She Retired From Teaching In 2001 With $725,000. Two Bear Markets In Eight Years Took Nearly Half Of Her Portfolio, And She Had To Go Back To The Classroom. Here’s What Every Retiree Needs To Know About Sequence Of Returns Risk
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
Near-retirees keep coming back to one question: what happens if the crash arrives right after I stop working? One retired teacher’s first decade shows why the order of returns matters as much as their average. It also shows what retirees can put in place before the next bad stretch.
Two Bear Markets in One Teacher’s First Eight Years
Business Insider identified Sharon by her middle name only. She retired from teaching in 2001 after a divorce and her parents’ deaths, worked temporary jobs in the 2000s and put much of her inheritance in the market. Business Insider gathered her story through a voluntary reader survey of over 1,700 Americans aged 48 to 90.
Jade Scipioni of Fox Business dated the dot-com bear market from March 2000 to October 2002, with a 49% peak-to-trough S&P 500 loss. That means Sharon retired in the middle of it. Jade Scipioni put the financial-crisis bear market, October 2007 to March 2009, at a 57% peak-to-trough loss. It arrived in her eighth calendar year of retirement, including 2001.
Noah Sheidlower reported that when the market crashed in 2008, Sharon lost nearly half of her $725,000 in assets, the balance she had when the crash hit. Business Insider’s account leaves open whether she lost money in the dot-com slide or was taking withdrawals in 2008, and it captures the fear that came after: “I became very afraid of the stock market, afraid of what to do, not trusting the advice I was getting from people,” she said, recalling “making a lot of bad financial decisions.”
Why the Order of Returns Can Matter as Much as the Average
Charles Schwab (NYSE:SCHW | SCHW Price Prediction) defines sequence-of-returns risk plainly: the order and timing of poor investment returns can have a big impact on how long retirement savings last. If you pull out during a slump, you are selling shares at low prices, and those shares are gone before the recovery. Sharon’s story shows that lesson. Business Insider did not name what caused her shortfall.
Rob Williams of Schwab showed the effect with two hypothetical investors:
| Hypothetical | Investor 1 | Investor 2 |
|---|---|---|
| Starting portfolio | Williams: $1 million | Williams: $1 million |
| Initial withdrawal | Williams: $50,000 | Williams: $50,000 |
| Annual inflation adjustment | Williams: 2% | Williams: 2% |
| Correct | Williams: 15% losses in first two years, then 6% | Same decline, later in retirement |
| Outcome | Williams: depleted in roughly 18 years | Williams: Nearly $400,000 left after 18 years |
Aswath Damodaran’s NYU Stern data shows how deep Sharon’s era went. These are calendar-year S&P 500 total returns including dividends, which measure something different from the peak-to-trough correct above.
| Period | Total Return (Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern) |
|---|---|
| 2001 | Damodaran: -11.85% |
| 2002 | Damodaran: -21.97% |
| 2001 to 2002 combined | -31.22% |
| 2008 | Damodaran: -36.55% |
| 2009 | Damodaran: 25.94% |
The rebound year’s gain was smaller than the crash year’s loss, and it applied to a smaller balance. Anyone who sold in fear also missed that recovery.
Building a Cushion Before the Next Downturn
Rob Williams suggested keeping a year’s worth of expenses in cash investments, after accounting for other income sources, plus two to four years’ worth in high-quality short-term bonds. That reserve can pay the bills through a downturn so stocks don’t have to be sold at low prices. Schwab also suggests cutting back withdrawals and spending in down years and avoiding selling when the market is down. These steps give the market time to recover, though they cannot eliminate losses. A bad market in retirement’s opening years does more damage than one later on, which is the whole subject of our free guide on defending the first five years.
A fee-only fiduciary planner can help design a withdrawal plan and choose a claiming age. That means an adviser paid only by the client and legally required to act in the client’s interest. Sharon wished she’d had one: “If only someone had just said, do not take Social Security early, do not invest your money this way. If I had somebody who would have just really directed me, maybe I wouldn’t be in this horrible situation.”
What Claiming Early Locked In for Life
Noah Sheidlower, who profiled Sharon at 77, reported that she took Social Security at 62 instead of waiting until 67. SSA’s table, though, sets full retirement age at 66 for people born 1943 to 1954, the range her age means. Taking that early contracts the benefit by 25.00%. Noah Sheidlower reported a monthly check of $936. Working back from that check with SSA’s reduction gives an estimated full-retirement-age benefit of about $1,248. Treat that as rough, since her birth and taking months were not reported. Health problems and home damage have stretched the check, and Noah Sheidlower reported she had under $100,000 in liquid assets at the time.
Protect the First Years Before Chasing Returns
If you’re retired or close to it, start with your annual spending minus Social Security and any pension. Rob Williams’ framework calls for holding a year’s worth of that gap in cash and two to four years’ worth in high-quality short-term bonds. In down markets, that framework draws on the reserve instead of selling stocks. Decide ahead of time that you’ll cut withdrawals when markets fall. Treat taking age as permanent: Sharon’s estimated 25.00% reduction never goes away. A strong long-run average can’t save a portfolio that was sold at the bottom. Business Insider reported Sharon’s own warning about why she keeps working: “because, by 2030, I easily will run out of money.”
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.








