Carvana Is Now Down 31% This Year: Is CVNA a Toxic Stock or Ready to Rally?
Carvana's record unit sales tell one story, but its shrinking profit per vehicle tells another. Before the third-quarter report drops, here is what bulls and bears are each watching to settle the debate.
The fastest-growing name in used-car retail has turned into one of the group’s weakest performers. Carvana (NYSE:CVNA | CVNA Price Prediction) stock is down 31% year to date (YTD) to $58.11 in afternoon trading, leaving it well behind its closest rivals. Selling used cars online and financing many of those purchases, Carvana depends on both vehicle margins and loan economics.
Meanwhile, CarMax (NYSE:KMX) stock is up 34% YTD to $51.70, a gain that runs opposite to the slide in Carvana stock. AutoNation (NYSE:AN) stock is down 23% YTD to $159.55, a smaller drop than Carvana stock has suffered. CarMax runs a store-based used-car business and AutoNation runs franchised new-car dealerships, which sets Carvana’s finance-heavy online model apart from both.
Carvana Lags Both Benchmark Funds
Two benchmark funds have held up far better than Carvana stock. The SPDR S&P Retail ETF (NYSEARCA:XRT) is up 3% YTD. This indicates that the softness of Carvana stock isn’t just a retail-specific problem. For a broader sector gauge, the SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust (NYSEARCA:SPY) is up 13% YTD.
The XRT retail fund counts AutoNation among its top holdings and still rose on the year. So, traders might wonder whether Carvana stock is due for a turnaround.
Profit Per Vehicle Drives the Bear Case
Carvana’s sales engine is still running hot. In Q2 2026, the company sold a record 197,325 retail units, up 38% year over year, while revenue reached $7.38 billion. Chief executive Ernie Garcia stated in the Q2 release that Carvana is “still just 1.5% of the U.S. automotive market.”
However, Carvana’s profit per vehicle is moving the other way. Each car Carvana sold in Q2 produced $412 less in total gross profit per unit (GPU) than a year earlier, and its adjusted earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization (EBITDA) margin fell to 10.4% from 12.4%. Rising benchmark interest rates also squeezed Carvana’s financing profit, a sore spot for a company carrying $4.85 billion in long-term debt.
At an industry conference in mid-August, Carvana’s chief financial officer pointed to loan pricing and vehicle reconditioning as the company’s drivers for profit in the back half of the year. That roadmap turns the Q3 2026 numbers into a direct check on management’s plan for Carvana.
Reconditioning Capacity Anchors the Bull Case
Early this month, Carvana added inspection and reconditioning capabilities at its ADESA Orlando site. More reconditioning capacity lets Carvana build inventory, and Garcia declared on the Q2 call: “When we grow inventory, any given customer is more likely to find a car they love and conversion goes up.” Higher conversion, under Carvana’s strategy, makes marketing dollars more efficient, while more cars closer to customers cut delivery times.
Carvana had 19 integrated ADESA sites after Q2, and its first full ADESA expansion is expected to produce vehicles in early 2027. The company lifted its full-year 2026 adjusted EBITDA guidance to $2.7 billion to $3 billion, compared with $2.24 billion in 2025.
Federal Trade Commission (FTC) guidance that requires competitors to fold mandatory dealer fees into advertised prices gives Carvana another edge, since Carvana doesn’t impose them. That shift supported Carvana’s retail GPU in Q2.
Longer term, Carvana aims to sell 3 million cars per year at a 13.5% adjusted EBITDA margin by 2030 to 2035. Such a target sits well above Carvana’s Q2 level.
Third-Quarter Report Puts Both Levers to the Test
Later this month, Carvana reports third-quarter results. The next test for Carvana is whether added reconditioning capacity and higher loan pricing lift profit per vehicle. Another decline in Carvana’s GPU could strengthen the dead-money argument, while steadier margins could support a bounce in Carvana stock.
Carvana stock has fallen far this year. Given that decline, investors should keep their position sizes moderate until Carvana’s third-quarter report arrives.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.
David Moadel is financial writer specializing in stocks, ETFs, options, precious metals, and Bitcoin. David has written well over 1,000 articles for leading online publications, helping investors understand markets, income strategies, and risk.His work has appeared in The Motley Fool, InvestorPlace, U.S. News & World Report, TipRanks, ValueWalk, Benzinga, Market Realist, TalkMarkets, Finmasters, 24/7 Wall St., and others.With a master’s degree in education, David has taught at the elementary, high school, and college levels. That teaching background shapes his writing style: clear, educational, and practical. David has also built a loyal social-media audience by providing trustworthy financial content on YouTube, X/Twitter, and StockTwits.
