Everyone Talks About Retiring to a Small Town. Nobody Talks About the Retirees Who Moved to a Big-City Apartment and Sold the Car

Most retirement stories that involve a move point toward a small town, a quiet road, and a bigger yard. A smaller group of retirees goes the other way.

They sell the house, rent an apartment in a dense city, and give up the car, handling daily errands on foot and reaching medical appointments by bus. This piece looks at what that trade actually costs, where it saves money, and where the numbers stop working.

What the Car and the House Were Quietly Costing

AAA’s latest Your Driving Costs study puts the average cost of owning and operating a new vehicle at $12,863 a year. That figure assumes 75,000 miles over five years, so a retiree who drives less will spend somewhat less on gas and wear. Insurance, registration, and depreciation don’t shrink much with fewer miles, though.

A paid-off house still sends bills. A Zillow Group (NASDAQ:Z | Z Price Prediction) and Thumbtack study put the hidden costs of homeownership at $15,979 a year, including $2,003 for homeowners’ insurance, $3,030 for property tax and $10,946 for maintenance.

Together, a mortgage-free suburban house plus one new car runs about $28,842 a year before utilities or food.

Where City Rent Lands Against That Number

Zumper’s latest national report puts the median one-bedroom rent at $1,519 a month nationally, $2,180 in Chicago and $4,610 in New York City. Over a full year, that comes to about $18,228, $26,160 and $55,320. A Chicago one-bedroom comes in a bit under the house-and-car figure.

A Manhattan-style budget lands far above it. Chicago’s one-bedroom rent also rose 12.4% year over year, so a lease renewal can quickly change the math.

The city brings costs a house doesn’t. Condo and co-op buildings charge monthly fees, apartments are smaller, and noise is part of the deal, while stairs in walk-up buildings can become a problem later in life, so some renters choose elevator buildings at higher rent. In exchange, there’s no roof to replace, and no yard to maintain, and major hospitals and specialists are usually close by.

Transit helps cover the gap left by the car. Agencies that receive federal Section 5307 funding must offer half fare or reduced fare to people with disabilities and seniors during off-peak hours. The provision applies to persons with Medicare cards.

Selling the House Without a Medicare Surprise

A seller can exclude up to $250,000 of gain, or $500,000 on a joint return, if the home was owned and used as a principal residence for 2 years or more during the 5-year period before the sale. Long-time owners in expensive areas can exceed that cap, and the extra gain counts as income.

That income can show up again in Medicare premiums. Medicare figures its income-based surcharge from tax returns filed two years earlier. Part B’s standard premium runs $202.90 a month, but joint filers with modified adjusted gross income above $218,000 pay $284.10, and the top tier reaches $689.90 per person.

A one-time house sale can raise premiums for both spouses two years after the move, so the sale’s timing affects premiums in a later year.

State income taxes also factor into the cost of the move. New York lets residents age fifty-nine and one-half and older exclude up to $20,000 of pension and IRA distributions, calculated separately for each spouse on a joint return.

Running the Numbers on a Chicago Apartment

The average retired couple who both collect Social Security receives $3,208 a month, or about $38,496 a year. After a median Chicago one-bedroom, about $12,336 is left for food, utilities, Medicare premiums, transit, and everything else.

Each extra $10,000 of annual spending takes about $250,000 in savings at a 4% withdrawal rate. Proceeds from the house sale often fill that role. At New York rents, the same couple would need far more savings, or a smaller apartment in a cheaper neighborhood.

Some retirees test the idea before they sell. They rent a furnished apartment for a month in the off-season and walk the routes to the grocery store, the pharmacy, and the doctor. That month shows whether the neighborhood works in daily life, and a short rental costs less than reversing a home sale.

Comparing the Car Bill With the City Bill

Owning a new car costs about $12,863 a year. The city’s extra cost is rent and building fees, minus the house expenses that disappear after the sale; in Chicago, the car savings plus the end of maintenance about cover the rent. In New York, they cover only a fraction, and the move generally requires a large portfolio or a large home equity gain.

Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.