assumed the portfolio earns 6% a year before costs, your three index funds cost 0.08% a year, you draw $45,000 in year one and raise it 2.5% a year for inflation, and the plan runs 30 years, to 95.
| Over 30 years | Do it yourself | 0.30% advice service | Flat-fee planner, $4,000 a year | Adviser at 1% |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fee in year one | $0 | $3,600 | $4,000 | $12,000 |
| Fees paid over 30 years | $0 | $127,938 | $175,611 | $355,096 |
| Balance at 95 | $1,835,837 | $1,496,551 | $1,400,103 | $833,471 |
Your $350,000 estimate is right on the fees. What you missed is the growth those fees never earned. At 95 the portfolio is about $1 million smaller with the adviser than without him, and the fee takes about a quarter of what you draw each year ($12,000 against $45,000).
One small softener. Most of the fee ($9,500 of the $12,000) would come out of the IRA, and the IRS treats a fee paid straight from the IRA as an expense of the account rather than a withdrawal, so in the 22% bracket that $9,500 costs about $7,410 of spendable money. Advisory fees have not been deductible since 2018, and the 2025 tax law kept it that way.
Now her side, which is stronger than you think
The honest case for paying an adviser was made by Vanguard’s own research team, in a paper it updated in July 2022. It estimates that a good adviser can add “up to, or even exceed, 3% in net returns,” with the largest piece, 1 to 2 percentage points, from what it calls behavioral coaching: keeping clients from abandoning their plan. On $1.2 million that is $12,000 to $24,000 a year. The same paper says the gain “should not be viewed as an annual value-add but is likely to be intermittent,” arriving “during periods of market duress or euphoria.”
With your numbers: say you hold 60% in stocks, $720,000, and a year like 2008 arrives, when the S&P 500 lost 36.55% with dividends included. Your stock side falls to $456,840. If you sell to cash at the bottom and sit out a year like 2009, when the index gained 25.94%, you miss $118,504 of recovery. That one decision costs about ten years of the adviser’s fee. You have held three index funds through 2000, 2008, 2020 and 2022, so you may be the rare client who never needs the coaching.
She is asking who manages $1.2 million when the man who built the spreadsheet is gone, or is 84 and no longer sharp. The odds say she will be the one holding this money at the end, and “I’ll figure it out” is a plan she cannot open.
The verdict
You are right about the price. She is right about the problem. The mistake would be to let the price decide the problem.
Pay for the problem at the problem’s price. Kitces Research, which surveys advisers on their fees, puts the median at 1% of assets up to $1 million, and the median retainer or subscription fee for advice without asset management at $4,000 a year in its 2020 study and $4,500 in 2024. A flat-fee planner at $4,000 a year, rising with inflation, costs $175,611 over 30 years and leaves about $1,400,000 at 95, against $833,471 under the 1% adviser. A 0.30% service that assigns a planner does nearly as well. Either gives your wife a name and a number. Keep the three index funds.
Two things this month. Write one page that says what you own, where it is, what to draw and whom to call, and put it where she keeps the car title. And ask her sister’s adviser for his fee in dollars and a list of what it buys. If it is $12,000 a year to hold a portfolio you already own, you have your answer. If it includes a written plan, a tax strategy for the IRA withdrawals and a person who will know her name in 2040, she may have hers.
A fight about 1% is usually a fight about who will be left to make the calls. Settle that one and the percentage takes care of itself.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.








