Gold Just Sank to a One-Year Low. Costco Members Who Bought Bars in September Are Down About $700 Each, and Launch Buyers Are Still Up 88%
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
A 67-year-old retired engineer who bought two one-ounce gold bars from Costco in September paid $4,459.99 each. On Wednesday each bar was worth about $700 less than it cost, after gold fell to its lowest price in more than a year. Spot gold was at $3,725.26 an ounce Wednesday evening, down 3.2% on the day and its lowest price since September 2025, and silver was at $45.22. The selling followed comments on Tuesday from New York Fed President John Williams that the central bank will likely need to raise rates again, which lifted the dollar to a 19-month high.
He is a scenario, built from Costco’s own listing prices as reported on the days he bought, and he has company. Costco has sold one-ounce gold bars to members since the late summer of 2023, online only, and it does not take them back. The listing on costco.com says “Item is Non-Refundable,” and Costco does not buy gold from members. The drop is a warning that the easiest gold to buy in America can lose money like any other gold; the limit is that a member who bought in the first two years is still far ahead, because gold at $3,725 is where it traded in September 2025, and the launch price was $1,979.99.
This retiree bought at every wave, two bars each time: at launch, in the quarter Costco first put a number on its gold sales, the week the two-bar limit arrived, and in September. Eight bars, four prices, one spot price on Wednesday. The money he has at stake, what each pair is worth now, the way out and the tax bill are below.
How much gold Costco moves
Costco’s first words on the bars came on its Sept. 26, 2023 earnings call, when then-CFO Richard Galanti said, “When we load them on the site, they’re typically gone within a few hours and we limit two per member.” That December he told analysts, “We sold over $100 million of gold during the quarter,” the 12 weeks ended Nov. 26, 2023. At the $2,069.99 listing price that month, that is about 48,000 one-ounce bars, roughly $1.2 million of gold a day.
In April 2024, Wells Fargo analyst Edward Kelly estimated the sales “may now be running at” $100 million to $200 million a month, at about 2% over the spot price, and called it “a very low-profit business at best” for Costco. With a bar then listed at just more than $2,400, that range is about 42,000 to 83,000 bars a month. Costco has not put a dollar figure on gold since. On its March 5, 2026 call, CFO Gary Millerchip said “gold bars have been a great example” of a tailwind, for the interest and website traffic they bring. On the Sept. 24 call, gold and jewelry was again a top-performing department, and the quarter’s Kirkland Signature launches included one-ounce silver bars. Costco ended its fiscal year with 84.1 million paid members, 42.3 million of them Executive.
The rule on the listing today reads: “Limit of 1 Transaction Per Membership, with a Maximum of 4 Units Per 24 Hours.” At Wednesday’s spot price, four bars is about $15,000 of gold a day per membership. The limit was two per member at launch, five a day in early 2025, and two a day from May 16, 2025.
Four waves of buyers, one price today
The prices below are Costco’s listed member price for the PAMP Suisse Lady Fortuna one-ounce bar on each date, as reported at the time by KTLA, CNBC, Fox 4 and Moneywise. Each pair of bars is worth $7,450.52 at Wednesday’s $3,725.26 spot price.
| Bought | Costco price a bar | Two bars cost | Difference at today’s spot |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sept. 27, 2023 (launch) | $1,979.99 | $3,959.98 | +$3,490.54 |
| Dec. 15, 2023 (the $100 million quarter) | $2,069.99 | $4,139.98 | +$3,310.54 |
| May 19, 2025 (the two-bar limit) | $3,389.99 | $6,779.98 | +$670.54 |
| Sept. 11, 2026 | $4,459.99 | $8,919.98 | -$1,469.46 |
| All eight bars | average $2,974.99 | $23,799.92 | +$6,002.16 |
The launch bars have nearly doubled: $1,745.27 ahead each, or 88%. The May 2025 bars are 10% ahead. The September bars are $734.73 under water each, about $700 a bar, or $1,469.46 on the pair. Across all eight he paid $23,799.92 for gold worth $29,802.08, a 25% gain, on an average cost of $2,974.99 a bar.
SPDR Gold Shares, the largest gold fund, closed at a record $495.90 on Jan. 29, 2026 and closed at $341.19 on Wednesday, 31% lower, according to Alpha Vantage data. By the fund’s ratio to spot, his first six bars were worth about $32,500 at that record and are worth $22,351.56 today. He gave back about $10,000 on paper in under ten months without selling a bar.
The premium, the rebate and the way out
Costco’s listed price ran $49.41 over spot on Dec. 15, 2023, about 2.4%, by CNBC’s figures that day, and about $160 over on Sept. 11, about 3.7%, by the prices Moneywise reported. Executive members get 2% back and the Costco Anywhere Visa by Citi returns another 2% on Costco purchases, so the September bar sends $178.40 back, which covers the premium. On the way in, a member pays close to spot.
The way out is the harder side. Costco will not take a bar back at any price, so selling means a coin dealer, a refiner or a private buyer, and dealers buy below spot. The September bars need gold back above $4,459.99, plus whatever the buyer takes off, before they break even. The launch bars could lose half their gain and still be ahead.
The tax side
Gold bars are collectibles to the IRS. Topic 409 puts the maximum rate on long-term gains from selling collectibles at 28%, against 15% or 20% for most stock gains. If the member sold the launch pair at spot, the gain is $3,490.54 and the tax at the 28% ceiling is $977.35; many retirees fall in a lower bracket and pay less, because 28% is the ceiling. Selling the September pair would realize a $1,469.46 loss that offsets gains first, and up to $3,000 a year of net loss can come off ordinary income, with the rest carried forward. The order confirmation from costco.com is the cost basis record; keep it with the bar.
What a member should know when gold drops
The bar is the same bar. A one-ounce PAMP bar from Costco is the product a dealer sells, in the same assay card. The price Costco charged on the day is history; what matters now is spot and the buyer’s bid.
Size it against everything else. For a couple with $2.4 million in retirement accounts, these eight bars are about 1.2% of the money, and the $10,000 paper drawdown from gold’s record is about 0.4% of it. That is the number to measure this week’s fall against, and it is why the member can hold without doing anything.
Decide the share before the next listing. The four-bar daily limit makes it easy to add $15,000 of gold in an afternoon. Where gold goes from here is a call nobody can make. The decision a member controls is how much of the whole gold should be, and whether a lower price changes that, which it usually should not.
Know the exit before you need it. Get a buy quote from two dealers now, while nothing is urgent, so the spread is known. A sale at a loss can be useful in a year with other gains; a sale of the launch bars carries a 28% ceiling on the gain.
The bottom line
Costco turned a one-ounce gold bar into a routine purchase, and Wednesday’s fall is the first real test for the members who bought at the top of the run. The member in this story is up $6,002.16 on $23,799.92 of bars overall, under water on the pair he bought in September, and about $10,000 below where his gold sat in January. None of that changes the bar in his safe. The questions worth answering tonight are how large gold should be in the whole plan, what a dealer will pay, and what the tax bill would be on the lot that is ahead.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.






