Target Pays the Higher Yield. Lowe’s Has Wall Street on Its Side. Which Wins for Retirees?
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
A retirement-focused investor might pick Lowe’s (NYSE:LOW | LOW Price Prediction) or Target (NYSE:TGT) right now. Target pays more, with a dividend yield of 2.9% compared with 2.2% for Lowe’s. Wall Street prefers Lowe’s, as about 71% of analyst ratings are Buy or Strong Buy, compared with Target’s 34% or so.
At its core, the comparison pits a discount retailer that sells everyday goods against a home improvement chain whose results follow the housing cycle. The two stocks compare on three points.
Dividend Income: Target Pays the Bigger Check
Yield is the annual dividend divided by the share price. Target’s forward dividend of $4.64 works out to about 2.9% of its $159 price. Lowe’s $5.00 comes to about 2.2% of $220.76. Lowe’s is raising its dividend faster. Its quarterly payout went from $1.20 to $1.25, an increase of about 4.2%. Target’s went up 1.8% to $1.16[1].
The payout ratio shows how much of earnings goes to dividends. For Lowe’s it is about 42% of trailing EPS of $11.83. For Target, it is about 48% of $9.63, and that EPS figure includes a one-time $1.65 per share[1] tariff refund. In Q2, Lowe’s generated $3.1 billion[2] in free cash flow and paid $673 million in dividends. Target’s finance chief said the company plans to build on its “more than 50-year record of annual increases.”[3] That streak puts Target in Dividend King territory. (We ranked ten of them by valuation in a free report here.) Lowe’s covers its dividend more comfortably, but a retiree living on dividends gets more cash today from Target. Target takes this round.
Business Stability: Target’s Momentum Beats Lowe’s Housing Drag
Comparable sales measure sales growth at stores and channels open at least a year. Target’s rose 5.6%[4] in Q1 and 3.8%[1] in Q2, after falling 2.6% in fiscal 2025. Management raised full-year guidance to about 5%[1] sales growth and adjusted EPS of $9.90 to $10.90.
Lowe’s revenue rose 8.3%[5] in Q2, helped by acquisitions. Comparable sales grew just 0.2%[5], and gross margin fell 77 basis points. The company lowered its guidance to the bottom of its earlier range: $92.0 billion in sales, flat comparable sales and adjusted EPS of about $12.25. Its chief executive said, “discretionary DIY demand remains under pressure.”[2] Lowe’s does keep more of each sales dollar, with an operating margin of 11.8% against Target’s 5.0%.
Lowe’s also has negative shareholders’ equity of about $7.4 billion. Shareholders’ equity, or book value, is what’s left after subtracting liabilities from assets. It turned negative because Lowe’s spent years buying back stock with cash and debt. On its own, that rarely puts a dividend at risk. Still, net debt of 3.54 times EBITDA leaves less room to absorb a long housing slump. Target wins on stability.
Valuation and Sentiment: Lowe’s Has More Room to Run
Target shares are up 59.2% year to date. Lowe’s shares are down 8.7% this year and 9.6% over five years. After that run, the two stocks trade at about the same forward P/E (share price divided by expected earnings): roughly 17 for each stock. Analysts’ average price target of $250.70 implies about 13.7% upside for Lowe’s. For Target, the $166.29 target implies about 5.2%. Analysts like Lowe’s growing business with professional contractors (its Pro segment) and its high returns on capital, and they see the stock as well placed for a housing recovery. Lowe’s wins this round.
Verdict: Target Is the Retiree’s Pick
Target comes out ahead in two of the three categories. It pays a higher yield, its sales are growing again, its guidance is rising, and it sells everyday goods people keep buying in a slowdown. That makes it the better fit for retirees who are drawing income now. Lowe’s suits investors with a decade or more ahead of them who can wait out the housing cycle in exchange for faster dividend growth and more analyst-projected upside.
Both companies are expected to report on November 18 before the market opens. For Target, watch whether comparable sales stay positive, what management says about the holiday season, and whether it keeps its EPS outlook of $9.90 to $10.90[1]. Weak sales in its home goods and apparel lines would undermine the conclusion.
For Lowe’s, management guided Q3 adjusted EPS to about 7%[2] below last year. Watch Pro customer demand and what the company says about housing. Holding the $12.25[5] full-year outlook would narrow Target’s lead.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.








