Everyone Talks About Retiring Somewhere New. Nobody Talks About the Retirees Who Went Back to Their Hometown and Never Looked Back

Some people approaching retirement consider moving back to the hometown they grew up in. That option gets less attention in “move somewhere new” headlines.

Plenty of people spent their careers in expensive metro areas because that’s where the jobs were, and some still have family ties there. That is why it’s so important to look at what it costs to move back.

Why Going Home Can Cost So Much Less

Many hometowns are in states where living costs run well under the national average. The Bureau of Economic Analysis gives Arkansas a cost-of-living index of 86.937, where 100 is the national average. Mississippi comes in at 86.953 and Iowa at 87.762. California stands at 110.72.

Price is only part of the appeal, though. Old friends, family, a church or club, familiar roads, and nearby relatives can help as the years add up.

A rough estimate uses national spending data. The average U.S. family spent $81,905 in 2025, according to the BLS Consumer Expenditure Survey. Adjusted to Arkansas prices, that comes to about $71,200 a year. At California prices, it’s about $90,700.

A retired couple where both spouses collect Social Security averages $3,208 a month after the 2026 COLA, or $38,496 a year.

That’s a gap of roughly $482,000 in required savings. Someone retiring in their early 60s who wants a tighter 3.5% withdrawal rate would need about $935,000 at hometown prices. The BLS figure averages across all households, so a paid-off house pulls it down and a mortgage pushes it up.

Medicare Part B by itself costs $202.90 a month per person in 2026, or about $4,870 a year for a couple. Income taxes on withdrawals also belong in the budget. Social Security goes up 3.6% in 2027.

Selling the Old House Without Losing the Tax Break

For many people, selling the house pays for the move. Federal law lets homeowners exclude up to $250,000 of gain on a main home, or $500,000 for married couples filing jointly.

To qualify, the seller must have owned the home and lived in it as their main residence for at least 2 years during the 5-year period before the sale, under 26 U.S.C. § 121(a). That timing requirement affects when to sell.

Plenty of people who move home rent out the old place in case things don’t work out. If they stay away so long that they no longer have 2 years of living there within the last 5, the exclusion is gone, and the whole gain is taxable.

National home prices are up 2.1% year over year on the Case-Shiller index, so equity in an expensive market keeps building while that window gets shorter.

Taxes and Medicare Across State Lines

Moving to another state changes how retirement income gets taxed. Eight states have no income tax: Alaska, Florida, Nevada, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Washington, and Wyoming. Only a handful of states still tax Social Security, and most of those offer income-based exemptions.

Pensions and IRA withdrawals are treated differently from one state to the next, so the treatment depends on the destination state’s own rules.

Original Medicare lets enrollees use any doctor or hospital that takes Medicare, anywhere in the U.S., while the private plans operate through local networks and service areas.

Enrollees who move out of their plan’s service area get a Special Enrollment Period that lasts for 2 full months after you move. Enrollees who don’t choose a new plan in that time are placed in Original Medicare when the old plan ends coverage.

When Home Has Changed Over the Years

A hometown may have changed since a retiree last lived there. Friends move away or pass on. Old family dynamics can return. Health care in a small town can be thinner, with specialists a long drive away. Some retirees test the move by spending a few weeks there in different seasons, reconnecting with people before committing, and renting before buying.

What It Takes to Make the Move Work

For a couple receiving typical Social Security, a hometown priced like Arkansas works on roughly $818,000 to $935,000 in savings, drawn down at 3.5% to 4% a year. That 4% figure comes from research done in a very different market, and we laid out the case for an income-first approach in a free guide here.

You can hold those savings in a mix of index funds, dividend ETFs, and Treasury securities. Selling the old house inside the 2-of-5-year window, with the gain tax-free, can cover part of that. Some people visit during an average week, outside the holiday season. That timing gives a closer view of daily life in the town.

Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.