On a recent Women & Money episode, Suze Orman took a call from Teresa, a 67-year-old California teacher retiring next year with roughly $600,000 across a 403(b) and 457, $200,000 in a CD, $30,000 in savings, and a $16,000 house emergency fund. Teresa wanted permission to buy her first real luxury handbag, a $1,500 to $3,000 piece from The Row, Bottega Veneta, or Chanel, after a lifetime where her priciest bag was a $259 Dooney & Bourke. Suze’s response cut straight to the psychology behind the purchase:
“Why at this point in your life do you want a designer bag? If it were me, I would not be doing it. But more important than you buying the bag, I want you to understand why.”
The Verdict: Suze Is Right, But Not for the Reason You Think
Teresa has a pension arriving, six figures in tax-advantaged accounts, a fully funded CD ladder, and a separate house emergency reserve. A one-time $2,000 purchase fits comfortably against that balance sheet. Suze’s concern is behavioral, and it lands because of when Teresa is asking.
As Suze put it: “Usually, especially women, when they approach retirement and they know income is going to stop, rather than spend, that’s when they take their money and they want to save, save, save. But not you.”
That reversal matters. The month a paycheck stops is the month every dollar shifts from “replaceable” to “finite.” A luxury purchase feels different at 67 with one year of earned income left than it does at 45 with two decades of paychecks ahead. Suze was explicit that if Teresa were 40 or 50, she would say go ahead. At 67, she wants Teresa to name the reason.
The Math on a $600,000 Nest Egg
At a 4% safe withdrawal rate, $600,000 generates roughly $24,000 a year in portfolio income. Add Teresa’s pension and Social Security, which just received a 2.8% cost-of-living adjustment for 2026, and she likely has a workable retirement budget. But inflation is quietly eating the fixed pieces.
The Fed’s preferred gauge, core PCE, sits at 130.08 as of May 2026, up from 126.43 a year earlier. The $200,000 CD is likely earning close to the roughly 2% national average 12-month CD rate, well below the inflation rate. Every year Teresa’s CD money loses real purchasing power. That is the invisible tax that makes discretionary spending decisions in year one of retirement matter more than the dollar amount suggests.
Run your own numbers and the point becomes concrete: one $2,500 bag is affordable inside this plan. Twenty $2,500 decisions across a 25-year retirement are the risk.
The Smarter Path KT Offered
Co-host KT, who spent years in the luxury industry, gave the most actionable answer: “If I were you, I would go to a consignment store or some of these online secondhand opportunities where you can get a beautiful designer bag for pennies on the dollar. And then you satisfy both needs.”
The secondhand luxury market is now deep and authenticated. The RealReal, Fashionphile, Vestiaire Collective, and Rebag routinely list Bottega and Chanel pieces at 40% to 60% below retail, with authentication guarantees. Teresa could own the same bag she described for closer to $1,000, keep the difference in her portfolio, and skip the retail markup entirely.
What Teresa, and You, Should Actually Do
Before any large discretionary purchase in the year before retirement, work through this checklist:
- Name the “why” out loud. Is it a milestone marker for a career you are proud of? A hedge against feeling invisible in retirement? An impulse triggered by having “enough” on paper for the first time? Suze’s point was that the answer determines whether the purchase will feel good in five years.
- Price the same item on the secondhand market first. Fashionphile, The RealReal, and Rebag list authenticated inventory with condition grades. A save of $1,000 to $1,500 on the same bag is arbitrage.
- Run a real withdrawal projection. Plug your balance, pension, and Social Security into a retirement calculator before the purchase. If a $2,500 bag changes the outcome meaningfully, the issue is your savings runway, not the handbag.
- Move idle cash to work. Teresa’s $200,000 CD at the national average is losing to inflation. Top-yielding online CDs and Treasury bills currently pay multiples of the FDIC national average. Rate shopping a fixed-income sleeve is worth far more than any single purchase decision.
Suze’s answer was to know why. That is the more useful lesson for anyone one paycheck away from a fixed-income retirement.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.
Top Gaining Stocks
Top Losing Stocks