Holders of the YieldMax MSTR Option Income Strategy ETF (NASDAQ:MSTY) bought into a story about triple-digit headline yields funded by option premiums on MicroStrategy. The appeal is real: MSTY sends cash every week, and at one point, the trailing yield printed around 222.83%. The problem is the payout has followed the underlying down. MSTY’s weekly distribution has slid from a historical $4.42 to $0.22, and the share price is $12.61 after a 68.38% one-year decline. The same covered-call structure exists in a version built on 50 blue chips instead of one volatile stock, and it has behaved very differently.
Why MSTY Keeps Bleeding
A single equity is what MSTY writes calls against, using synthetic exposure. When MicroStrategy fell roughly 74% to 75%, the fund captured all of the downside and then capped the rebound on the way back up. The 1.03% expense ratio and ordinary income tax treatment on distributions only compound the drag. Distributions look large in percentage terms largely because the denominator, net asset value, has collapsed. Year-to-date, MSTY is down 30.88% in price.
What BIGY Does Differently
The YieldMax Target 12 Big 50 Option Income ETF (NYSEARCA:BIGY) uses the same YieldMax option-income playbook but spreads it across the 50 largest U.S. companies, combining synthetic long exposure, covered-call writing, and Treasuries as collateral. The stated annual income target is 12%, with monthly distributions and a current yield near 11.99%. The expense ratio is 0.99%, four basis points below MSTY.
The mechanism that matters is the diversification of the option overlay. Instead of one ticker driving 100% of premium and 100% of drawdown risk, BIGY’s biggest position is NVIDIA at 6.33%, followed by Apple at 6.15%, Alphabet at 5.63%, and Amazon at 5.47%. When any single name breaks, the rest of the basket keeps generating premium. NVIDIA alone posted Q1 FY2027 revenue of $81.615 billion, up 85.23% year over year, including $75.246 billion in data center revenue. That kind of underlying does not need double-digit dividends to justify the call premium; implied volatility on names like NVIDIA and Apple does the work.
Behavior Through the Same Market
Since December 31, 2025, BIGY is up 7.44% in price while paying monthly distributions in the $0.49-$0.54 range. Over one year, it is up 18.04%. Trailing 12-month distributions total $6.511427, with forward annualized income of $6.2844. Coverage from the fund’s one-year anniversary noted that BIGY had outperformed JEPI and SPYI on cumulative total returns. The option-income wrapper is the same; the denominator is different.
The Tradeoffs
Risk is not absent from BIGY either. The covered call overlay still caps upside when mega caps rip, and so far this year Alphabet is up 14.44% while Amazon has gained 17.95%, with BIGY holders capturing only a fraction of those moves. Distributions are variable and taxed largely as ordinary income. Fund assets remain modest at $26.1 million, which can widen bid-ask spreads. And a broad market drawdown would hit all 50 names at once, even if none of them behave like MSTR.
How to Think About a Swap
In a taxable account, selling MSTY at a loss may create a usable capital loss to offset gains elsewhere; wash-sale rules would not apply to a purchase of BIGY given the different underlying. In an IRA, the switch is mechanically simpler. Position sizing matters more than the choice of ticker. An option-income ETF functions as a yield sleeve, and 11.99% distributions still leave room for principal loss in a bad market.
Where This Leaves You
Concentration is the structural flaw in MSTY, and BIGY addresses that issue without abandoning the covered call income model. The swap preserves monthly cash flow at a similar headline yield, slightly reduces the expense ratio, and replaces one volatile underlying with a diversified mega-cap basket that has appreciated year-to-date. Whether that fits depends on whether the reader wanted exposure to MicroStrategy or the 12% distribution. If it were the distribution, BIGY would deliver the same target with materially less blow-up risk.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.
Top Gaining Stocks
Top Losing Stocks