John Rogers, founder of Ariel Investments, built his reputation on patient, long-horizon value investing in quality small and mid-cap businesses that are temporarily unloved or misunderstood. Rogers prefers durable franchises with strong brands, buys them when sentiment is poor, and holds through years of doubt while the market catches up. That approach can be powerful, but it does not automatically make every contrarian name appropriate for a retiree who needs income reliability, business predictability, and lower volatility.
The three stocks below all sit somewhere on Rogers’ contrarian spectrum. The question for a retirement-focused investor is narrower: which of these out-of-favor names actually pays investors to wait, and which requires nerves a 70-year-old may not want to test? We rank them from least to most appropriate for a retirement portfolio.
3. Envista
Envista (NYSE: NVST | NVST Price Prediction) is the purest Rogers-style turnaround in this group, and that is precisely why it ranks last for a retiree. The dental products maker behind Nobel Biocare, Ormco, Kerr, DEXIS, and Spark has been a multi-year laggard, with shares down 37.9% over five years and closing at $27.02 on June 29, 2026.
The operating recovery is underway. Q1 FY2026 delivered adjusted EPS of $0.36 versus $0.31 expected, revenue of $705.5 million, up 14.4% year over year, and adjusted EBITDA growth of 25%. CEO Paul Keel called it a “good start to 2026” with 9.5% core revenue growth. Management authorized a fresh $300 million buyback through the end of 2029.
The retirement caveats are significant. Envista pays no dividend, trades at a trailing P/E near 66x (forward P/E 20x), and carries the highest beta of the three at 0.886. CEO Paul Keel also disposed of 12,811 shares at $23.43 on May 25, 2026. The contrarian thesis holds, while the income and stability profile remains weak.
2. MSG Entertainment
Madison Square Garden Entertainment (NYSE: MSGE) owns truly irreplaceable assets: Madison Square Garden, Radio City Music Hall, the Beacon Theatre, the Chicago Theatre, the Christmas Spectacular, and the Rockettes. That is exactly the kind of durable franchise Rogers favors. Shares closed at $80.95 on June 29, 2026, up 99.9% over the past year and 50.2% year to date.
Q3 FY2026 was mixed. EPS came in at $0.11 versus $0.18 expected, missing by 38.89%, while revenue of $246.26 million edged estimates. SG&A rose 17%, and an $8.62 million restructuring charge pressured operating income. Cash grew to $323.65 million, up 264% year over year, and the prior quarter’s Christmas Spectacular drew 1.2 million tickets across 215 paid performances, the highest in 25 years. CEO James Dolan said demand “remains strong” with Harry Styles and Bon Jovi residencies on the books.
For a retiree, the issues are familiar: no dividend, a trailing P/E of 79x, and exposure to discretionary consumer spending. Recent insider activity was largely RSU grants at $0.0, not open-market buying. The assets are iconic, but they generate no income for shareholders.
1. Smucker
J.M. Smucker (NYSE: SJM) is the cleanest fit for a retirement portfolio in this trio. The brand stable includes Folgers, Dunkin’, Café Bustelo, Jif, Uncrustables, Smucker’s, Hostess, Milk-Bone, and Meow Mix. The company is a consumer-staples and pet-food cash machine that has been hated since the Hostess deal, precisely the kind of dislocation Rogers looks for.
Q4 FY2026 results were strong. Adjusted EPS of $2.77 beat the $2.64 estimate, net sales rose 5.8% to $2.27 billion, and free cash flow reached $483.9 million, up 61.9%. Full-year free cash flow hit $1.156 billion, up 41.6%. Management guided FY2027 adjusted EPS to $9.75 to $10.25. CEO Mark Smucker said the company is “entering fiscal year 2027 with meaningful momentum.”
For retirees, the income case is decisive. Smucker pays a $4.40 annual dividend yielding 3.8%, backed by a 27-plus-year quarterly payment history and steady raises (from $0.88 per quarter in 2020 to $1.10 in 2026). Beta is just 0.264, forward PE is 12x, and shares closed at $115.89 on June 29, 2026. Risks include Sweet Baked Snacks weakness (−5% in Q4), prior Hostess impairments, and recent post-vesting CEO disposal of roughly 25,677 shares near $115 in mid-June 2026. But the dividend, low volatility, and recurring grocery-aisle demand are exactly what a retiree’s portfolio needs.
The Rogers Playbook, Filtered for Retirement
John Rogers’ patience pays best when the underlying business is durable enough that time is a friend. All three names fit some part of the contrarian template, but only Smucker pairs the unloved valuation with the income reliability and low beta that a retiree actually needs. Envista and MSG Entertainment can reward patient holders, yet without dividends and with higher cyclicality, they belong in the growth sleeve, not the income sleeve. For a retirement-focused investor seeking Rogers-style contrarian exposure, Smucker is the one that lets the tortoise win.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.
Top Gaining Stocks
Top Losing Stocks