General Mills Yields Nearly 7%. Is Its Dividend Safer Than Kraft Heinz or Smucker?

Packaged food stocks have spent years as the market’s forgotten corner, and that neglect has pushed yields high enough to catch any income investor’s eye. General Mills (NYSE:GIS | GIS Price Prediction) now yields 6.94%. A yield is just the payout divided by the price, though, and a falling stock can produce a big number as easily as a generous board can. General Mills and Kraft Heinz (NASDAQ:KHC) have held their dividends flat, while J.M. Smucker (NYSE:SJM) keeps raising its payout. Here is how each dividend holds up when safety does the ranking.

General Mills: An Ultra-High Yield Powered by a Sliding Stock

General Mills pays $0.61 per share each quarter, or $2.44 a year. The stock offers a 6.94% yield at a recent price of $34.15, clearing the 6% line for ultra-high-yield status. Shares are down 21.53% year-to-date and 23.87% over the past year. When a yield rises because the share price is falling, that is a warning sign (we laid out seven of those warning signs in a free dividend trap guide), and you should treat it as one.

Dividend Safety Check: Covered, but Leverage Runs Hot

On adjusted numbers, earnings cover the payout. Management confirmed fiscal 2027 adjusted EPS guidance of $3.00 to $3.20, which sits above the annual dividend, and expects free cash flow conversion of about 95% of adjusted after-tax earnings. Fiscal 2026 free cash flow was $1.626 billion. GAAP results look worse. Trailing diluted EPS is -$1.64 after a $1.75 billion goodwill and intangible impairment, mostly tied to North America Pet, plus a $1.032 billion valuation loss on the Brazil sale.

The balance sheet is the weak link. On the fiscal first-quarter call, CFO Kofi Bruce was asked whether leverage was above four times net debt to EBITDA. He answered, “Yeah, yeah, just a touch,” and said it will take “at least a couple years to work ourselves back to our target of three times net debt.” Buybacks already fell to $500 million in fiscal 2026 from $1.2 billion the year before, which shows the company is holding on to cash.

No one in this group can match its longevity. General Mills mentions its 127th consecutive year of uninterrupted dividends. The quarterly payout rose from $0.51 in 2021 to $0.61 in 2025, then stopped. Every payment declared since, including the one payable November 2, is $0.61. Paying without interruption and raising the payout are two separate promises, and right now General Mills is keeping only the first.

Bull Case: A Turnaround That Pays You to Wait

The stock trades at a forward P/E of 12 and sits closer to its 52-week low of $30.60 than to its high of $47.04. Management is targeting $750 million in fiscal 2027 cost savings as part of $3 billion by fiscal 2030. Share losses are also getting smaller: cereal share fell just 0.1 point in the first quarter, compared with a 0.9-point drop a year earlier. If volumes are steady, someone buying today locks in an ultra-high yield on a low price.

Key Risk: Inflation Eats the Cushion

Bruce expects fourth-quarter input cost inflation of “around 6%,” and adjusted operating profit is guided down 13% to down 8% in constant currency. With leverage already above target, further margin pressure would leave little room to restart dividend increases.

Kraft Heinz: Ultra-High Yield on a Dividend Frozen Since 2019

Kraft Heinz pays $0.40 per quarter, or $1.60 a year. That is a 6.38% yield at $24.88, high enough to count as ultra-high-yield. Recent price action has been better than at General Mills, with shares up 7.83% year to date. The longer view is the warning: the stock is down 54.89% over 10 years.

Dividend Safety Check: Cash Coverage Is Solid

Kraft Heinz raised its 2026 outlook to adjusted EPS of $2.03 to $2.09, above the annual dividend, and targets free cash flow conversion of about 110%. The cash is real. First-quarter free cash flow rose 58.9% to $766 million, against $474 million in cash dividends paid. That gap is the best evidence that the $0.40 is safe. The GAAP trailing EPS of -$3.06 reflects $7.4 billion in noncash second-quarter impairments on goodwill and intangibles.

