Jim Cramer Says Home Depot Beat but Gave a ‘Tepid’ Forecast. Why He Calls It a Rate Stock
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
Home Depot (NYSE:HD | HD Price Prediction) beat Wall Street’s expectations on Tuesday. Then it cut short the celebration with a full-year outlook that leaves little room for upside. The stock traded at $338.14 by noon, down 2.7% on the session. Jim Cramer addressed the split on CNBC. He walked through the divergence in the stock’s reaction: “Everything that I hear is good, but I will tell you, they did give you a forecast that was tepid.”
Checking Cramer’s Numbers Against the Report
Jim Cramer started with the metric he says matters most: “Same-store sales are the number that you use for this company, 2.2 versus 1.7.” He also said, “The earnings 3.86 versus 3.75.”
Home Depot’s third-quarter release backs up Cramer’s actual figures: comparable sales rose 2.2%, and adjusted EPS came in at $3.86. Consensus estimates put EPS at $3.84, which means the beat was 0.57%, a smaller margin than Cramer’s 3.75 suggests. Revenue of $43.40B also exceeded the $42.78B estimate and grew 4.95% year over year.
Same-store sales (or comps) count only stores that have been open at least a year, so new locations and acquisitions don’t balloon the number. Inside Cramer’s 2.2%, the comparable average ticket rose 3.0% to $93.09 while comparable transactions slipped 0.5% to 392.7M. Shoppers spent more per visit and came in slightly less often.
Why the Forecast Weighed on the Stock
In August, management guided for fiscal 2026 comps of flat to 2% growth[1] and adjusted EPS growth of approximately flat to 4%. The new outlook lands at about 1.4% comp growth and about 2.0% adjusted EPS growth from a $14.69 base. Gross margin guidance edged down to about 33.0% from approximately 33.1%[1]. Total sales growth of about 4.5% lands at the top of the prior range, but acquisitions such as GMS account for much of that gain. Third-quarter operating margin also contracted to 12.6% from 12.9%.
What Cramer Means by “Rate Stock”
Cramer grouped Home Depot with Lowe’s (NYSE:LOW): “No, it’s a rate stock, as is Lowe’s. And they are fabulous companies, but they don’t do as much business with contractors, which is where the pro money is for these guys when you can’t build.”
Mortgage rates determine how often homes change hands, and each sale tends to spark spending on paint, flooring and renovations. The 10-year Treasury yield, which mortgage rates follow, rose to 5.15%[2] on November 13 from 4.86% a week earlier. October existing-home sales, central to Cramer’s thesis, fell 5.5%[3] to an annualized 3.75M, the past year’s low. In August, management said: “We’ve seen housing turnover at these low levels for four years now.”[1]
Home Depot has spent on contractor business through SRS Distribution and GMS; in August, management expected cross-selling across those units to generate $400 million[1] this year. Pro spending still depends on construction activity, though, and housing starts fell 5.2%[4] in September.
New CEO and a Steady Dividend
Home Depot named Richard McPhail CEO effective November 23, 2026[5]. He said the company can “grow market share in a dynamic environment.” The quarterly dividend is $2.33 per share, which annualizes to $9.32 and yields 2.64%.
What Long-Term Investors Should Watch
The stock is up just 0.42% year to date and down 2.76% over five years, yet it still trades at a trailing P/E of about 25. That multiple assumes a housing recovery is coming. Management’s own read from August was that “there’s just no sign of an inflection point at this moment.”[1]
Using Cramer’s framing, watch the 10-year yield and mortgage rates first, since they drive everything below them, then track comparable transactions: Home Depot needs more customers coming through the door, and higher tickets alone can’t sustain growth. Finally, look for SRS and GMS to bring in more pro revenue. Execution looks solid heading into the CEO transition. For the stock to break out of its long flat stretch, rates will likely have to come down first.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.







