A Retired Couple in the 12% Bracket Pays 0% on Stock Gains. Sell Gold Coins or Baseball Cards Instead and the 0% Rate Is Gone
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
A retired couple filing jointly with modest taxable income can sell appreciated stock and owe no federal tax on the gain. If they sell gold coins or a binder of vintage baseball cards for the same profit, the gain is taxed. With gold spot near $3,723.94 an ounce, many retirees now hold coin profits large enough to change their tax bill.
How a 12% Bracket Couple Reaches the 0% Rate
For tax year 2025, the IRS sets the 12% bracket for joint filers at taxable income from $23,851 to $96,950. Publication 550 sets a 0% maximum capital gain rate for joint filers with taxable income of $0 to $96,700. Taxable income is counted after the standard deduction, which for joint filers in 2025 is $31,500 under the One, Big, Beautiful Bill.
This rule stems from 26 U.S.C. § 1(h)(1)(B). It applies “0 percent”[1] to adjusted net capital gain that fits under the taxable income that would otherwise be taxed below 25%. To count as long-term, an asset must be held “more than 1 year”[2] under § 1222(3).
Why Gold Coins and Baseball Cards Miss the Zero Rate
Section 1(h)(3)(A)(ii) removes “28-percent rate gain”[1] from adjusted net capital gain, and § 1(h)(4)(A)(i) puts “collectibles gain” in that group. Section 1(h)(5)(A) ties collectibles gain to section 408(m) “without regard to paragraph (3) thereof.”[1] Section 408(m)(2) lists works of art, rugs, antiques, metals, gems, stamps, coins, alcoholic beverages and “any other tangible personal property specified by the Secretary.”[3]
Collectibles gain is taxed at ordinary rates, capped at 28%. Publication 550 says: “If you are otherwise subject to a rate lower than 28%, the 28% rate does not apply.” For a couple in the 12% bracket, that means gold coin gain is taxed at 12%, the same rate as an IRA withdrawal. Any part of the gain that pushes taxable income above $96,950 is taxed at 22%.
Baseball cards need one more check. Sports cards aren’t named in the statute, so whether they count turns on the catch-all for other tangible personal property and on how the cards are classified. Ask a tax preparer to confirm the category before you assume a rate. Many other items, such as vehicles, firearms, farm equipment, fossils and real estate, generally fall outside § 408(m) and follow their own rules.
Gold in an IRA Follows a Separate Rule
Some precious metals can be held inside an IRA. Section 408(m)(3) exempts certain gold coins described in 31 U.S.C. § 5112(a), silver coins under § 5112(e), platinum coins under § 5112(k), “a coin issued under the laws of any State,”[3] and gold, silver, platinum or palladium bullion whose fineness complies with contract-market requirements, “if such bullion is in the physical possession of a trustee.” For anything that does count as a collectible, Publication 590-A says the amount a traditional IRA invests is “considered distributed to you in the year invested.”
That exception covers IRA investing only. Section 1(h)(5)(A) specifically skips paragraph (3), so an eligible gold coin bought in a taxable brokerage or safe-deposit box and later sold at a profit still produces collectibles gain. The same coin can be a permitted IRA asset under one rule and a collectible under the other.
A Large Coin Sale Can Push Stock Gains Out of 0%
The order in which income is counted matters. Under § 1(h)(1)(B), the 0% rate covers adjusted net capital gain only up to the room left below the 25% line after counting “taxable income reduced by the adjusted net capital gain.”[1] Because collectibles gain is excluded from adjusted net capital gain, it is counted first, along with pensions, IRA withdrawals and taxable Social Security. A large coin sale can use up the space below $96,700, which pushes stock gains that would have been tax-free into the 15% rate.
Medicare Premiums Can Rise After the Sale
For 2026, CMS sets the basic Part B premium at $202.90[4] a month. Joint filers with income up to $218,000[4] pay no surcharge. Above that, up to $274,000[4], the Part B surcharge (called IRMAA) is $81.20, bringing the premium to $284.10 a month, plus a Part D surcharge of $14.50. These surcharges are based on income reported on a prior return. So a one-time sale of a large coin hoard or card collection can push a couple who normally falls well below these lines into higher Medicare premiums in a later year.
Questions to Answer Before Selling
- Which rules apply? Confirm whether the item is a § 408(m) collectible and whether you have held it more than one year before assuming any rate.
- What is the cost basis? Purchase records set the size of the gain. Inherited items follow separate basis rules.
- Can the sale be spread across tax years? Selling pieces in different years keeps more of each year’s income inside the 12% bracket and below the Medicare surcharge lines.
- What other income lands in the same year? Required distributions, Roth conversions and stock sales all compete for the same room below $96,700.
- Which assets should use the low-income room? In a year when stock gains could be taxed at 0%, a collectibles sale costs twice: ordinary-rate tax on the coins plus lost 0% room for the stocks.
The thresholds above are for tax year 2025. The IRS’s 2026 schedule starts the joint 12% bracket at income over $24,800 and the 22% bracket at income over $100,800. Check the current Publication 550 table for the matching 0% threshold before planning when to sell. The collectibles trap is one of several IRS rules that quietly drain retirement accounts, and we detailed the rest in a free guide.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.








