Intuit Plunged 53% Year-to-Date: This Wall Street Pro Says the Tax Software Titan Has Teeth, Predicting 60% Gains From Here
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
Intuit (NASDAQ:INTU | INTU Price Prediction) currently trades at $310.02, while Wall Street’s average price target sits at $408.86. That gap implies 31.9% upside.
Intuit runs TurboTax, QuickBooks and Credit Karma for consumers, small and mid-market businesses, and accountants. Its stock has lost half its value this year even though it keeps beating earnings estimates. That is why the gap draws attention. The most bullish analyst, Jefferies’ Brent Thill, has a $500.00 Buy target, which implies 61.3% gains.
Software Fears and Soft Guidance Wiped Out Half of Intuit’s Value
Intuit shares have fallen 52.54% year to date, from $653.16 to $310.02. A decline that far past 30% amounts to a full re-rating. The pressure started across the sector, as enterprise software multiples compressed on fears of AI disruption in seat and workflow software.
The latest earnings report made those fears worse. Revenue rose 12.1% to $4.354B[1], and non-GAAP EPS of $2.91 beat the $2.64 consensus. That was the sixth straight beat[1]. However, guidance for the current quarter calls for just 6-7%[1] revenue growth. Full-year revenue guidance also slipped to $23.081B-$23.365B[1] from an initial $23.279B-$23.512B[2]. TurboTax grew only 1%[1], and Credit Karma’s 9% growth fell short of internal expectations. Management blamed higher interest rates and a faster-than-anticipated shift toward AI-powered experiences[3]. Intuit also agreed to sell Mailchimp at about a third of its 2021 purchase price.
Most Analysts Still Back Intuit’s QuickBooks Engine
Bulls are focused on the business side. Global Business Solutions grew 15%[1] and Online Ecosystem revenue rose 20%. Intuit Enterprise Suite reached $177 million[3] in annualized revenue. QuickBooks, TurboTax and Credit Karma are now available inside ChatGPT and Claude[3].
Capital returns add support. Intuit bought back $1.5B[1] of stock last quarter and has $6.4B of authorization remaining. It plans to put all Mailchimp cash proceeds toward buybacks. At a forward P/E of 14, bulls see asymmetric upside if growth stabilizes.
Of 34 analysts, 5 rate Intuit Strong Buy, 15 Buy, 12 Hold, 1 Sell and 1 Strong Sell. Recent target changes have mostly been cuts. Jefferies lowered its target to $500.00 from $550.00 and Mizuho to $430.00 from $500.00. BMO reiterated $412.00. Wells Fargo, at $330.00, is among the more cautious. Tax season and the Mailchimp sale, expected to close in early calendar 2027, are the next tests.
Intuit Fell Alone While Tax and Payroll Peers Rose
Intuit’s peers are higher this year, so the selloff is specific to Intuit.
H&R Block (NYSE:HRB) is up 10.22% year to date. At $46.46 against a $53 target, it has 14.1% upside. Analysts are split, with one Strong Buy, three Holds and one Sell.
ADP (NASDAQ:ADP) has gained 19.69% and trades at $301.19. That is above its $298.27 target, implying roughly 1% downside. Holds lead with 11, against four Buys.
Paychex (NASDAQ:PAYX) is up 3.75% at $111.40. Against a $114.57 target, it has 2.8% upside, and analysts mostly rate it Hold, with 15 Holds.
Intuit has the largest analyst-implied upside in the group by a wide margin. Targets are opinions, and much of that gap reflects how far the price fell.
Intuit Lags a Rising S&P 500 by a Wide Margin
Intuit trades at $310.02. Its average target from 34 analysts is $408.86, implying 31.9% upside. Its 52-week range runs from $250.56 to $672.79.
Intuit is down 52.54% year to date and 8.86% over the past week. The S&P 500 is up 4.97% year to date and down 5.45% over the past week.
Intuit Looks Cheap if This Tax Season Delivers
The bull case strengthens if QuickBooks keeps growing near 19%[1], Sign & File wins assisted filers this tax season, and Mailchimp proceeds shrink the share count. That would support non-GAAP EPS guidance of $22.88-$23.12[1] and a move back toward the low $400s.
The bear case strengthens if Credit Karma keeps losing traffic to AI platforms, government encroachment in tax pressures TurboTax, and guidance keeps getting cut. In that case, the low multiple becomes a value trap.
I lean modestly bullish. The business side is healthy and buybacks are aggressive. Still, the consumer business needs a strong tax season before the $500.00 target looks realistic.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.