Paying down debt is the priority. CFO Andre Maciel said the company “paid down $1.9 billion of debt in the quarter” and repaid another $1 billion after the quarter closed, adding, “Our balance sheet remains very strong.” Interest expense remains guided at about $890 million, which is a big cash drain.

The track record is the sore spot. Kraft Heinz cut its quarterly dividend from $0.625 to $0.40 starting in 2019. Every payment since, through the one paid September 25, has been exactly $0.40. Shareholders have not had a raise since the cut.

Bull Case: The Cheapest Earnings in the Group

Kraft Heinz has a forward P/E of 10 and a price-to-book ratio of 0.746, the lowest forward multiple of the three. It has beaten EPS estimates for five consecutive quarters, and CEO Steve Cahillane said Heinz is “back to growth” in the U.S. Emerging Markets sales rose 10.4% in the second quarter. On Mad Money, Jim Cramer said Kraft Heinz “has the best story” among the dividend stocks he reviewed, pointing to Cahillane’s record at Kellogg. The company also still has a $1.5 billion buyback authorization.

Key Risk: The Core Business Is Still Shrinking

Adjusted operating income in the North America segment fell 15.8% in the second quarter, and full-year constant currency adjusted operating income is guided down 16% to 18%. A dividend that hasn’t grown since 2019 is likely to stay frozen while the biggest segment keeps losing profit.

J.M. Smucker: A Smaller Yield Backed by Steady Raises

Smucker pays $1.12 per quarter, up from $1.10. Its trailing annual dividend is $4.42, for a 3.31% yield at $130.26. That is well short of ultra-high-yield territory, and for a good reason: the stock is up 37.23% year to date, and those price gains pulled the yield down.

Dividend Safety Check: Rising Cash, Falling Debt

Smucker raised fiscal 2027 adjusted EPS guidance to $10.50 to $11.00 from $9.75 to $10.25, far above the trailing dividend. It also lifted free cash flow guidance to about $1.1 billion from $1.0 billion, after fiscal 2026 produced $1.156 billion. First-quarter free cash flow was $337.3 million. GAAP charges skew the trailing P/E of 61, while the forward multiple is 12.

Leverage is heading the right way. Lower debt cut net interest expense by 18%, debt repayment is still a stated capital priority, and full-year interest expense is guided at about $335 million.

This is the only payout in the group that continues to grow. Smucker’s quarterly dividend records go back to 1999, and the history shows a higher payout in every calendar year from 2009 through 2026. The quarterly amount has risen from $0.88 in 2020 to $1.12 today.

Bull Case: Coffee and Uncrustables Carry the Load

U.S. Retail Coffee sales rose 13% to $807.8 million on volume gains at Dunkin’ and Café Bustelo. Uncrustables added volume, and cat food drove growth in Pet. Analysts lean positive, with 3 Strong Buy ratings, 7 Buy ratings, no Sell ratings, and a consensus target of $141.81. For an income investor, that means each raise is backed by brands that are actually growing.

Key Risk: Tariff Refunds Flatter the Numbers

First-quarter adjusted EPS of $3.24 included a $0.84 per share benefit from about $115.0 million in tariff refunds, and full-year guidance includes a net $0.60 per share benefit. The guidance assumes no new or changed tariffs, so a shift in trade policy could fell the earnings cushion.

Smucker’s Payout Looks Built to Last

General Mills pays the biggest check and has 127 years of continuous payments. Even so, a flat payout, leverage above target, and a falling stock make its ultra-high yield as much a warning as a reward. Kraft Heinz covers its dividend well with cash but hasn’t raised it since the 2019 cut. J.M. Smucker pays less today, yet it is the only one of the three still raising its dividend, with rising free cash flow and lower debt, making it the most durable packaged-food dividend here.

Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.