PayPal Is Up More Than 40% From Its 52-Week Low, but $1,000 From Five Years Ago Is Worth Less Than $350
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
If you’ve held the stock through the past year, the recent bounce probably feels like relief. PayPal (NASDAQ:PYPL | PYPL Price Prediction) trades at $57.91, up 51.92% from its 52-week low of $38.12. Over five years, the picture changes: $1,000 invested back then is worth about $303 today.
From Pandemic Darling to a Five-Year Slide
PayPal spun off from eBay (NASDAQ:EBAY) in July 2015 and rode the digital-payments boom to a late-2021 peak near $300. After that, Apple Pay, Shop Pay and Stripe chipped away at checkout, active account growth stalled and margins contracted. The CEO job changed hands too, going from Dan Schulman to Alex Chriss, then to interim chief Jamie Miller, and finally to Enrique Lores.
The low point came with Q4 2025 results, when non-GAAP EPS of $1.23[1] missed the $1.29 consensus and management said it had fallen short in branded checkout. The stock sat at $42.20[1] when those results were filed.
Three Straight Beats Fueled the Rebound
Since then, PayPal has beaten EPS estimates for three straight quarters. In Q3, non-GAAP EPS hit $1.45[2] against a $1.31 estimate, and full-year guidance rose to about $5.60 from $5.38. Venmo’s payment volume has grown double digits for the eighth consecutive quarter[3], and buybacks cut the diluted share count from 960M to 858M[2]. Jim Cramer also said in August that the stock jumped in July after PayPal reportedly received a takeover overture from Stripe, backed by private equity firm Advent International. The two companies would abandon their pursuit in late August.
Your $1,000 Shrank to $303 Over Five Years
1-Year Return
- Initial Investment: $1,000
- Current Value: $996.30
- Total Return: -0.37%
- S&P 500 (same period): $1,119.40 (11.94%)
5-Year Return
- Initial Investment: $1,000
- Current Value: $303
- Total Return: -69.75%
- Annualized Return: -21.27%
- S&P 500 (same period): $1,575.90 (57.59%)
10-Year Return
- Initial Investment: $1,000
- Current Value: $1,424.80
- Total Return: 42.48%
- Annualized Return: 3.60%
- S&P 500 (same period): $3,381.80 (238.18%)
Your result depended almost entirely on when you bought. Buyers in late 2021 paid pandemic-era prices right before e-commerce growth cooled, and holding on meant sitting through years of shrinking value. Ten-year holders are still ahead, but they trailed the index by a wide margin. The one-year number came out about flat because the stock fell to its low partway through the year and then climbed back.
I’d Want Proof Beyond Buybacks
The bull case rests on Venmo, Braintree and financial services continuing to grow and carrying the company toward management’s goal of solid double-digit EPS growth over time[3]. At about 10x this year’s EPS guidance, that result isn’t priced in much.
The bear case gains weight if branded checkout stays stuck in the 1%-2%[3] growth range and revenue keeps missing expectations, as it did in Q3 at $8.58B[2] versus $8.71B. Active accounts barely moved at 440 million, so buybacks are doing a lot of the work.
The current price already reflects a lot of bad news, though a lasting recovery in the share price likely depends on checkout growth.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.



