U.S. Home Sales Just Hit Their Lowest Level in 25 Years. Is the Housing Market Breaking?
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
In October, Americans signed fewer contracts to buy existing homes than in any month since the National Association of Realtors began tracking them 25 years ago. NAR’s Pending Home Sales Index fell 4.7% to 63.0, the lowest reading since records began in 2001. Contracts were down 16.7% from a year earlier. All four regions declined, led by the West (-6.9%) and the South (-6.3%).
Pending sales usually turn into completions one to two months later, which is roughly how long financing and title take. Completions are already falling. Existing home sales ran at a 3.75 million annualized pace in October, down 5.5% from September. That was the lowest reading of the past year. NAR chief economist Lawrence Yun warned that annual existing-home sales could fall to their weakest level since the mid-1990s.
Eight Months of Rising Rates Froze the Market
Higher borrowing costs caused this. Freddie Mac’s average 30-year fixed rate was 5.98%[1] in late February. It topped out at 7.4%[1] on October 15 and was 7.28% on November 19. The 10-year Treasury yield, which mortgage rates track, hit 5.31% in early October. Lennar (NYSE:LEN | LEN Price Prediction) CEO Stuart Miller tied the rise in rates to inflation “driven by geopolitical tension and higher oil prices.”[2]
High rates hit both sides of a sale. Owners with cheaper mortgages stay put, and many buyers can no longer qualify. Miller said in many Lennar markets “almost 50% of our visitors cannot immediately qualify.” The University of Michigan’s consumer sentiment index was 48.0 in October.
Builders Are Cutting Prices While Homeowners Hold Out
Sales volume is cracking, but home values are holding up. The Case-Shiller National Home Price Index read 336.7 in August, just below its July high. The discounting is happening at homebuilders, and it shows up in their profits.
D.R. Horton (NYSE:DHI) reported fiscal fourth-quarter EPS of $2.67[3], missing expectations of $3.00. Net orders fell 7%[3], and cancellations rose to 23% from 20%. The builder pays to lower its customers’ mortgage rates, and these buydowns run about 1.5 points below market[4]. CEO Paul Romanowski said “anticipating rates to go down is not prudent at all.”[4]
Lennar is in deeper trouble. In the third quarter, its gross margin on home sales fell to 15.8%[2] from 17.5%, and net income dropped 51.96%. It also cut its full-year delivery target to 80,000 to 81,000[2] homes. Miller said the company is choosing volume over profit: “We are compromising margin in order to maintain volume.” Lennar shares are down 19.71% this year. D.R. Horton shares are up 2.24%.
Home Depot Shows Owners Choosing Small Fixes
Home Depot (NYSE:HD) shows how the freeze plays out inside existing homes. Third-quarter comparable sales rose 2.2%, but customer transactions fell 0.5% while the average ticket climbed to $93.09. Fewer, larger trips fit owners who are staying put, taking on smaller projects and delaying big renovations. Management says it sees no clear turning point for housing turnover.
Watch Builder Margins Before Home Prices
The housing market is frozen, and home values are holding up. Home prices fall broadly when owners are forced to sell. Record-low contract volume shows owners are choosing to wait instead. Three signals to watch next:
- Whether D.R. Horton’s first-quarter gross margin holds its 18% to 18.5%[4] guidance.
- Whether Lennar’s fourth-quarter margin lands inside its 15.5% to 16.0%[2] guidance.
- Whether Case-Shiller posts a year-over-year fall. That would turn a sales problem into a price problem.
As long as mortgage rates stay above 7%, builders will keep giving up profit to keep homes selling.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.







