If you own YieldMax MSTR Option Income Strategy ETF (NYSEARCA:MSTY), you are paying taxes on shrinking distributions while your principal quietly disappears. Over the past year, the fund’s share price has fallen 67.45%, and the weekly checks (that were the whole reason to own it) have collapsed from a peak of $4.4213 per share in November 2024 to $0.2222 on July 30, 2026.
What You’re Actually Paying
MSTY’s stated expense ratio is 1.03%. That is $103 per year per $10,000 invested, before you factor in any of the strategy’s structural costs. A diversified covered-call ETF like JPMorgan Nasdaq Equity Premium Income ETF (NASDAQ:JEPQ) charges roughly a third of that. On the same $10,000, JEPQ’s fee runs about $35 a year. Held for 20 years, that fee gap alone is roughly $1,360 in headline expenses, and that ignores the compounding drag on returns.
The fee is a smaller problem, especially when compared to the fund’s tax inefficiencies. YieldMax’s own prospectus language notes distributions are “generally taxable as ordinary income, qualified dividend income, or capital gains (or a combination)”, and most of MSTY’s payouts land in the ordinary-income bucket. If you sit in a 32% federal tax bracket and hold MSTY in a taxable account, the fund’s trailing 12-month payout of $15.6569 per share generated a real tax bill, even as the share price fell to $12.51.
The Part the Factsheet Doesn’t Highlight
MSTY sells calls on MicroStrategy (NASDAQ:MSTR | MSTR Price Prediction), a single-stock proxy for Bitcoin. That is the entire portfolio. When MSTR fell 74.13% over the past year, MSTY ate the drawdown on the downside while its written calls capped any bounce. The YieldMax prospectus is explicit on the mechanics: “gains on the Underlying Security above the strike price(s) of the sold calls are generally expected to be reduced or foregone.”
Additionally, there is a second, quieter cost. The same prospectus warns that “a portion (sometimes significant) of the Fund’s distributions may be classified as return of capital”. Return of capital is the fund handing you back your own money, then reducing your cost basis, so a future sale can trigger a bigger capital gain. Combined with weekly options rolls, which the prospectus flags may produce “high portfolio turnover” and higher taxes in taxable accounts, the yield you see on the marketing page is not the yield you keep.
The Cheaper Mirror
If the goal is a covered-call income ETF, JEPQ writes calls against a diversified Nasdaq-100 book instead of one volatile stock. Multiple analyses of MSTY have named JEPQ specifically as the more stable alternative. The trade-off is clear: JEPQ will not print a headline yield near MSTY’s advertised 64.53%, but it also does not concentrate 100% of your risk in a single Bitcoin-linked equity that has moved -5.86% in the last month alone. For pure MSTR exposure at a fraction of the cost, owning MSTR shares directly carries no expense ratio and defers taxes until you sell.
What This Means for You
Before your next MSTY distribution hits, ask a simpler question than “what is the yield?” Ask: what did the share price do this year, what tax rate will apply to the payout, and how much of it is return of my own capital?
MSTY is down 32.12% year to date. If a distribution shrinks while your basis shrinks and the IRS still wants ordinary-income rates, the “income” label is doing a lot of work.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.
Top Gaining Stocks
Top Losing Stocks